• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Flight/Your Shoes: A comparitive essay

Extracts from this document...


Justin Liu Maine A English AXS Flight/Your Shoes In this essay I will be comparing 'Flight' by Doris Lessing and 'Your Shoes' by Mich´┐Żle Roberts. The content and style for both stories are similar in some ways and different in other ways. For example, the main problem in both stories is the daughter leaving home for the first time. Another example of a difference is 'Flight' is written in third-person whereas 'Your Shoes' is written as an interior monologue. The difficulties about the daughters leaving are: in 'Flight', the grandfather is reluctant to let his granddaughter go off and marry. This is because she is his favourite granddaughter and his last. 'He confronted her, his eyes narrowed, shoulders hunched, tight in a hard knot of pain which included the preening birds, the sunlight, the flowers. He said: "Think you're old enough to go courting, hey?"' He also does not like Steven, the postmaster's son, and is maybe jealous of him and how he can win over his granddaughter better than he can himself. ...read more.


'If I wrap my arms around myself and hold tight it keeps the pain in. Stops it spilling out and making a terrible mess. If I keep my mouth pursed tight I can't scream or throw up. If I imagine that you're gone for good, that you'll never come back, then this terrible wailing sound will begin and never stop, I might go mad.' Just as in 'Flight', the mother tries to appeal for her daughter to come home, this time, however, through her mind. In 'Flight', what I think the author wants to say is the idea about the problems of letting young people grow up and leave home. This sometimes can be quite hard for some adults just as it is for the grandfather. The story is written in third person and let us see everyone's point of view as well as the grandfather's. '"You never liked it when we married," she said. "Why not? Every time, it's the same. When I got married you made me feel like it was something wrong." ...read more.


'It seemed to the old man that the whole afternoon had stilled to watch his gesture of self-command, that even the leaves of the trees had stopped shaking.' In 'Your Shoes', the way the author makes me respond to this situation is the opposite seems to happen compared to 'Flight', the Justin Liu Maine A English AXS Flight/Your Shoes (cont...) mother's condition clearly gets worse and lapses into madness at the end. 'Laces like strings of white liquorice. They taste sweet.' Again there is the symbolism of the shoes and again it represents the way the mother would like her daughter to be. I prefer 'Flight' to 'Your Shoes' because the story is much clearer and you get to see everyone's point of view whereas in 'Your Shoes' the storyline is not so clear and harder to understand because only one person is speaking. However, 'Flight' has less detail than 'Your Shoes' because there are many more people to focus on. For example, in 'Your Shoes' you know who is still alive and who is not whereas in 'Flight' it is not as clear. However, I enjoyed both stories and thought that they had more similarities than differences. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Reviews of Personal Performances section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Reviews of Personal Performances essays

  1. Matrimonial consent - in the eyes of the law.

    What is one to understand by lack of discretion of judgement? Our Marriage act contains a similar provision to this Canon, "A marriage shall be void if the consent of either of the parties is vitiated by a serious defect of discretion of judgment on the matrimonial life, or on its essential rights and duties...

  2. Homelessness production essay

    We felt our roles were very well suited and that we had the potential to make our performance very powerful. Our intensions when setting out to create our drama sketches were to raise awareness of the plight of homeless people and to raise money to help them.

  1. Tempest essay

    This wasn't the only time there were several times before Katie and I improvised so it could get us out of trouble. I believe tom speed's idea of blood pack on prospo was excellent but I think we should

  2. The statue of Ni-ka-re, His Wife and Their Daughter is one of the best ...

    The face lines of Ni-ka-re, his wife and daughter are clearer than those of Khentet-ka and her son. Besides, the figures of Ni-ka-re's family seem to be more refined and perfect. The shapes and muscles of their bodies look very natural and all this creates an impression that not the

  1. What Issues/Themes does the story 'Your Shoes' raise?

    'What do you expect? We were half out of our minds with worry, of course we were upset. I've always thought of you as an empty-headed blonde, I've never thought you were really bad.' Throughout these quotes her mother repeatedly insults and patronises her daughter, showing a great lack of respect for her.

  2. Compare how Doris Lessing and the writer of one other story in the selection ...

    When I came back " he swung me so high in the air that my hand grazed the ceiling". This quote proves my point that he was a nice and a powerful person. Moreover "Uncle Franc" really liked his nephew.

  1. In What Ways Are The Stories "Your Shoes" and "Flight" Said To Be Similar.

    There is selfishness in "Your Shoes" too but interpreted in a different way. The mother in the story talks mostly of the bad childhood she had with her mother instead of worrying about her daughter, e.g., "She loved you more than she loved me.

  2. Consider the representation of 'underdogs' in Silence by Moira Buffini, Kosher Harry by Nick ...

    It is these comments on women such as "The soul of women is an inferior thing, a dark shadow compared to the brilliant soul of a man" from Roger, Ethelred and other characters within the play that Moira Buffini has used in order to sway our allegiance towards Ymma who

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work