• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Studying Shall with the Help of Corpus Data

Extracts from this document...


Studying Shall with the Help of Corpus Data 1 Introduction In this essay I will discuss the use of shall. How frequent and important is it when making statements and asking questions about the future? To begin with, I will introduce material from different grammar books. To make the structure clear, I will discuss the uses in statements and questions separately. Furthermore, I will also distinguish the uses with 1st person subjects from the uses with 2nd and 3rd person subjects. In section 3, I will go on to examine a random sample of 50 examples of shall gathered from the British National Corpus online search facility. 2 Description of shall in the grammars Shall is a modal auxiliary verb which goes with the infinitive in all persons. Leech (1987, 88-89) argues that the speaker has authority in statements with shall, but in questions, the authority is in the hands of the hearer. In his view, shall is more common in questions than in statements, because consulting someone else's wishes is more polite than asserting one's own. 2.1 Shall in statements 2.1.1 Use with 1st person subjects According to Jespersen (1933, 278), shall is considered the natural auxiliary expressing the future, because will is often associated with volition. Shall is therefore often used to indicate predictions. Jespersen goes on to argue that "When a future state of one's own feelings is to be mentioned I shall is the natural expression, because one does not like to imply that they depend on one's will." ...read more.


For example, shall can be used when making a threat. Close to this is the idea of insistence introduced by Quirk and Greenbaum (1973, 54): You shall do as I say. He shall be punished. Another use of shall is making a promise. Jespersen (1933, 276) argues that this use has the idea of an obligation on the part of the speaker. However, COBUILD English Usage (1992, 622) states that using shall in this kind of meaning sounds old-fashioned and therefore, is also frequently replaced by will: You shall have the money as soon as I can get it. You shall not find me ungrateful for what you have done. 2.2 Shall in questions Leech (1989, 426) introduces three different kinds of uses of shall in questions: offering to do something, asking about some future event or asking for advice or suggestions. (1) Shall I...? or Shall we...? are generally used in making an offer. In these kind of questions, Leech (1987, 89) states, the speaker is consulting the wishes of the listener. Therefore, the will of the person addressed is important and, in fact, Leech states that Do you want me/us to...? can be used as a way of rephrasing: Shall I open the door? Shall we carry those bags for you? (2) Shall we...? is also used in making suggestions about the future or as a tag question after Let's. ...read more.


According to the corpus data, the use with 3rd person subjects is clearly less frequent with only 11 examples of the total of 50. However, what is interesting about these sentences, is that they are all categorised as rules and regulations: B3A 380 The board of the faculty shall deem a student to have withdrawn.... FRB 871 The democratic process demands that ministers shall be accountable.... As there was only one example of the use of shall with 2nd person subjects in the 50 samples, I did an additional search on they shall and you shall. In these examples shall was most frequently used in old-fashioned / biblical contexts or threats / insistence respectively: ALH 722 Blessed are the merciful: for they shall obtain mercy. FSJ 53 If you don't put that knife away, I promise you shall die a criminal's death under the law. 4 Conclusion In this essay I have discussed various uses of shall in different contexts. By using both grammar books and a corpus data, I have taken into consideration not only how the grammarians advise the learner to use shall, but also how shall has actually been used by native speakers. The corpus gives a good overall view of the frequency of shall. For example, it showed very clearly that the main use of shall is with 1st person predictions about the future, in which cases it can usually be replaced by will. Furthermore, what also became evident, is the fact that with 3rd person subjects, shall is mainly used in rules and regulations. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Reviews of Personal Performances section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Reviews of Personal Performances essays

  1. Drama - Studying 'women of courage'.

    We then started work on Edith Cavell starting with pair work of Edith hearing the news of the attack on Brussels, her home town. This helped me to understand what Edith and her mother would have been feeling. It helped me see what was expected of her and how hard

  2. How can the person-centred core conditions help me to understand and change my life?

    When speaking with a client, their past actions would have been involving someone else, thus I am not part of the actual event, surely this makes it easier to be unconditionally positive towards him or her. In real life however, the action may have been aimed directly at you.

  1. Homelessness production essay

    This all added to our performance as a whole and being in costume made me personally feel more in role and ready for the performance as it gave me more confidence and I felt as if I had actually become my character.

  2. Year 11 Portfolio on Homelessness

    From this, I found that my character lived in a squat and was providing the main income for the squatters, which on the main necessities. I used a Mancunian accent to show where I was from I was quite brash and open.

  1. Edger Allen Poe.

    This episode is crucial to the story because it shows Dupin's views of the police and his own approach to finding answers to difficult problems. He calls the enquiry "a shell of an examination" implying that it is hollow and has no substance.

  2. Childhood - Charlie Chaplin was born on the 15th of April 1889, in London.

    Within two years of his first appearances in motion pictures, he had become one of the best known personalities in the nation. Therefore on the 27th of February 1916, Chaplin signed with Mutual Films for $10,000 a week plus a �150,000 signing bonus.

  1. Police Powers to Stop and Search.

    The police have received reliable reports that a large gang of right-wing extremist will attack people taking part in an Asian outdoor festival. A group of skinheads allege police harassment when they are stopped and search for no apparent reason.

  2. This project was about the lives of slaves and in some cases the slave ...

    I offered to be the narrator. We decided it would be effective to show a hanging scene whilst the poem was being read. I sat just behind where Dan was being hung and read the poem in a tearful voice and pretended to cry.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work