• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

“The Great Gatsby” is a deeply tragic novel; “A Handful of Dust” is a light-hearted, farcical comedy.” To what extent do you agree with this evaluation of the genre and style of the two novels?

Extracts from this document...


"The Great Gatsby" is a deeply tragic novel; "A Handful of Dust" is a light-hearted, farcical comedy." To what extent do you agree with this evaluation of the genre and style of the two novels? 'The Great Gatsby', written by F Scott Fitzgerald, is undoubtedly a deeply tragic novel. There are many tragic elements about it, many of which I shall be looking at in greater detail. The title character and protagonist in the novel is Jay Gatsby, a mysterious and fabulously wealthy man living in a gothic mansion in West Egg. Gatsby does not appear a speaking role until chapter three of the novel. Fitzgerald initially presents Gatsby as the aloof, enigmatic host of the unbelievably wealthy parties thrown every week at his mansion. He appears surrounded by spectacular luxury, courted by powerful men and beautiful women. Yet he is flawed. Many aspects of Gatsby's world are intriguing because they are slightly amiss - for instance, he seems to throw parties at which he knows none of his guests. His accent seems affected and his habit of calling people "old sport" is hard to place. One of his guests is surprised to find that his books are real, and not just empty covers. ...read more.


Nick is the only character at all interested in Gatsby after his death. At the funeral "nobody came" until Owl-Eyes arrives. Gatsby experiences loneliness, even in death. He has truly become a tragic, piteous character, and has reached his tragic end. * After Gatsby's funeral, Nick ends his relationship with Jordan and moves back to Minnesota to escape the disgust he feels for the people surrounding Gatsby's life. Nick reflects that just as Gatsby's dream of Daisy was corrupted by money and dishonesty, the American dream of happiness has disintegrated into the pursuit of wealth. Though Gatsby's power to transform his dreams into reality is what makes him "great", Nick reflects that the era of dreaming - both Gatsby's dream and the American dream - is over, thus making Gatsby's end a tragic end. I believe that the novel "A Handful Of Dust", written by Evelyn Waugh, has elements of comedy and farce, but can also been seen, like "The Great Gatsby", as a tragedy. The action developed in the novel closely resembles the action of classical greek tragedy. There is the rising action: Brenda's growing disaffection for her husband; the climax, the accidental death of John Andrew and Brenda's subsequent desertion of Tony, Tony's voyage to South America, and finally, the catastrophe with Tony ending up in the hands on Mr Todd. ...read more.


In "The Great Gatsby", Myrtle Wilson accidentally gets run over, an act of fate which causes Gatsby to lose his life. Both Gatsby and Tony come to a tragic end which they do not deserve. There is a significance in Tony's ending; he has ultimately gone from one imprisonment to another - from Hetton to South America. This ending is both tragic and farcical: it is tragic as Tony's traditional values have finally decayed, and it is farcical because Mr Todd makes Tony read him Dickens aloud. This is nonsensical, but at the same time, absurdly funny. Referring back to the question, I do agree with the evaluation that "The Great Gatsby" is a deeply tragic novel, but disagree that "A Handful of Dust" is a light-hearted, farcical comedy. "A Handful Of Dust" does have an underlining element of farce to it, however, the tragic elements exceed the farcical elements. Like Gatsby in "The Great Gatsby", Tony Last is a victim; a victim of society, a victim of adultery and most significantly, a victim of himself. He has a tragic flaw, and readers can sympathise with him. He reaches a tragic end which he does not, by any means, deserve. From all of these points, I would conclude that "A Handful of Dust", like "The Great Gatsby" is a deeply tragic novel. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE F. Scott Fitzgerald section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE F. Scott Fitzgerald essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Beneath the Surface Glitter, The Great Gatsby is a Profoundly Pessimistic Novel. Do You ...

    4 star(s)

    he is astounded at what he finds. There is rife hypocrisy and a general lack of purpose. "Tom would drift on forever seeking, a little wistfully for the dramatic turbulence of some irrevocable football game." Tom also shows signs of something even more incorrect with his bigoted comment: "Civilisation's going to pieces..

  2. Peer reviewed

    What is so Great about Gatsby? The word great in the title gives the ...

    4 star(s)

    People always want more than they have and what they dream of having, because once they have achieved their dream they will simply dream of having something else. We know therefore that Gatsby will never be happy, especially since what he hopes to achieve is unachievable, he dreams of going

  1. Corruption of the American Dream in The Great Gatsby.

    so that he can always glaze at "the green light that burns all night at the end of your [Daisy's] dock" (P.90). Actually, he also buys a luxurious "yellow car", a deluxe yacht, many ornate clothes and stacks of bona fide books, not only to show off his wealth and social and educational status, but also to impress Daisy.

  2. "The Great Gatsby" and the American Dream.

    She didn't want to take a chance with Jay when he was in the army, and she doesn't want to risk her future on the precarious wealth that Gatsby has earned from crime. This is even though she knows Tom is having an affair and isn't really too sure about Goddard's books at all.

  1. Death of the American - Great Gatsby and Death of a Salesman

    love him, but her selfish motivations prevent her from leaving her husband (26). She has a wealthy, handsome husband and small child; to her that is all that matters. In one last attempt to win back Daisy's love, Gatsby sacrifices himself for her when he covers up her crime.

  2. To what extent would you agree that in "The Great Gatsby" Fitzgerald reflects a ...

    Daisy's reactions to things are either to laugh or to cry, and this presents women unsympathetically, because they lack the capacity to express themselves. Diane Roberts remarked, "Zelda Fitzgerald was the inspiration for many of her husband's amoral, ultimately unattainable, sometimes deeply troubled heroines."

  1. 'Examine Fitzgerald's use of time and place in The Great Gatsby'.

    the sociology of wealth and how the millionaires or upper class of the 1920s differed from the old aristocracy of the country's richest families. As said in the previous paragraph, the West Egg represented the newly rich people of the 1920s, whilst the East Egg, along with Tom and Daisy who live there, represent the old aristocracy.

  2. Effectiveness of Narration in The Great Gatsby

    A contradiction becomes apparent when Nick compares Wilson to Tom, who seems to juxtapose George's sickness for being "well" (111). These descriptions by the narrator hints to the readers that the reality of this contrast is the opposite, as Tom should have been the sick one because he lacks spiritual and moral values from what he has done.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work