• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A Comparison between Billy Liar and Shirley Valentine

Extracts from this document...


A Comparison between Billy Liar and Shirley Valentine I have just been studying Billy Liar and performing it as part of my mock scripted drama GCSE, and have been asked to compare this theatre script to the film script of Shirley Valentine. I have already given the first difference between these two scripts; one is a theatre script and the other is designed specifically for the big screen. Billy Liar was originally a novel written by Keith Waterhouse, who with the help of Willis Hall made it into a theatre script in the 1960's. Billy is an imaginative youth who is fighting to get out of his complacent, clich�-ridden background. He was born and brought up in a town in Yorkshire and lives with his father, Geoffrey, mother, Alice, and grandmother, Florence. Billy has three girlfriends, Rita, Barbara and Liz, but he only shows genuine affection and feelings towards Liz. Billy is always fantasising and making up things which earns him the label 'liar'. At the end of the play Billy decides to leave his home and follow Liz to London but as we find out in the last scene he 'chickens' out and returns to the home he so desperately wants to escape. ...read more.


Because both scripts are designed for different purposes the dialogue in each one is very different. In Billy Liar the dialogue is quite lengthy and quite adult, proper and formal in the way it is constructed. This would be down to the time at which it was written. In the 1960's the Lord Chancellor was very tough on censorship. Any swearing or even slightly risqu� images were changed or censored completely. The strongest word used within the play is probably 'bloody' which Geoffrey says a lot and even this, is a bit 'close to the bone'. Whereas when Shirley Valentine was written there was not such a strong censorship law. In Shirley Valentine there is a lot of risqu� language and many sexual innuendoes. The dialogue is a also very brief, there is no need for such long and perfectly formed sentences because the visuals give us the information, for example there are many close-up's of Shirley which give us the understanding which you cannot get in theatre. Also because of this extra medium the audience feels much closer to Shirley as we are let into her most intermit thoughts and feelings its much more personal, and because of this we are much more inclined to be sympathetic towards Shirley. ...read more.


Where on the other hand Billy is a lot harder to relate to. We she him come back at the end of the play and unpack his suitcase placing the calendars back into the sideboard cupboard. This gives the impression that he can never escape, and the audience feels sorry for Billy because of this but we also feel a lot more detached from Billy. Billy had the chance but didn't take it, he was not brave enough, but he also left Liz at the train station having brought the tickets for the both of them. Billy is still very naive and obviously still is not sure what he wants. Another comparison we can make is through the characters Joe and Geoffrey. Both are very strong and narrow-minded businessmen. They have no consideration for the feelings of others; they are chauvinistic, antagonistic and brusque. But in the end we see that Joe is starting to 'come round' and we love him for it but Geoffrey on the other hand is still just as stubborn. This behaviour reflects in the actions of Shirley and Billy. So in conclusion I think both of the plays offers very different things but also have striking similarities. Drama Coursework - A comparison between Billy Liar and Shirley Valentine Anjali Lockett Page 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Shirley Valentine section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Shirley Valentine essays

  1. Shirley Valentine

    This additionally conveys a monotonous life led by Shirley. Towards the closing stages of the play the audience feel content at the fact that Shirley has changed for the better, and that her dream has turned into reality. Russell's uses of flashbacks are imperative towards our understanding of Shirley's lifestyle.

  2. Shirley Valentine

    The division helps the audience as they think as if they are with Shirley through the changes. The way Russell has added the flashbacks helps the audience in understanding how she used to be and how she has become. Like when Shirley was talking about the wheel to the holidaymakers, this helped us know where she got this information from.

  1. Shirley Valentine.

    Shirley had a great time with Costas and on the beach. This shows that Shirley is becoming independent and is no longer dependant on others. The setting and costume are different in Greece and so helped because Greece is full of Sunshine and social life where as in Liverpool it's

  2. Shirley Valentine. How does Russell invite the audience to sympathise with Shirley?

    Shirley feels isolated, and so discusses her relationship with the wall, "He used to laugh, Joe. We both did. Hey, wall you remember when we first moved in here?"

  1. How does the dramatic technique used in the play help the audience to understand ...

    that "Shirley" was playful and enjoyed life to its fullest with her husband Joe.Then Shirley is seen in a pub with her friends in her thirties; these are shown as stories of parts of her life. Russell shows Shirley as she talks to the wall, she expresses all her emotions

  2. shirley valentine

    at the start of the screen play her monologues are about getting to know Shirley better through the use of flashbacks this allows us to feel an affinity with Shirley as we find out that she has had a difficult life from her school life - teachers not treating her

  1. Shirley Valentine

    And it was the geeks, I'll have you know- who were responsible for the most important invention of all-time wheel!" this shows a glimpse of Shirley Valentine, hence the transformation begins! Setting used by Willy Russell highlight's the difference between Shirley in Greece and Shirley in Liverpool by setting a

  2. Shirley Valentine-how does Russel encourage the audience to feel sympathy for Shirley?

    The use of graphic gives the opening of the story, where Shirley arriving home with the shopping into a small terraced house. She walks into the kitchen and begins to talk to the wall by saying "Hello, Walls". This immediately suggests that Shirley seems trapped and lonely.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work