• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

“Whatever happened we all done it.” Discuss who you think is to blame for the tragedy at the end of the play.

Extracts from this document...


"Whatever happened we all done it." Discuss who you think is to blame for the tragedy at the end of the play. "Whatever happened we all done it." These words are spoken by Beatrice in response to Catherine's accusations about Eddie Carbone. Catherine has just accused Eddie of being a rat, "You belong in the sewers." "In the garbage he belongs." "He bites people when they sleep." Later in the play Eddie draws a knife on Marco who turns the knife back into him and Eddie dies. In my opinion it can be argued that all the characters; Eddie, Catherine Marco, Rodolfo and Beatrice contribute to the tragic death of Eddie at the end of the play. Eddie Carbone contributes most in my opinion to his own death at the climax of the play. We can see his over-protective behaviour towards Catherine at the start of the play, "I'm tellin' you you're walkin' wavy." This over-protective behaviour towards Catherine may contribute to Eddie's constant feeling that he controls the life of Catherine. He is obsessed with her and analyses everything she does to her appearance; "Where are you goin' all dressed up?" "And what happened to your hair?" Eddie shows a hint of jealousy in the same conversation as when he displays his feelings on Catherine's way of walking when he comments the 'looks' that Catherine is getting from other men, "I don't like the looks they're giving you in the candy store." ...read more.


"Go ahead Rodolfo. He's a good boxer. He could teach you." "He's teachin' him; he's very good." The fact that Beatrice encourages this kind of behaviour gives Eddie a good enough reason to hit Rodolfo and teach him a lesson. This 'fight' may also be another method by Eddie to get rid of Rodolfo for good. This contribution by Beatrice may not seem much at the time, but it may have been a considerable boost for Eddie in his attempt to eliminate Rodolfo from Catherine's life. Marco, the cousin of Beatrice Carbone is introduced into the play after he and his brother have entered America illegally. Marco, in my opinion contributed greatly to the tragedy at the end of the play but I do not feel that his contribution was as great as Eddie's. Marco is the character who accuses Eddie of reporting him to the immigration bureau in front of the whole neighbourhood. "That one! I accuse that one!" "That one! He killed my children! That one stole the food from my children!" The fact that Marco has said these things about him in public has removed the people of Red Hook's respect for Eddie and therefore he has now got a mission to get his 'name back'. The way in which Eddie goes about getting his name back (with a knife) ...read more.


This change in attitude toward Eddie leaves Eddie with virtually nothing, no friends, no respect and no Catherine. Eddie is a broken man and has no one but himself to blame but himself. The only thing that he can do is to recapture his name from Marco, which he doesn't succeed in doing. Catherine's guilt at the end of the play may be summed up in the final statement. "Eddie, I never meant to do nothin' bad to you." Having began the play in all innocence, being dutiful and loving to her elders, her character develops a rebellious streak who is prepared to defy Eddie at all costs. She is also not afraid to speak her mind, "Who the hell do you think you are?" I feel that it must be argued that it was mostly Eddie Carbone's fault for his downfall although the other characters contribute to the tragedy. He was the one that made the call to the immigration bureau and he was the one that set out with the knife to kill Marco. At the end of the play we see the state of desperateness that Eddie has resorted to. From his words, "Oh, Jesus, no, I wouldn't do nothin' about that" when Alfieri suggests that Eddie should report them to the immigration bureau Eddie does exactly this later in the play. Eddie's downfall was due to his obsession with a young girl who found true love in the arms of another man. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Arthur Miller section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Arthur Miller essays

  1. Why and How Does Eddie Carbone Change As The Play Progresses? What Leads to ...

    That's probably why he felt no shame when he kissed Rodolpho on the lips. "Eddie pins his arms, laughing, and suddenly kisses him". Readers almost sympathise for Rodolpho. He doesn't even know that he's been trapped in Eddie's emotional

  2. Who Or What Is To Blame For The Death Of Eddie Carbone?

    Italian-American masculine belief of what being a man is about; this is because Eddie is intellectually limited. Protecting your territory and regarding other men as hostile and intruders when they try to cross the boundary is Eddie's view of what being a man is about.

  1. How much is Eddie to blame for his own downfall?

    Catherine is the one that Eddie loves so how can she be blamed for his own downfall? Catherine starts off the play as a little girl and at that time Eddie is contempt, however, Catherine acts too much like a little girl that when it is time for her to

  2. Catherine says Eddie is "a rat" who belongs in the sewer - To what ...

    This would then encourage the audience to feel sympathetic towards Beatrice because she is lacking the attention and affection from her husband, which is instead being given to Catherine. We can interpret this when she is advising Catherine "give him (Eddie)

  1. In what ways can Rodolfo be seen as a catalyst to the tragedy?

    Catherine in return seems to accept this role as Eddie's daughter (without realising). She lights his cigar, brings him a beer and sits on the edge of his bath while he shaves. These are not mannerisms that girls of her age naturally perform, and this shows the audience the unnaturalness of their relationship.

  2. Explore the implications of Beatrice's words and say to what extent you agree with ...

    (She hurries into the kitchen, and as she exits there) I'll do the dishes, B.! Alone, EDDIE stands looking towards the kitchen for a moment..." Here there is a sort of flirting going on, when a girl lights the cigarette, or a cigar in this case, for the guy there is a bit of sexual seductiveness to it.

  1. A View from the Brige - How is it evident from the beginning of ...

    We can see that all he says is relevant to the play, immediately knowing it is likely to end in tragedy. The following line is taken from Alfieri's first speech: "I am a lawyer. In this neighbourhood to meet a lawyer or a priest on the street is unlucky.

  2. Who or what is to blame for Eddie Carbone's downfall in

    As a result of this Eddie died. Loss of popularity is Eddie's central worry which directed him to death. He is so concerned about what the neighborhood thinks of him because he lives in Brooklyn which is a tough part of downtown New York and it was close nit, meaning that they care about what the community thinks of them.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work