• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

One thing that endures through time and change is one's brain; so perhaps the self is the brain. Give some good reason to think this idea isn't correct.

Extracts from this document...


a. One thing that endures through time and change is one's brain; so perhaps the self is the brain. Give some good reason to think this idea isn't correct. The above is the account of the powerful critisism to the body theory that states that the self is the body- i.e. each person is identifiable on the basis of physical and biological continuity. So, we can assume that the body theory is false and the above statement is true if we carry out a 'survival test'. By removing one person's brain and implanting it into another person's body, it is the brain that will determine the 'I' of the body. Therefore, the 'I' or the person is the brain. But still no scientific fact would state that the transplanted brain would determine the self of the body. People go through drastic psychological changes in their lives- they can convert to different religions, acquire different tastes in music, literature, start to possess different moral values and norms. ...read more.


would be a waste. This point of view is in the least degree absurd and inhumane to accept. Thus equating existence of the self to the biological life of the brain, with consequence like acceptance of the social death in case of the brain death is superficial and unacceptable in our society. b. another thing that endures through time and space is the bulk of one's mental characteristics; so perhaps the self is one's relatively stable and continuous psychology. First, explain what this view is in detail. Second, give some good reason to think this idea isn't correct. The 'bundle theory' as it is sometimes called states that it is our bulk of sensations that constitute ourselves-'I am something that thinks, and acts, and suffers'4. Each person has his own unique bulk of experiences that are his own. If we imagine that one morning a person wakes up in his bed, has the same sensations and thoughts that he normally has, for example, he is planning his day, experiences happiness of the sun that is shinning, feels the hunger and thirst. ...read more.


c. Present and defend your own view on what the self is. The self is a complex concept. One can not equate the self simply to the brain or to our mental characteristics. I personally think that our body, as well as our mind constitute our true selves. If our mind was to be reincarnated or implanted into another body, we would not be capable of operating this body it in the same way as we used to operate our own body. For example, if I was a good singer in my own body and had experienced happiness from being onstage singing, in my new body I would not necessarily be a good singer, because, firstly, singing requires vocal training which my new body might not have, and, secondly, the vestibular apparatus must work in the same way-I must have good ears, breath support etc. All of the above are required for me to gain that one sensation of happiness and satisfaction from singing. So, my old body is vital for myself to continue experiencing the same sensations. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Reviews of Personal Performances section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Reviews of Personal Performances essays

  1. "Explain the meaning of authority in relation to the public services"Authority:This can be defined ...

    Because they are experts ? Higher status to you ? Or because they have power Within the public services it is obvious to you what your status is, who you are superior to and who you are inferiors to. This is because of the rank structure.

  2. In this essay I will explore Carl Rogers core conditions and how these effect ...

    relationship with his client he is genuine and without "front" or facade, openly being the feelings and attitudes which at that moment are flowing in him... the feelings the therapist is experiencing are available to him, available to his awareness, and he is able to live these feelings, be them, and able to communicate them if appropriate."

  1. one to one communication interaction

    This is an affectionate term for Mr A. I responded with 'yes I think it is time I had a holiday' and Mr A laughed and said 'its time you did'. I laughed with Mr A to show I found his remark amusing. He shuffled around a little in his chair again.

  2. How can the person-centred core conditions help me to understand and change my life?

    In some way, trying to understand their world, the way they were brought up, their money worries and living conditions, the things that led them to the decisions they made. So in a sense I feel it is not about losing my opinions or experiences of certain times but about

  1. Comparative study, between the presentation of the characters Pechorin ("A Hero of Our Time") ...

    The style of the novel is understated and straightforward. Solzhenitsyn has written this book very descriptively. Everything has been described accurately so the reader can imagine and visualize the surroundings. An example of this is when Shukhov is describing the mess hall: "The mess-hall seemed as usual, with clouds of

  2. Homelessness production essay

    The pace immediately changes and the lights are bright on stage adding to the sudden liveliness, Emma realises who this homeless wreck is and forces notes into her palm Mary is scared and uneasy she manages to scurry away too frightened to face her past.

  1. Describe the nature, qualities and essential object of matrimonial consent according to Canon law ...

    It concerns not any sort of critical or judgemental power but one that can evaluate and make a true judgment about the very special and life-long obligations and effects of the married state as a community of life and love which involves a mutual self-giving or amor conjugalis.

  2. Skungpoomery - Textual Analysis.

    We looked at the Cinderella set because it would help us understand how you can build up a set using different ideas and images. When designing a set you need to look though the script and work out what things you have to do you then make a list of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work