• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

“A sad tale’s best for winter. What then is the value of the comic elements of The Winter’s Tale?”

Extracts from this document...


Shakespeare: The Winter's Tale "A sad tale's best for winter. What then is the value of the comic elements of The Winter's Tale?" The Winter's Tale is a play of extremes of character, mood and genre, the play therefore cannot easily be categorised. As a result, in considering a question such as this we must be conscious of the fact that we are measuring the comic elements' relative value against, for example, the tragic or romantic sides of the play. The comedy must therefore be gauged in the context of the piece as a whole. Contextually, comedy was of course very important in contemporary live performance as it is today on stage. It is often easy to forget that a playwright can and will blend genres, a technique that modern critics will often explain away as a method to increase tension. For example, it has been said that the comedy of the drunken porter in Macbeth does not vitiate but rather increases the tragic momentum.1 These sorts of effect are undoubtedly achieved; this fact does not however diminish the spontaneous comic value of a moment in a live performance. The term 'tragicomedy' has been has been employed to describe The Winter's Tale and plays similar in genre-structure to, such as Pericles, Prince of Tyre. These plays tend to have more than just a glimpse of relieving comedy; the humour usually has a significant role in the development of the play and its ideas. ...read more.


He is the instigator in making most of the fourth act extremely farcical, inducing misunderstanding and comedic situations predominantly for his own gain. Autolycus is essentially in control of his actions, a "snapper-up of unconsidered trifles" through being a man of many guises, from the grovelling "O, that ever I was born!" to the joyously satisfied "A merry heart goes all the day." The key to the comedy of his introductory scene, the clown's pick pocketing, is the speed of the dialogue, the spontaneity of the rogue's loosely constructed alibi, and the sense of classic dramatic irony that Shakespeare is not afraid to adopt, "You ha' done me a charitable office." When Autolycus describes the man who allegedly robbed him, comically, he describes himself, "that's the rogue that put me into this apparel." In winding-up the clown's opinions of this mystical 'Autolycus', the audience takes delight in this mockery of the fool, whilst also hearing the humorously exiting description of the rogue's life of short-term commitments in many "knavish professions". Beneath the obvious fact that Autolycus is a rogue, lies the essence of his mythical namesake, the god Mercury, not only god of theft and lying (Autolycus meaning "lone wolf") but also paradoxically of eloquence and presidency over the truths of hermetic philosophy. This is, of course, where Autolycus lives up to his roots; this is arguably where the humour's significance lies beyond just being a break from the tragedy. ...read more.


The penultimate act's gradual introduction to unconventional ideas allows us to laugh at them in comedy to prepare for Hermione's awakening, which, without the fourth act's careful preparation with humour, might seem funny when it is clearly not supposed to be. Comedy aids the play in its plot on a character level, on our understanding of the play's message and how the ending can plausibly come about. We must remember that Shakespeare is also catering for a live audience in his use of the humour but is also exploring the fabric of reconciliation and forgiveness. In my opinion, the major artifice or leap of faith cannot be taken seriously without the audience adopting what one could call a sense of humour, that is to say an open mind and an ability to mentally break convention. In order to have this ability to leave behind the pretence of the final scene of the play, an audience's mind has to have been nurtured by the comic elements in the fourth act. This nurturing leads to an admission on the audiences part that this play is a work of art and must be accepted and appreciated as just that. 1 "The Knocking at the Gate in Macbeth', De Quincey, first published in the London Magazine, Oct. 1823. 2 "As You Like It" Act II, Sc. 5, L. 7-8. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Winters Tale section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Winters Tale essays

  1. How does Shakespeare present relationships between men and women in The Winter's Tale, ...

    Love, may follow later but in terms of Jacobean realism it would be realistic that neither the husband nor wife loved each other. In literary terms and in modern terms marriage is usually for love from the beginning. In the case of Leontes and Hermione, love is disregarded for jealousy.

  2. In Death and The Maiden, Paulina's struggle is symbolic of the struggle of oppressed ...

    to just get a confession from Roberto, but then changes to wanting to kill him. "And why does it always have to be people like me who have to sacrifice...This time I am going to think about myself, about what I need.

  1. Explore the role of women in 'The Winters Tale'

    "The bug which you would fright me with, I seek". In this speech, Hermione is very angry " sir spare your threats". The fact that she trivialises his threats shows courage. The use of clear direct language and monosyllables gives the effect of unemotional language.

  2. How are women represented in "The Winter's Tale"? How might a modern audience react ...

    This is perhaps Shakespeare's most literal display of Hermione's character as although she appears strong and dignified on the outside, on the inside she is weak, which is shown by Hermione fainting to her apparent death. The death of Hermione's son, Mamillius, is also a large factor in Hermione's 'death'.

  1. Shakespeare's A Winters Tale Scene by Scene Analysis.

    Having produced an heir, Leontes shirks his duty to be a good father. Leontes questions the paternity of Mamillius, and so absolves himself of the responsibility to provide for the boy's safety, happiness, and wellbeing. Leontes' outrageous behavior will eventually cost him the life of his heir Mamillius, as well as the loss of his second child, Perdita.

  2. How does Shakespeare present the role of women in the play "The Winter's Tale"

    figures, Hermione is accused of adultery and then of carrying a bastard child, Paulina loses Antigonus, she says, "As my Antigonus to break his grave," Paulina makes Leontes suffer along with herself at the loss of a spouse. Hermione looses two children, and Perdita is persecuted by Polixines for bewitching his son.

  1. Discuss the roles and dramatic significance of the three main female characters in the ...

    Thus illustrates her own complete confidence in her innocence. Her beliefs are backed up by the members of the court of Sicilia as they hold her in high esteem and regard her as a paragon of morality and virtue. "more it would content me To have her honour true than your suspicion," (Act II Scene i lines 159-160)

  2. How does Shakespeare present relationships between men and women in The Winter's Tale and ...

    difficult to manage - when outraged with Paulina, Leontes calls her "A mankind witch!" and warns her that he'll "ha' thee burnt." Although Hermione is badly treated, Leontes becomes the focus, it becomes he who suffers and repents, as Nevill Coghill remarks: "it is a play about a crisis in the life of Leontes, not of Hermione."

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work