• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A Comparison between 'The Signalman' by Charles Dickens and 'The Withered Arm' by Thomas Hardy.

Extracts from this document...


A Comparison between 'The Signalman' by Charles Dickens and 'The Withered Arm' by Thomas Hardy. 'The Signalman' written in 1866 by Charles Dickens and 'The Withered Arm' written in 1888 by Thomas Hardy. They were both written in the 19th century but 'The Signalman' was written earlier in the 19th century than 'The Withered Arm'. Both of the stories are mysteries but 'The Signalman' is also a ghost story and 'The Withered Arm' deals with the supernatural in a different way. Both 'The Signalman' and 'The Withered Arm' the stories are influenced by the writer's backgrounds. For example Hardy lived in Dorset and Dickens was also in a train crash that could have made him put the crash in the story as he could have been thinking about it at that time. In 'The Withered Arm' Gertrude was seen more as a high classed lady and Rhoda as an average type of person. But in 'The Signalman' there was only a slight hint. The titles of both stories do not explain much about the stories; though 'The Withered Arm' deals with more superstition rather than natural causes. ...read more.


After this happened she is run down that she wondered whether her past name calling of a 'witch' could be true or not. As she thought now that she might have 'malignant powers'. All this causes her to feel guilty and the one to blame. The end of Hardy's story is Gertrude trying to find a cure for her 'ailment'. The cure most successful is for her to 'touch with the limb the neck of a man who's been hanged', 'Before he's cold - just after he has been cut down'. Gertrude did not like the idea of doing this but she went along with it and went to a hanging to touch the criminal's limb. In the end the criminal turned out to be the son of Rhoda and Mr Lodge. Gertrude and Mr Lodge both die and Mr Lodge leaves his money to Rhoda. In 'The Withered Arm' there are a lot of different settings however in 'The Signalman' there is only one main setting. In both Hardy and Dickens's story there is a setting, which is 'isolated', quiet and away from everyone and everything. ...read more.


In 'The Withered Arm' and 'The Signalman' the theme is supernatural. In 'The Withered Arm' there is a good balance of narrative, description and dialogue. Hardy uses dialect because it was set in Dorset and this dialogue would have been used there in that time. Words like 'a' ready', 'tis' and 'ha'n't' where used in that period of time. 'The Withered Arm' uses different syntax as this is how it would have been used in the time it was set. For example 'he do bring home his bride tomorrow' would be written in this time as, he brings back his bride tomorrow. Hardy uses antiquated language typical of the period written in, Dickens also. Both writers make use of brackets much Dickens more than Hardy. In 'The Signalman' the signalman uses many rhetorical questions, showing that he could be nervous or scared of the spectre. I prefer 'The Withered Arm' as this is more interesting and is an easy story to read and understand. The storyline is better although there are more characters, settings, and relationships between people, which make it more interesting. 'The Signalman', I think is harder to understand although there are fewer characters, settings and relationships. Overall I think 'The Withered Arm' is the better of the two and I prefer it, as it is easy to understand. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Signalman section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Signalman essays

  1. Compare the two short stories, 'The Signalman' by Dickens and 'The Withered Arm by ...

    Both these settings are contrasted. The descriptions of the settings in the introduction help us to predict future plots. The atmosphere of 'The Signalman' suggests that the occurrence of a tragic or unnatural event is probable whereas in 'The Withered Arm', it is unpredictable and the setting does not give us any indication of future plots.

  2. Compare and Contrast "The Signalman" by Charles Dickens and "The Withered Arm" by Thomas ...

    The first story that was analysed was "The Signalman". It is apparent from the very beginning that it is encompassed by an air of tension and ambiguity, making it the mysterious and intriguing read that it is. The scene is set in a dark and 'unusually precipitous' railway cutting with a solitary figure, the signalman, standing by the line monitoring the track.

  1. The Judges House and The Signalman Comparison

    the visitor says '"Ah"' this is because he just found out that the phrase used by the train driver was the same as the dreaded phrase that the Signalman hated.

  2. Explain what makes a good mystery story, based on your understanding of 'The Red ...

    Watson proves a most satisfying. He accompanies Holmes at all times, is presented with the same clues but not achieve the same conclusion as Holmes as he is less experienced however we admire him as Holmes sees him worthy of escorting him on his cases.

  1. Compare the two short stories, "The Signalman" by Dickens and "The Withered Arm" by ...

    Also when the milkmaids are gossiping about the arrival of the new bride, they refer to Rhoda, "Tis hard for she" "He hadn't spoken to Rhoda for years," this suggests that there must have been a past affair between Rhoda and Farmer Lodge.

  2. Compare the literary styles of Dickens and Hardy useing 'The Signalman' and 'The Withered ...

    Rhoda and Gertrude are reunited at the end. In a way, the two stories are similar as their themes are based on the same topics: mystery, supernatural and the unknown. They both involve premonitions of fate and the future. In 'The Signalman�, the narrator attracts the attention of the signalman by shouting "Halloa!

  1. Prose study of 'The Signalman' by Charles Dickens,' The Superstitious Man's Story' by Thomas ...

    The narrator thinks him trustworthy and reliable. I found whilst reading the text, it somewhat of a mystery as to why the narrator and the signalman met in the first place, was it fate or was it a chance meet?

  2. A comparison between 'Lamb to the Slaughter' by Roald Dahl and 'The Signalman' by ...

    By placing a train track through the country, man has tried to control it but the country still has control. Man does not have total control over events. This is shown by the crash and the spectre.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work