A Comparison of Two Love Poems

Authors Avatar

Sarah Tribedi

A Comparison of Two Love Poems

In this essay I am going to compare ‘To His Coy Mistress’, written around 1640 by Andrew Marvell, with ‘The Sun Rising’, written by John Donne around 1600. Although they are both love poems of a kind, they are different many ways, especially their attitudes to women, love and time.

The speaker in ‘To His Coy Mistress’ is a guy, trying to persuade a woman to have sex with him. She is being ‘coy’, which suggests she is being shy on a playful, teasing or provocative way. To try and persuade her, he uses a three-stage argument – If, But, Therefore.

The ‘If’ section of the poem says that if they had forever, he would woo her slowly, and respect her honour by not hurrying her:

                        “Had we but world enough, and time

                         This coyness, Lady, were no crime”

He feels she deserves to be wooed slowly, and be flattered and praised:

                        “For, Lady, you deserve this state

                        Nor would I love at lower rate”

This section of the poem is praising and flattering, but joking and a bit nudge nudge. For example:

                        “My vegetable love would grow,

                         Vaster than empires and more slow”

Join now!

This means he would have lots of love for her, and it would be natural and organic. But it also implies that his ‘vegetable’ would grow very big, and he’s boasting to her about it. He’s trying to subconsciously get the lady to think in a sexual way. The same goes with:

                        “Two thousand to adore each breast,

                         But thirty thousand to the rest”

He’s gradually praising her body; her forehead and eyes, then her breasts, and then ‘the rest’. Working his way downward, this would imply her groin area – again, trying to get her to think sexually.

...

This is a preview of the whole essay