• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

“A pink wool knitted dress,” by Ted Hughes and “Sonnet XLIII” (43) by Elizabeth Barrett Browning.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Love Poetry Coursework By Eithne Mc Crory. The two poems I have selected to compare and contrast are, "A pink wool knitted dress," by Ted Hughes and "Sonnet XLIII" (43) by Elizabeth Barrett Browning. The first poem I intend to analyse is, "A pink wool knitted dress." This poem is not written along conventional lines, since it does not employ the use of sonnet or stanzas of four lines. Indeed there are three lines in the first stanza while the fourth stanza could be a sonnet in itself as it consists of fourteen lines. All the other stanzas are of differing lengths as are the lengths of the lines. In terms of rhyme in many of the poems I have previously read the last word in each line often rhymes with the last word in the next line or the second next line. This sort of rhyming occurs in Barrett Browning Sonnet XLIII where the second and third lines rhyme as do the first and fourth. This pattern continues throughout the poem. Hughes writes in run on sentences, some of which carry on into the next line, in fact the style and structure of the poem reminds me more of a piece of prose than a poem. ...read more.

Middle

How can this be a love poem? The whole flavour and texture of the poem is so mundane, workaday and prosaic, just like any other day. Does this reflect Hughes' innermost thoughts about his wedding? That is certainly the impression he gives me. So how is it a love poem? The answer lies in the last two stanzas where Hughes addresses his bride in language that is quite different to that used in the previous stanzas. In the second last stanza the language contains heavenly imagery, "Transfigured," "brimming with God," "the heavens open," "Riches ready to drop upon us," "levitated." What a contrast to what has gone before! Not drab but uplifting and celestial. But is Hughes describing a person whom he loves or some image he sees in her? Is it what she can do for him, not what he can do for her? The last stanza seems to reflect the poet's notion that his bride is 'crazy' about him and simply cannot take her eyes off him. Nowhere in the poem does Hughes describe a similar intoxication for her. This poem is the embodiment of what Ted Hughes sees and portrays himself as a poet. "Imagine what you are writing about. See it and live it... Look at it, touch it, smell it Listen to it, turn yourself into it." ...read more.

Conclusion

Browning herself suffered ill health and that she was conscious that death was never far away so this possible morbidity could arise from that feeling. It is undoubtedly very intense. Both poems differ in many obvious ways. Ted Hughes poem is much longer, he has quite a different style and approach, his piece tells a story with a certain amount of wry humour and diversity. Only in the last part of it does Hughes concentrate on the theme Of love whereas Barrett Browning is totally concentrated on the love theme. Of course both are structurally quite different and different also in both tone and language. Hughes uses inclined, common and everyday language while Barrett Browning's is austere and devotional like the language used in a prayer. Perhaps, in the final analysis, Ted Hughes' approach to love is not quite as serious and faithful as Elizabeth Barrett Browning's. She expresses her love in depth, breadth and Height while Hughes' expression of love somewhat appears to be more shallow and perhaps less sincere. Does Hughes love his bride merely because she loves him? While Barrett Browning appears to love her partner for his own sake. I prefer Ted Hughes' poem, basically because I feel it is more true to life, the storyline is also interesting. This is a stark contrast to the quasi-religious intensity of Elizabeth Barrett Browning's sonnet, which I find too overpowering and totally redolent of the early Victorian ethos. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Ted Hughes section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Ted Hughes essays

  1. Esthers Tomcat by Ted Hughs.

    It grabs your attention. This anecdote is also used to tell us about cats in general. It tells us how vicious cats are. "Grallochs dogs on the quiet" tells us that cats are quite good at fighting. "Grallochs" tells us how vicious, strong and violent cats are.

  2. How does Ted Hughes convey the ruthless power and violence in animals through the ...

    Its monologue of plain, forceful words matches the arrogant frankness of the speaker. The hawk is arrogant because it is blowing its own trumpet on how powerful it is and on its right to kill. In one stanza we see the poet keeps three pikes behind glass.

  1. Ted Hughes, the thought fox, is an effective poem on both a literal and ...

    All the literal meaning of the fox which discussed earlier exists only in the internal world of the poet. This fox, which is a "thought fox", symbolizes the thought or idea. With the fox delicate movements and actions, this can be seen as the thought process of the poet and how his inspiration or imagination comes about.

  2. Compare and contrast "Pike" by Ted Hughes with "Trout" by Heaney.

    Now Heaney compares the trout to a gun and suggests that they are both very similar, 'his muzzle gets bull's eye;' from this quote we can establish that both a gun and a trout are accurate missiles, which never miss their target.

  1. In a close reading of 'The Thought-Fox' and 'Roe-Deer', discuss how he uses, the ...

    first stanza, 'something else is alive' is beginning to enter his mind/ to confront Hughes. The third stanza illustrates the thought - the fox - coming out of the darkness. The first sign of movement by the fox is described as, 'A fox's nose touches twig, leaf:' And again now,

  2. Examine the significance and treatment of the natural world in the poetry of one ...

    The feebleness of the tractor against the elements of winter reflects a human beings weakness against nature. And the tractor, streaming with sweat, Raging and trembling and rejoicing. This final short paragraph displays best the tractor as a person with an illness.

  1. Concentrating on one Poem by each Poet, Compare and Contrast the ways in which ...

    This comes through strongest in Wordsworth's poems. He gives the impression that nature is like a religion to him by continually saying things like 'Books! 'tis a dull and endless strife, come, hear the linnet,' and things that are similar in both poems.

  2. Which section of Ted Hughes ‘Grief’s for Dead Soldiers’ did you find the most ...

    all at once which is like what the widow must be trying to do, take in all the events slowly. In this section Hughes uses some very interesting metaphors and similes to produce more striking images. One such simile is when he compares the telegram to a bomb "that dives to the cellar and lifts the house."

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work