• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

‘The Black Cat’ and ‘The Squaw’ are both short stories from the sub-genre of horror fiction. How are evil and the supernatural presented in each of the stories? Compare and contrast the two stories.

Extracts from this document...


English Literature Coursework - Response to Pre-1900 Prose texts 'The Black Cat' and 'The Squaw' are both short stories from the sub-genre of horror fiction. How are evil and the supernatural presented in each of the stories? Compare and contrast the two stories. Horror stories have common ingredients, including, a ruined gothic castle with monsters such as vampires and werewolves. Horror stories generally play on fear of the unknown. They cause the reader to be afraid of what they are going to see that they don't expect. When horror stories are also short stories, they benefit from this. A larger amount of dramatic events can take place in a short space of time. If the main character of a horror story that wasn't a short story died very near the end, the whole story would be ruined. This means that readers of short horror stories are shocked much more. In the two stories, evil and the supernatural are not presented in the way that they are normally in short stories. They are presented in a way to make the reader think about them, and how they can arise. This is unlike most horror stories, in which the aim of the story is just to shock and scare the reader. The two stories are entitled 'The Black Cat' and 'The Squaw'. The tiles of stories can tell the reader about them. The Black Cat is a short story about a man who is driven to murder by his cat. The Squaw is also a short story, about a man who kills a kitten, and is then killed by its mother, in an act of revenge. The titles mean that the reader to has impressions of what the stories are about as soon as they start reading them. ...read more.


This feeling of someone deserving an act of revenge adds to the horror theme of the story. The only shock in the story is when the kitten is killed. For these reasons, the usage of shock and surprise in the two stories is very different. The two men who kill the cats in the two stories have very important roles in the plot, as do their characters. The narrator in The Black Cat seems very emotional. He often confides in the reader about how The Black Cat drives him to insanity, whereas Elias P. Hutcheson is not given a particularly prominent character, and the reader does not learn much about his emotions. In The Black Cat, the narrator is used as the main character, to confide in the reader, about his experiences. In this way, the author brings about the questions about evil and the supernatural. In The Squaw, Hutcheson is instead used as a tool for the plot to be developed. He doesn't have any visible emotions shown. He seems only to be in the story to kill the kitten, and then to be killed at the end. The reader feels sorry for the narrator in The Black Cat, because he is driven to madness and he is very hopeless, but they also feel hatred for him because of all of the cruel things he does. The cats are probably the most important elements in both of the stories. In The Black Cat, the cat is initially introduced amongst the narrator's other pets, and in The Squaw, the cat is introduced when the characters see it with its kitten. Unlike at the beginning of The Squaw, at the beginning of The Black Cat, the reader is given a small hint of the supernatural powers of the cat, in the title, because black cats are said to be bad luck, and witches in disguise. ...read more.


and I believe that his purpose in writing The Black Cat was to give an insight into the mind of someone who goes mad. I believe he wanted to show that people are driven to do evil things, and they do not just suddenly turn evil and crazy. He wanted to show that evil people are people too, like everyone else. This does not fit the general trend in horror stories very well. Usually, the evil character is just there to be someone for the reader to dislike and fear. The reader is never usually shown any reason for the person to have become evil. Stoker believes that evil is not always how and where it seems, as Poe also does, and I believe that he wrote The Squaw to show this. This fits the horror story genre in the same way as The Black Cat does because it is not like most horror stories. Like The Black Cat, it depicts a different meaning to evil and the supernatural, and it doesn't rely on clich�s. I believe that evil and the supernatural are well presented in the both of the stories. Both of the authors wrote the stories to give a deeper meaning to the way they are depicted in horror stories. Neither of the two stories is typical of the horror story genre. They are both deliberately meant to show the different ways that evil and the supernatural can exist, that are not usually depicted in horror short stories. I believe The Black Cat to be the more effective as a horror story. The way it depicts the mind of a madman is more effective in horrifying the reader. His feelings and reactions give the reader a chilling and disturbing insight into the mind of an evil, twisted murderer. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Edgar Allan Poe section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Edgar Allan Poe essays

  1. Compare and contrast the narrative techniques used in three or more of Edgar Allan ...

    During the story Edgar Allan Poe has used a list of three commas to slow the text down, for example "then silence, and stillness, and night were the universe". Yet again similar to the other stories wrote by Edgar Allan Poe, the "Pit and the Pendulum" uses imagery to build

  2. Compare the two nineteenth century horror stories, 'The Black Cat' and 'The Tell-Tale Heart' ...

    The amount of description sets the scene very effectively and makes the reader feel like there telling the story from their own personal experience. The use of evil words such as 'greatly decayed' and 'clotted with gore' also emphasise the fear and terror of the story.

  1. ‘Milk for the Cat’ and ‘A Case of Murder’

    Each poem rhymes here are some rhyming couplets from 'Milk for the Cat' 'Care, There, Grate, Late Haze and Gaze'. Here are some rhyming couplets from 'A Case of Murder' 'Rat, Cat, Sit, It, Sat and That'. Each poem has similes in 'Milk for the Cat' the simile is 'The white saucer like some full moon descends'.

  2. How is tension created in 'The tell tale hearts' and 'The black cat'?

    I think however, that Poe's stylistic devices add the most tension to the tales, the combination of punctuation and sentence length. He uses dashes in the middle of sentences in his work to add tension, to make them moment's stand out from the rest of the text.

  1. Compare and contrast The Purloined Letter and The Black Cat

    Both of the stories although do share one plot that is the same and that is revenge. There are more different locations in The Purloined Letter compared to the different locations in The Black Cat. The Purloined Letter has locations such as Minister D's hotel, which adds mystery; Royal apartment equals high society and extravagance.

  2. What makes Poe's writing Gothic?

    -to the earth art thou not for ever dead?' This creates a sense not only of a true person behind the story but also of this criminal writing it himself while we read. He also informs us he must conceal his name, so dastardly are his crimes, as though if

  1. Comparing the ways Edgar Allen Poe and Bram Stoker convey horror through writing.

    The cat gets more and more attached to him but he is reluctant to interact with it because he feels the supernatural element of this situation. He begins to hate the cat and the fact that it is always around him: "Its evident fondness for myself rather disgusted and annoyed

  2. Poe's mark on American Literature.

    By paralleling the American's progress into the heart of a new and unknown area, Poe could describe the hardships of which the Americans had to endure. Through this method, those who weren't at the heart of the matter could understand what the Americans were doing, and why they were doing it.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work