• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Part One Essay- Nature Documentary Comparison

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Part One Essay- Caroline Stretton I have chosen to compare and contrast an episode of David's Attenborough's nature documentary "Planet Earth" with our devised play. I believe this comparison is appropriate as both texts address the same theme- observing and analysing particular animals in their natural environment- in different ways, though sharing some similarities. Our play is a parody of Attenborough's documentary, an idea which is reflected in the contrasting styles of the two pieces. "Planet Earth" has a naturalistic style, as Attenborough is playing himself and the animals are unaware of the camera's presence, creating the naturalistic style by displaying real-life situations. In contrast, our play has an extremely non-naturalistic style, with stereotypical characters- including "Davie Tattenborough", a character who mimics and exaggerates Attenborough's presenting style to comic effect. ...read more.

Middle

In our play, the characters do not acknowledge the presence of Tattenborough until briefly in the final scene of the play, and similarly in "Planet Earth", the animals are usually unaware of Attenborough's presence. One of Attenborough's documentaries, however, (aired on the 18th February 2007) contained a rare example of Attenborough interacting with the animals when he fished for a small reptile. This similarity helps to establish our play as a pastiche of "Planet Earth" by immediately creating a character disconnected from the main dramatic action, as Attenborough is in his documentary. Another way to establish this, which then creates another similarity between the two pieces, is Tattenborough's deliberate mockery of Attenborough's performance. An example of this is when in "Planet Earth", Attenborough continually hides behind bushes to avoid being noticed by his subjects. ...read more.

Conclusion

However, although both scenes are similar in structure, our play is much shorter in length than the "Planet Earth" documentary- twenty minutes compared to an hour. The shorter length of our play forces the action to be concentrated and condensed to that of "Planet Earth". This condensed format helps to create the non-naturalistic style of the piece, however, as each scene is brought to a climax more quickly, heightening dramatic tension for the audience. In conclusion, both texts share similarities and differences as our play uses the same structure (with a similar dynamic between characters) to establish our play as a parody of "Planet Earth" whilst the purposes of the pieces are completely different. To achieve these contrasting purposes, our play is a subverted version of "Planet Earth", contrasting naturalism to non-naturalism and reality to scripted exaggeration for comic effect. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Personal Performances section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Personal Performances essays

  1. GCSE Drama Coursework - Billy Liar Section One: The Response PhaseFor the response ...

    used to Florence's mumblings that they generally just ignore her and she just becomes background noise. We get the feeling that Geoffrey always does his paperwork at breakfast, Alice is always busy trying to keep things in order and Billy always strolls into breakfast as if he has all the time in the world.

  2. Blue Remembered Hills - Part 1

    Having no narrators or songs in Blue Remembered Hills means that the only way characters can communicate with the audience is through their interaction with other characters.

  1. A Written Comparison between Just Between Ourselves and Between Mouthfuls

    Also, his random little interjections such as "potted shrimps sir?" put the whole scene into context, and makes the audience wonder to themselves whether or not this is a situation that really does occur in real life to the extent that waiters are simply used to it!

  2. Comparative Essay - the Woman in Black and Blue Remebered Hills

    In The Woman in Black, minimal props were used. For example, a wicker basket was used to represent a horse and trap, a bed, a seat on a train and an office desk. In our production, which was more naturalistic, we did not employ multiple uses for our props and tried to make our stage look like a wood;

  1. Comparative essay

    a major outbreak of a deadly disease takes this superb reputation away. The main influence the writers of "Allo Allo" uses was stereotypes and comedy, with the war included strongly, and our piece was very similar to this as we wanted to convey the way people are judged in the workplace by stereotypes.

  2. Comparing the two plays 'The Crucible' and 'In The City' (3rd part of 'Barbarians')

    He is quite happy to hospitalise Louis just for laughing at him, showing partially the morals at the time of a select few. It is designed to shock the audience. While 'The Crucible' is about respectability, keeping 'a good name' etc., 'In The City' is more about the boundaries between classes and races.

  1. Unit 1 - Documentary Response to Children's Drama

    Stage 5 ? New Equilibrium Reached: The good defeats evil. The wolf is killed by the woodsman, the Grandmother is rescued and they live happily ever after. Again due to the action, this was mimed quickly and emotion was lost due to fast un-exaggerated movements but this was eventually corrected.

  2. Unit 1 - Drama Exploration of the theme Peer Pressure - Documentary Response

    He was also indicating that he wanted aid from Chris to defend him, thinking that he would help Derek because he already helped Chris with the shooting, but Chris stayed silent instead, conveying the peer pressure given off by Derek to Chris.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work