• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A comparison of the Dagger scene, Act 2, Scene 1, from 'Macbeth' as presented by two different directors, Roman Polanski and Trevor Nunn.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Rachel Crick Year 10 Shakespeare Unit A comparison of the Dagger scene, Act 2, Scene 1, from 'Macbeth' as presented by two different directors, Roman Polanski and Trevor Nunn Shakespeare wrote 'Macbeth' a long time after this actual period of Scottish history. To help him, Shakespeare used historical stories that were written about Macbeth. His information source was a book written by the historian Raphael Holinshed 'Chronicles of England, Scotland and Ireland', published in 1587. Shakespeare amended this information. He selected, altered and added to the stories written by Holinshed to achieve maximum dramatic effect. Shakespeare felt that the original story of Macbeth would not captivate his audience, and so changed it to give greater dramatic interest. Scotland in the eleventh century was a violent country. Murder and killings to gain status were common. There was always threat of invasion and constant fighting and battles to control various parts of the country. Each warlord (thane) was in control of their own territory. There are many differences between Shakespeare's Macbeth and the Macbeth that ruled Scotland almost one thousand years ago. The real Macbeth was born in 1005, son of Findlaech, and a member of a great family that ruled Moray and Ross. He married Gruach, granddaughter to a High King of Scotland. Macbeth ruled Scotland for seventeen years, it was a prosperous reign and in those seventeen years he provided Scotland with stability. He united South and North Scotland. Macbeth was killed in 1057 at Peel Ring, Lumphanan in Mar after an invasion by Duncan's son Malcolm III. There is no evidence that Macbeth mixed with witchcraft and he was a strong supporter of the church. Macbeth was a bold character, strong willed and a good fighter. He was not weak and would not have given in to the witches and his wife. Also there is no historical evidence that his wife, Gruach, had an influence over her husband. ...read more.

Middle

The other is a video of a stage production by the Royal Shakespeare Company, directed by Trevor Nunn. The main differences between the two versions are the fact that one is a feature film and one is a filmed stage production. No special effects could be used in the Trevor Nunn version because it was filmed on stage. The only effects that could be used were sound and light effects. Roman Polanski concentrates on the visual aspect of the play, whereas Trevor Nunn cannot. Nunn has to rely on the actors' strengths, to portray, for example, the vision of the dagger, and convey the darkness and eeriness. Trevor Nunn even chose not to use any scenery and few props in his particular production, which also intensified the need for actors to use their own skills. Purists prefer to watch the Royal Shakespeare Company version. The number of people wanting to watch this performance is smaller because it is not advertised as a feature film. The Roman Polanski version was a feature film and this opportunity gave him a wider audience. It was felt that this version was more accessible and understandable than the purist version by Trevor Nunn. In the Roman Polanski version, we first see Lady Macbeth holding the jug of wine to give to the guards. She then walks in an open galleried landing which surrounds the courtyard. We hear Fleance and Banquo talking as they enter the courtyard. The scene is in darkness, but as Banquo and Fleance enter, they are carrying a torch. We are looking down on them, the camera being from Macbeth's point of view. Banquo drops his cloak and asks Fleance to take his sword. We briefly see the faces of Lady Macbeth and Macbeth as they look at each other worriedly. Banquo then asks Fleance to take his torch. This is not indicated in the stage directions, it is left up to the director to decide what will be given to Fleance when Banquo asks him 'Take thee that too'. ...read more.

