• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A comparison of the Zeffirelli and Luhrman versions of the 'Romeo and Juliet' Film

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

A comparison of the Zeffirelli and Luhrman versions of the 'Romeo and Juliet' Film William Shakespeare's play 'Romeo and Juliet' is a very popular tragedy and has been for hundreds of years. However, the play from the script runs for around three hours, so in recent times two films have been made of the play. One is the Zeffirelli film and the other the Luhrman film. These films do not run for 3 hours, however. Therefore these films differ from the play in many ways, have scenes cut out and bits added for effect. Not only do these films differ from the play, they differ in many ways from each other. In both of the films many of the long and winding speeches are shortened a lot, and in some cases are cut out completely. This helps to shorten the films, as there is not as much to say. In some cases little scenes are omitted and some characters have even been left out. The Zeffirelli film has the Montagues and Capulets as they are in the play. However, in the Luhrman film there is a new Capulet, Abra, although he does not play much part in the story. There is no such character in the Zeffirelli film. Zeffirelli stays more true to Shakespeare than Luhrman does as he sticks with many things that would be the case in Shakespeare's time. ...read more.

Middle

The balcony scene in both comes straight in instead of having a chorus and in both films the balcony scene is full as it is one of the famous scenes of the play. Also the wedding is not shown in the Zeffirelli or the play itself, however in the Luhrman film it is shown. In both films the violence scenes are dramatised and lengthened and in both the fight scene with Romeo, Tybalt and Mercutio is lengthened and made a key event in the play. In both there is a lot of moving from place to place, but probably more so in the Zeffirelli. Both use the fact that Romeo was standing in front of Mercutio lead to Mercutio's death, as it is done in the play. The remainder of the scene is cut very short, with Juliet and Romeo's sad speeches shortened considerably. In the Zeffirelli film their farewell scene is quite hasty but in the Luhrman film they are seen in bed together, spending time together before Romeo leaves. Both films then have scenes where Capulet forces Juliet into marrying Paris and Juliet then goes to Friar Lawrence to plan the fake death. In the Zeffirelli, Friar Lawrence's plan for Juliet to 'die' is quite lengthy, although in the Luhrman it is reasonably short. Her funeral is a larger event. Another thing the two films have in common is that there is no Paris present in Act 5. ...read more.

Conclusion

Tybalt is just a menacing character that is reasonably normal in the Zeffirelli film but in the Luhrman film Tybalt is a posing, menacing man who coats himself in leather. In both films Tybalt is seen flirting with Lady Capulet, more so in the Luhrman where some actual incest is involved. None of the flirting is in the play. In addition, Paris is named Dave Paris in the Luhrman film. The soundtrack in the Zeffirelli film is orchestral and romantic. Luhrman uses some pop and some classical music. Both films are colourful, although the Zeffirelli is more artistic. The Luhrman film is very different where there is music blaring, lights flashing and the camera tilts. The costume in the Zeffirelli stays true to Shakespeare and is sixteenth century dress, although in the Luhrman the dress is modern and completely different. Overall, I think that the Luhrman version of the film is the better of the two. It is more modern and despite the language staying the same as old modern English, it is easier to understand. The effects are good and the characters look more like we would see in the modern day. The Zeffirelli film is a good film but it harder to understand and minds may wander while watching the film. For the modern day audience, I think that the Luhrman film is the better film to watch. Chris Rootkin IVA ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Romeo and Juliet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Romeo and Juliet essays

  1. A Comparison of Two Film Versions of Romeo and Juliet.

    Tybalt then started on him. In this version, Mercutio was slashed across the stomach with a piece of broken glass, which Tybalt had picked up. The fight was over within 30 seconds. As Mercutio staggered across the beach, a storm arose to show the anger of the characters.

  2. Look closely at the treatment of love in Shakespeare's play and in the Zeffirelli ...

    The film he made would have been more popular at the time when he made it in comparison to now (nearly 40 years later on ). In many scenes throughout the play the love- hate relationship is very clear more so in Act 1 Scene 5.

  1. A Comparison between the film openings of two versions of Romeo and Juliet, focusing ...

    Sound and music play an important role in the presentation of a film and both directors have used this effectively. Baz Luhrmann uses this cleverly to a greater effect as compared to Zeffirelli. An example of this is when the Capulets were introduced in the film to the strains of wild-western music themes giving a classy, stylish look.

  2. Act 3 scene 1 is interpreted in very different ways by Zeffirelli and Luhrman. ...

    as my own, be satisfied' Mercutio is mortified that Romeo is refusing to fight Tybalt and takes matters into his own hands, and Tybalt accepts. Romeo tries to make peace between the two, and Mercutio gets hurt under Romeos arm.

  1. Romeo & Juliet - comparison of film versions

    At this point Lord Capulet has rejected her. Then she goes to her mother and pleds to her, but she doesn't want to listen to her. Then she goes to the nurse. The one she usually goes to when shes in need the most, she turns a blind eye and agrees with her father.

  2. Baz Luhrman - Find out the challenges he faced and how he solved them ...

    it is horrible and funny and Baz Luhrman does not want this because then the audience will not be able to concentrate on the film. The play was set in Verona and so Baz Luhrman made the play set in Verona, there was a feud between two powerful families which Baz Luhrman adapted and made them quarrel because of businesses.

  1. There have been many different versions of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet'. Describe the two ...

    The prologue has many words and sentences that stand out. One phrase that really stands out are when the lovers are described as 'star-crossed' this suggests that their love was controlled by fate. Shakespeare explains the situation by telling us the setting is in 'fair Verona' and it is a city of 'ancient grudge'.

  2. A Comparison Of Luhrman's and Zeffirelli's film Versions Of Romeo And Juliet

    The characters also appear on screen with their name next to them. There is also text to tell the audience how each character is related to either Romeo or Juliet. The camera is constantly panning from side to side. As soon as you see the title you get a hint

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work