• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Macbeth - Polanski’s version and Bogdanov’s version

Extracts from this document...


Macbeth Polanski's version and Bogdanov's version In Act our Scene 1 we are confronted with many of the themes of the play, which have already been introduced. The themes of the play are the supernatural, blood, good & evil, light & dark ambition, loyalty, love, kingship, corruption, justice and deception. The themes I am concentrating on are the supernatural element of the play and the portrayal of Macbeth himself. The theme of the supernatural occurs very prominently in Polanski's version but isn't as prominent in Bogdanov's version, and the element of Macbeth himself is presented in both versions of Macbeth, but they are presented differently as you will see. The theme of the supernatural in Polanski's interpretation gives more depth to the interpretation of Shakespeare's Macbeth. The setting of this scene is a major factor in giving the interpretation, which Shakespeare himself wanted to portray, because of the older props and the witches who look the way witches were expected to look like in the days of Shakespeare. In Polanski's version, the scene is set in a dark cave, positioned on a hillside. Darkness is a major theme in the whole of Macbeth, and it is again shown here in the jet-black skies of the night with the only light coming from the cave the witches inhabit. The musical soundtrack of the film sends an eerie feeling through the scene. ...read more.


We are therefore made to feel, that while the witches control Macbeth in Polanski's version, Macbeth in Bogdanov's version is in control over his own fate, and has been taken over by his own ambition and madness. The physical destruction presented to us by the use of the wasteland is representing the breakdown of old order and the moral chaos that Macbeth's actions have inevitably created. Supernatural elements are also taken from Bogdanov's version by speeding up the pace of the speech. This speeding up in the pace is supposed to add to the audience's expectations, but I think it takes away from the anxiety built up in Polanski's version with the slower speech. In Bogdanov's version, the horror/tragedy effect is taken out of this scene mainly because of the exclusion of the supernatural element. The fact that this scene is presented as a dream tells us that it is Macbeth's own madness that is driving Macbeth to extremes and not the witch's potion, which causes Macbeth to actually live the experience of seeing his fate. The lack of colour in Bogdanov's version adds to the dreamy effect. The only colour comes from the red-orange colour of the raging flames coming from the oil drum (cauldron). Due to the scene being black and white, Bogdanov may be trying to represent that only 1 in 4 people actually dream in colour. ...read more.


The setting of the scene is a lot more open due to it being positioned on a wasteland, and the witches are less threatening than the witches in Polanski's version. From analysing and comparing each version, I can say that I like Polanski's version much more. This is due to his more realistic interpretation of Shakespeare's Macbeth. Everything in his scene is what I would expect it to be in Macbeth's time. Even though Bogdanov seems to be more faithful to the original play in terms of the words. Polanski re-arranges the order of lines in the play, to reflect the chaos in Scotland at that time. Both interpretations of Macbeth are true to the original in different ways. Polanski's version is truer to the original in it's setting, realism and how all the characters and not only Macbeth are portrayed. Bogdanov's version is truer to the original in the use of the original script of the play, even though some lines are taken out, and also the amount of witches is true to original. I think that what Bogdanov was trying to show was that Shakespeare's themes are not only relevant to the times of Shakespeare, but hey are also relevant to the modern age where war, evil and sin still occur. I prefer Polanski's version because of how much Bogdanov's versions in my mind has strayed from the original. Polanski's version in my opinion, gives a better insight in to what Macbeths time was like and also to what Macbeth himself was like. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Macbeth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Macbeth essays

  1. Nunn and Polanski's Versions of Macbeth - comparing the two versions.

    He displays this when the three witches have said all their lines from the first scene. To make them exit he scams past them and as the camera isn't viewing them one leaves. He does this two more times, as he turns away a witch exits, until all three are gone.

  2. Study and compare two different film interpretations of Act 4 Scene 1 of Shakespeare's ...

    be king, and also that he has limited time left to carry out his plans of murdering all of Banquo's descendants so he could be crowned king. Also playing in the background are spooky, high-pitched notes, which add to the suspense.

  1. Film Version of Macbeth Act 3, Scene 4 (the Banquet Scene).

    In the dining area, when John Finch actually sees the ghost, Francesca Annis doesn't appear to be doing a very good job of controlling the scene. Also, John Finch doesn't look as scared as you think he would be if there actually was a ghost there.

  2. What is Shakespeare's purpose for the witches in Macbeth?

    The third area was where the very rich went. They had a roof over their head as well as cushioned seats. If you wanted to watch the play from there you had to pay about 3d. Because the crowd were very impatient Shakespeare had to tell them when they were

  1. What part do the witches play in Shakespeare's Macbeth?

    I would not have the apparitions as just voices as I don't see them as being completely psychological. I would therefore have projections of images onto the stage, flickering, fading in and out and appearing in different places around the set.

  2. Study three dramatised interpretations of Macbeth

    Truly frightening. It throws the natural order of things as we associate caring and gentleness with children not roughness and violence. The witches' costumes consisted of stereotypical rags and black cloaks. They apparently had long hair but it was difficult to see as it was covered by their costume.

  1. Write about the transposition of Shakespeare's play, Macbeth, from live theatre to the medium ...

    other things, for example, in the Royal Shakespeare Company Production we see Macbeth's face taking up half the screen and the messengers talking between themselves in the distant background. When it comes to actors thinking to themselves, in the theatre they would stand facing the audience and talk out loud

  2. Macbeth The presentation of the witches in the opening scenes is crucial to the ...

    What are you?" This shows that they were unlike ordinary women. in scene iii the witches are again standing in the triangular formation and this time we notice the witch at the peak and how she must be the predominant witch as she has more lines and they are more important to the story.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work