• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

‘The tragedy of Richard III lies in the progressive isolation of its protagonist.’ Discuss.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'The tragedy of Richard III lies in the progressive isolation of its protagonist.' Discuss. There are many ways throughout the play that Shakespeare shows isolation in Richard Gloucester, the protagonist, but there is some debate over whether or not it is this which leads to tragedy. This partly occurs due to the dubious understanding of the term 'tragedy' itself. It is a term used widely to describe a variety of different plays and even situations: from Romeo and Juliet to Death of a Salesman, even to true-life events such as the terrorist attacks on September 11th this year. It would appear to us that tragedy is all around us, in every news bulletin and on virtually any television program but, if this is true, why is it that 'tragedy' is so hard to define? Aristotle once claimed: 'In order to be a tragic hero, you have to be important.' If this is true, then it would also be true that tragedy can be defined as a fall from power and happiness to death and destruction. Obviously, this tragedy is greatened as the person in question becomes more powerful, as they have further to fall from - as they build the metaphorical scaffolding higher, the ground becomes further away. This indeed means that if a pole secured further down the tower breaks, the scaffolding above would break too, leaving the person further to fall, and increasing the likelihood that they will break their neck on impact. If the person had spent more time securing the poles further down, and then fallen, the effects would be less catastrophic. ...read more.

Middle

Indeed even after this, the night before his big battle, Richard has a dream in which he is all alone. This is another sign of his isolation. However, although Richard's physical condition is definitely a prominent cause for his isolation, it is also a cause for the audience to feel sympathy for Richard. Richard himself uses his condition against the other characters in the play to create the idea that he is not to blame - he is actually victimised by them, not vice versa. Because of this, the tragic element of the play is reduced by Richard's actions, although his isolation may be becoming increasingly worse. In addition to Richard's physical predicament, his psychological condition plays a large part in his isolation. The first sign of any psychological problem is when he does not show any distress when murdering people, apart from in Act V scene iii, when his conscience appears to return to him for the first time in the whole play, and he shouts: 'Have mercy, Jesu! / O coward conscience how dost thou afflict me!' Indeed the only time Richard is entirely serious in the play is just before he is about to murder someone. It is about the time of the return of Richard's conscience that he realises that he has become so detached from the people around him he has forgotten who he himself is: 'Richard loves Richard; that is, I am I. / Is there a murderer here? No. Yes, I am' (V.iii.) ...read more.

Conclusion

However, there is one aspect of Richard's role on stage that he does not isolate: the audience. He makes them his allies right from the very beginning. The audience understand a lot more of Richard's wit, sarcasm and dramatic irony than the other characters involved do, and therefore feel in league with Richard in a detached, secretive sort of way. Richard also shares some of his feelings, real or otherwise, with the audience. However, Richard seems so evil a villain, hardly caring about all the murders and sins he commits, he does not seem a person associated with extreme tragedy. The greatest loss in the play is actually more likely to be that of the young princes, rather than that of Richard. In Act III scene i, the Princes talk happily with their trusted Uncle and 'Lord Protector', whom the Uncle know is a multiple-faced villain. The audience feels deep sympathy for the Princes, who are naively trusting but also afraid of being forced to stay in the Tower. Also, one of the Princes also manages to outwit Richard, from which the audience gains extreme respect because many fully mature adults have not been able to achieve this. The princes were happy, witty and intelligent before their murder, and their death seems multiple times worse than the death of Richard - a twisted, villainous, death-driven old man. To conclude, the tragedy of Richard III's protagonist is perceived because of Richard's attractiveness as a villain and also by the way he defied society's rules and expectations. However, the audience always recalls his wickedness - the murdering, the lying and the corruption. Therefore, despite Richard's attractiveness, we never really feel any great loss or waste when he dies. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Richard III section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Richard III essays

  1. Why does the audience admire Richard III and feel sympathy based on the opening ...

    He first describes the way he himself actually, and then says that this results in dogs barking at him. This is supposed to show us his lowly based confidence, which has an effect on the way he thinks. The emotive language that he uses in my view is when he

  2. Exploration of the techniques used to foreshadow death in Richard ...

    that Catesby is in fact plotting against Hastings, so the revelation of his trust in him is a very ominous sign for Hastings. Also, Hastings believes himself very much to be safe. 'With some men think themselves as safe as thou am I' 3.2.66-67.

  1. 'In plot, in imagery, in structure, Richard II offers us little thatis not already ...

    One of the main ways in which Shakespeare is possibly indebted to Marlowe is through his use of imagery. The constant repetition of the sun in Edward II is echoed in Richard II, used by both playwrights to symbolise the monarchy and the splendour of the royal family.

  2. Richard III Empathetic Essay

    That child learned no lesson from the murder of her own ex-husband Prince Edward, nor father-in-law King Henry VI. She clumsily fell for my son's nasty tricks and mind games, and for her ignorance I can not share any compassion.

  1. Is Richard III a hero or a villain

    Some qualities however, like intelligence, can fall into both categories of "heroic" or "villainous". Richard's role in the story can easily classify him as a hero. As I mentioned before, in my definition of the word hero, Richard is the principal male character in this story.

  2. How do we feel Sympathy or Admiration for Richard III?

    But also this hatred could be out of envy and jealousy of the better looking soldiers as he has nothing to be vain about because he is deformed. After this he goes on to personify his weapons, "Our bruised arms hung up for monuments" The personification of his weapons makes

  1. Our intial impression of a character usually influences the way we judge that character ...

    of not caring about being hanged, and is eager for his death to come quickly and be over and done with, when he reaches the gallows he becomes increasingly frightened which shows, once again, that he is not quite the hard man he tries to make himself out to be.

  2. "Richard III has been called Shakespeare's greatest villain. Do you agree? Analyse two scenes ...

    Another example of Richard's evil nature is when he starts to blame other people for the evil things he has done. An example of this is when Brakenbury is taking Clarence to the Tower and they meet Richard. "RICHARD Brother, good day.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work