• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A cruel bully A fine leader of men Which do you think is the more accurate description of Stanhope? Support your ideas with details from Sherriffs writing.

Extracts from this document...


Ellen Weerasekera 10H Mr Gerig Word Count: 1033 QUESTION A: ?A cruel bully? ?A fine leader of men? Which do you think is the more accurate description of Stanhope? Support your ideas with details from Sherriff?s writing. R.C Sherriff represents Stanhope in many contrasting situations throughout Journey?s End. In each circumstance he is portrayed in a different way depending on the scenario. ?A fine leader of men? is the more accurate statement to describe Stanhope, although the reader is often left with mixed opinions of this diverse character. The gossip of the other characters in the play help to signify Stanhope?s personality; this is a major part of the character development as well as the contrast of Stanhope and Raleigh. Although R.C Sherriff first introduces Stanhope as a callous character when Hardy speaks of him to Osborne, when he is presented for the first time, he does not seem quite as harsh as originally portrayed. Stanhope?s role as a leader of the battalion is often very successful and he seems professional and extremely capable of being in charge of other soldiers. ...read more.


The death of Osborne is expected to evoke a strong reaction from Stanhope, as it was suggested that Osborne was his closest friend. However Stanhope proceeds with the celebratory dinner, and is depicted in high spirits. This reaction is not expected; however the he strain he is under is shown when he asks for more alcohol, which revisits the detail that drinking is Stanhope?s coping mechanism for the terrors of war. As the scene continues, it is evident that he is trying to divert his and the other soldier?s minds from the topic of Osborne?s death. This effort shows good leadership skills as it suggests that Stanhope was trying to keep the battalion together and he did not want any of the other soldiers to be distressed or distracted. This is a good quality as it shows that Stanhope is considerate and professional and does not let his feelings get in the way of his position. However later on in this scene, Stanhope becomes frustrated when Hibbert and Trotter start to speak of Raleigh and the raid. ...read more.


Stanhope confesses to Osborne when drunk ?if I went up those steps into the front line ? without being doped with whisky ? I?d go mad with fright.? Sherriff does this to create a vulnerable side to Stanhope yet also to show how Stanhope has hidden this from the other soldiers to give them moral inspiration and confidence. In conclusion, neither statements provide a completely accurate description Stanhope?s character, however ?a fine leader of men? is more truthful than ?a cruel bully?. This is because all of Stanhope?s actions, whether they are positive or negative, were primarily to protect all of the soldiers in his battalion and he always has their best interests in mind. However they are often portrayed in a rather harmful or unproductive way and this gives the reader a bad impression of Stanhope. Overall Stanhope is extremely committed to his position and is not a bully at all, only ever being critical and harsh when necessary. Any point where Stanhope shouts at another soldier, in fact just shows that he is a fine leader as he must maintain respect and discipline within the battalion and he is only ensuring this is present. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE RC Sheriff section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE RC Sheriff essays

  1. In what ways does R.C.Sherriff re-create for his audience the tremendous stress and fear ...

    He has arrived to relieve Hardy of his role. They become involved in a conversation about the duration of their stay at the front line and the circumstances they're expected to adapt to e.g. state of trenches. "Mustn't hang your legs too low, or the rats gnaw your boots" From

  2. Travel Writing.

    At that point I froze for a second then burst out in a fit of laughter, everyone o the tram then looked round at me wondering whether I was having a fit or whether I was laughing at the suicidal man's misfortunes.

  1. In what ways does R.C.Sherriff re-create for his audience the tremendous stress and fear ...

    This comment may shock the audience and make them realise that hardy is also a very shallow individual. These mixed opinions continue throughout the discussion and many characteristics of Stanhope become apparent to us. His experience and his knowledge are the chief qualities to his unique identity yet the prime down-fall is his heavy drinking.

  2. What characteristics of Stanhopes personality do you think this passage reveals? Support your answer ...

    STANHOPE is also branded a pessimist in this passage. When RALEIGH arrives at his battalion, STANHOPE immediately starts thinking negatively about his presence, remarking, "It's rather damnable for that boy...to have come to me.

  1. Write an analysis of R. C. Sherriffs presentation of soldiers under stress in the ...

    attitude towards war at that time and also the class differences between soldiers in the army. Officers in the Crimean War did not necessarily have any more military expertise or experience than the soldiers; they were officers because they were middle or upper class.

  2. Explain the ways in which R C Sherriff conveys a sense

    Bottles, glasses and papers need to be piled high on the small table. The dugout should be poorly lit, by a candle or oil lamp. The sky, visible through the door, needs to be bright. The contrast between light and dark represents the soldiers' confinement versus the world that they knew before the war.

  1. Creative writing

    Following our usual routine after breakfast, the twins Ben and Pete, and I trekked up the small hill to the tennis courts. Situated in a small clearing, the tennis courts were surrounded imposingly by the evergreen forest. Chatting away, completely oblivious to everything, we were suddenly stopped dead in our tracks by a freakish noise.

  2. Explore Sherriff's presentation in

    They were frightfully annoyed. OSBORNE: I know. There's nothing worse than dirt in your tea. Clearly, there are many things worse than 'dirt in your tea', and one would expect an adjective that was rather stronger than 'annoyed' to describe the men's reaction to the fact that they were being bombed.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work