• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A Comparison Between the Coping Mechanisms and Realisations Made While in Prison by Alba in House of the Spirits and Meursault in The Outsider

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Barbara Schmidt IB1 Supervisor: Dr. Kerry Vincent Developed Piece A Comparison Between the Coping Mechanisms and Realisations Made While in Prison by Alba in House of the Spirits and Meursault in The Outsider Alba in The House of the Spirits and Meursault in The Outsider display several survival strategies that are contrasting, yet there are some undeniable similarities worth noting. They come to contrasting realisations on the ultimate meaning of life, as Alba takes the decision to fight at all costs to preserve her life, while Meursault makes the opposite choice in taking a despondent attitude towards life and a fatalistic one towards death. Another contrast is that Alba's life has a definite cyclical nature, whereas Meursault's follows a typically existentialist linear form. Also, Meursault's acceptance of his guilt and his inability to form emotional bonds with people contributes to his resignation towards life, whereas Alba's knowledge of her innocence and her compassion towards others fuels her fight for life and her optimism. But both characters experience, to some extent, an alteration in personality as a result of their incarceration. As well, both characters occupy their minds with listing things and writing on imaginary paper in order to escape the horror of their ordeals. ...read more.

Middle

Allende writes "this allowed her to venture slowly out of the private circle of her terror"(467). She succeeds in converting negative emotions of despair and hopelessness into compassion and caring for others: "her fear began to ebb and she was able to feel compassion for the others" (467). Meursault, on the other hand, remains isolated throughout his ordeal, alone in his last hour as in every other hour of his life. He answers to no one, therefore he is made to face his demons alone, and through his acceptance of his situation and his survival, he is alone. After all, he faces no "divine justice" (113), only he reflects on his own life and actions and finds peace through his final judgement of himself: "I was guilty and I was paying for it and there was nothing more that could be asked of me" (113). The existentialist nature of Meursault's character and his detachment from other human beings does not allow him to connect with others during his struggle, nor does he need to in order to achieve final peace within himself before his death. ...read more.

Conclusion

The relative simplicity of the exercises she employs her mind in are the reason for maintaining her sanity in the face of hopelessness and desperation. The two characters' personal realisations on the meaning of life are opposing, and this determines their attitude towards their imprisonment. While it is true that the two characters' personalities were the deciding factors in their ultimate outlook on life, Meursault's indisputable guilt dashes any hope he may have had, and Alba's innocence drives her in her fight for freedom. Equally importantly, Alba's ability to relate to those around her through mutual compassion and support is a key motivator for her fight to live, whereas Meursault's solitary nature contributes to his fatalistic attitude. Alba succeeds in surviving her ordeal and through her strength defeats Esteban Garcia. This is her victory, her legacy. Meursault goes to his death with the realisation that the world is indifferent to his existence, and leaves no legacy behind. Nevertheless, I feel that his death isn't pointless. There is some victory in that he stays true to himself right until the end and I am sure that he leaves a lasting impression through his refusal to succumb to any social pressure, most notably his refusal to fake emotions that he doesn't feel. 1500 words ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Albert Camus section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Albert Camus essays

  1. The role of judgement in The Outsider

    "[Meursault retelling the prosecutor's argument] I'd asked him for his gun. I'd gone back with the intention of using it. I'd shot the Arab as I'd planned. I'd waited. And 'to make sure I'd done the job properly', I'd fired four more shots, deliberately and at point-blank range and with some kind of forethought" (96).

  2. EXISTENTIALISM IN THE OUTSIDER

    emotional whim of society and the values that it possesses at that present time in history. Mersault is sentenced to death in court. He is rather relieved about these news, as Camus says, " I'd [Meursault] felt my heart give this terrifying leap at the thought of having another twenty years to live."

  1. The Outsider

    113), he knew no one better, and there wasn't "anything or anyone" (p. 113) there. Still, the chaplain will not accept the fact that Meursault doesn't share his views on religion, and concludes with that fact that his "heart is blind" (p. 115) and that he "shall pray for" (p.

  2. The role of judgement in The OutsiderThe actions of Meursault, the protagonist in The ...

    of logical thought and Meursault's irrational nature does not allow him to have this logical thinking ability. To summarize, by calling Meursault "Mr Antichrist", the magistrate superimposes society's rational nature, which is in this case represented by Christianity, upon Meursault's irrational character and this leads to the fact that the magistrate also judges upon Meursault in terms of Christianity.

  1. People's perception of the protagonists as being indifferent in "The Metamorphosis" by Kafka and ...

    was that there should be a crowd of spectators at my execution and that they should greet me with cries of hatred.14" He hopes that his death would make the people who he lives among angry at him, for rejecting the rules by which they themselves have to obey.

  2. The Portrayal of Society in The Sound of Waves and The Outsider

    It is merely a matter of society's intolerance for something different, be it a person, an ideal, or an object. Shinji is a 'normal' Japanese fisherman - he fits in. He displays traditional emotions, those expected regarding the circumstances, such as his relationship with Hatsue.

  1. This is the commentary on the book "The Outsider" written by Albert Camus. I ...

    For example, he has problems with his ex-girlfriend, he beats and abuses her. He says to Meursault that he needs to punish her, which actually leads to conflict with the Arab. Raymond initiates action. Although he only seems to use Meursault, he actually testifies for him and feels a bit responsible.

  2. Nothing but a Metaphor - 'The Outsider'.

    A prime example of the law trying to make sense of something completely nonsensical in the novel is when the elderly reporter tells the protagonist that his story and that of the parricide to be judged the next day were the only stories worth covering.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work