Conclusion

Also, the camera angles were restricted, but he managed to overcome this by using a static camera used for close ups and medium close ups. The limited shots were hidden by the zooming in and out. This version was intentionally shot to bee eerie and dark. Roman Polanski, when describing Macbeth, thought that 'I see Macbeth as a young, open-faced warrior, who is gradually sucked into a whirlpool of events because of his ambition. When he meets the weird sisters and hears their prophecy, he's like the man who hopes to win a million-a gambler for high stakes.' Macbeth is shown as a man driven by his wife. We see his weaknesses and sympathise with him. His ambition is evident in both versions of the film. Ambition is the driving force behind Macbeth's life and it is his major weakness. When trying to resist murdering Duncan, he says 'I have no spur...but only/Vaulting ambition which o'erleaps itself' (act 1, scene 7). He does not realise the consequences of his ambition, nor does his wife. Trevor Nunn sees Macbeth as a strong and determined character. Macbeth's ambition is clearly very visible and this comes across well. He holds his head high, without any big doubts or fears about what he must do. He seems braver, and more confident than the Macbeth directed by Roman Polanski. Roman Polanski's Macbeth is clearly worried and anxious. He seems pressurised into killing the King. He pulls himself together through his soliloquy, and nervously walks to Duncan's chamber. My favourite version was the scene directed by Trevor Nunn. I found it easier to understand. Effects were not needed to help the audience understand because the actors spoke so immaculately and with meaning. I think that Trevor Nunn made good use of the stage and the camera angles. I also liked the Roman Polanski version because it has made Shakespeare more accessible to a wider audience because it was a feature film. Both of these versions clearly show the differences between the directors thoughts about Macbeth. Macbeth has been interpreted in two different ways, both of which work well. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Macbeth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Macbeth essays

  1. ACT 4, SCENE 1: EXPLAIN HOW THE WITCHES' BEHAVIOUR IN THIS SCENE MAKES AN ...

    The three apparitions also create fear, and they have a particular dramatic impact both on the audience and Macbeth. This is how at the end of the scene the audience should feel. Towards Macbeth, the audience should not be very sympathetic as they should reject what the apparitions told him

  2. Explain what Act 1, Scene 7 tells us about the characters of Macbeth and ...

    someone else to do her deeds for her. This once again shows her femininity as a skill, perhaps meaning Shakespeare intended his audience to realise that, like the brute strength of masculinity, the cunningness of femininity can too be used as an advantage. Lady Macbeth also emotionally blackmails Macbeth.

  1. Macbeth Film Comparison

    This could show Macbeth's desire for a prettier woman in the schoolgirls, and reality- the less attractive sight of his wife; but in the end, no-one knows what he is thinking, just that he is not comforting his wife. Here, the atmosphere is quite tense- lots of things are happening

  2. Macbeth - Imagine you are the director of Act One, Scene Seven - Write ...

    the unrest in the macrocosm, which in this case is the sky, reflects the microcosm, which in this case is the castle. Structure has been effectively used here, as Lady Macbeth's early predictions had now been validated, thus improving the understanding of the audience and proving her insightfulness.

  1. Comparison between Roman Polanski’s Macbeth and Macbeth on the Estate

    In Macbeth on the Estate Lady Macbeth's appears appealing to males, basically showing herself off. I think she does this so that when she suggests killing the king he looks at her and realises that he cannot say no to someone so beautiful.

  2. Look at Act 1, Scene 5, Act 1, Scene 7, Act 2, Scene 2, ...

    Macbeth replies with admiration, 'Bring forth men-children only; for thy undaunted mettle should compose nothing but males.' The only input from Macbeth is that he goes on to improve the plan by saying that they should use the attendants daggers to do the deed, and then smear Duncan's blood on the attendants.

  1. How does shakespeare create a sense of evil and disorder in act 1 of ...

    Shakespeare highlights the witches' power through their ability to see into the future, which, being supernatural would bring the audience into the realm of evil magic. Shakespeare shows that the witches are also very intelligent, as Macbeth is easily manipulated by their premonitions for him to be king, and his thoughts instantly turn to murder.

  2. Macbeth Act 1 Scene 1 Analysis

    darkness tell us truths, Win us with honest trifles, to betray's In deepest consequence. Cousins, a word, I pray you. His words convey the message that the witches are not to be trusted and that if he believes in their words completely, he might burn with an unholy desire for the crown.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work