• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Does Quinton offer a compelling defence of the claim that it is the continuity of psychological characteristics that that is crucial to being the same person?

Extracts from this document...


Friday, March 08, 2002 Tayrin mehmet Does Quinton offer a compelling defence of the claim that it is the continuity of psychological characteristics that that is crucial to being the same person? In the first section of Quinton's essay Quinton describes the theory of the soul and spiritual substance. The soul is described in two ways, vitality that distinguishes human beings and as a seat of consciousness. The second explanation, which Quinton is concerned about, tends to be identified with the view that in each person there tends to be found a spiritual substance, which is the subject of his mental state and the bearer of his personal identity. Quinton's explains the nonphysical aspects of a person identity not need involve a spiritual substance and can be supported solely on the bases of a person's mental state that makes up a person inner conscious life. Quinton's view is that spiritual substance is logically distinct from it being the criteria for personal identity. If the spiritual substance is permanent and unchanging it must be useless for the purpose of personal identification. We need differentiate between spiritual substance and psychological characteristics before we can go any further. ...read more.


I would say that there is more to a person then a set of characteristics and memory and that the spirit of a person is a faculty which is crucially identifiable. The mental and bodily criteria of identity Many philosophers have insisted that the basic and indispensable criteria of human identity is bodily. This form of identification has a number of virtues mainly it is simple and is used most commonly and successfully. The fact is that a person can be both identified by physical appearance and metal characteristics. But it could be said that bodily identification is not a complete form of identification, at best a necessary condition of personal identity. Sentimental relationships that wouldn't survive a change of body may be rejected because they lack any substance. The continuation of a person must be base on there mental characteristics. Disembodiment If it where possible to remove a brain from a dead person and fix it into a manufactured body which as a result become perfectly active we would have to assume that the dead person is no longer dead. Does William offer a compelling argument against Quinton's claims? ...read more.


The presents of emotions not consisting solely on memory is a strong enough argument for me to say that there is something other to identity then consistency of characteristics and memory suggested by Quinton. Quinton ideas of the soul may need more explanation as although he does not doubt its existence he questions its importance in the identification process. From my understanding of both Quinton's and Williams arguments I would have to say that there is definitely some relating factors that do suggest the presence of a soul, but whoever I would have to agree with the fact that there is more to the a person then just their characteristics and memory. The importance of the body or some physical connection to our soul may point to our underlying sentimental hung up of material things. I agree that the identification of a human does not necessarily relay on their physical attributes and that a person can solely be identified by their characteristics but I would have to argue that there is something consistently identifiable at birth, and that this may be present throughout life. I would describe this as spiritual a substance the seat of consciousness. There is more to a person then their ever changing psychological characteristics and this is inevitable consistent and identifiable. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Reviews of Personal Performances section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Reviews of Personal Performances essays

  1. Explore Carl Rogers core conditions and how these effect the personality change in a ...

    1961:61. I feel a major turning point happened two thirds of the way through my own therapy. I talked of a particularly very painful incident in my life. My therapist allowed me to talk, be angry, to be whatever I wanted to be.

  2. In Scott Russell Sanders "The Inheritance of Tools," the first person narrator explains the ...

    but he doesn't lose his temper or even break down and cry. Instead, he went back to work and made sure it was done perfectly. The relationship he had with his father was very important, but the character his father taught him was what guided him through his troubles.

  1. In this essay I will explore Carl Rogers core conditions and how these effect ...

    It felt good to feel worthy and on the same level with someone who cared about me, they accepted my issues without any judgment or conditions. This made me feel safe enabling me to voice my thoughts and feelings knowing that I was being accepted for who I am, with no "ifs 'or' buts"s.

  2. Describe two of the following psychological approaches: the psychodynamic perspective, the cognitive perspective, the ...

    Oral-sensory deals with the events that help a child to bond with a caregiver. This is the time when a baby and mother form a bond by spending time together and learn to love each other. Muscular-anal is the time when a child is developing and learning basic life actions.

  1. In this essay I will be looking at two books based on Carl Rogers ...

    One example is a client, "Mary was 45 yr old, who didn't look after herself, her hair was unwashed, her clothes were old and a mixture of dark and grey and she also smelled" (Mearns and Thorne 2001:68-69). At the end of both the first two sessions Mary would say,

  2. Childhood Memories

    Where as in Anorexia most of whole cast were teenagers as it is mostly the young adults and teens, with a mother who is very interested in the care of her child and there was also some multi-role playing with the bullies which were just minor cameo roles.

  1. We had to create a tableaux image of the four strong words in the ...

    Our fourth scene, learning to ride a bike, showed Eliot learning to ride a bike, being taught by Georgina whilst the rest of us played parents and other adults watching him learn. I played the father of Eliot and we all cheered when he rode the bike on his own.

  2. Josephine believes that there is a difference between visual and aural memory - She ...

    Test 2 The second test that I will do is the aural test. In this test I will tell the same twenty people to listen to me reading the 10 words, trying to remember as much words as they can.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work