• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A Man For All Seasons Essay

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

A Man For All Seasons Act II Scene 8 (The Trial Scene) The trial scene is the climax of the play, everything the rest of the play has been leading up to. In another story, this would be the most furiously paced and relentless section of the prose, and whilst this is admittedly somewhat true here, the fact the audience know of More's fate from the start of the play changes its complexion. The scene encompasses a clashing of two opposite consciences, in More and Rich, as well as two opposing ideologies, in More and Cromwell. The scene quickly devolves into a battle of words rather than moral stance, but is effective in its attempts to captivate the audience. The overriding message of this section of the play is that, even with the now very real (and, for the first time, very present) threat of death hanging in the air, More still has the integrity and conscience to stick to his beliefs and serve his God. The character himself is inspirational since very few people who ever read or see the play will act in a similar manner - most would opt to save themselves well before this order in proceedings is even in sight. This scene is probably the most interesting in the play in terms of the volume and impact the stage directions have on the events. ...read more.

Middle

The fact that Rich has to commit the 'holy crime' (lying under oath) in order to finally suitably incriminate More is testament to More's self-assurance and complete faith in his religion and his God. The final betrayal of More, at the hands of Rich's false testimony, leads More to a final grimace of pain, as he comes to the realisation that Rich has sold his soul not for the whole world, but for a post of meagre power. "Why, Richard, it profits a man nothing to give his soul for the whole world... But for Wales!" This highlights how saddened More is by this final betrayal, and this is very effective in the scene as a whole as it illustrates how More's 'acquaintanceships' become his ultimate downfall, no matter how many he tried to sever (like Norfolk's). The Common Man has a seemingly docile and benevolent role to play in the drama up until this scene - from this point onwards, the intention of the playwright to install the Common Man as a person who will go out of his way to save himself, even at the expense of great men such as More, as well as liken him to the audience themselves. The fact that the roles that the Common Man begins to take become increasingly more malevolent towards More, from the completely innocent boatman, through to the jailer, foreman of the jury and eventually even the executioner in the next, conclusive, scene, shows this. ...read more.

Conclusion

Without Rich's false testimony, the sheer difference in thoughts and motives would have resulted in complete stalemate. The amount of fruitless bargaining from one side to the other, despite the clear iron-clad resolution that both sides hold, is interesting to witness. Cromwell in particular never gives up on convincing More to sign the document, despite how staunch More is in defending his position. In fact, in a final section of the court scene, Norfolk gives More one last chance which he totally rejects. "...I am empowered to tell you that even now - No no. It cannot be." The sheer volume of rhetoric from either side shows just how the case has already been decided and there is little need for deliberation. This is interesting and the playwright seems to wish to highlight how unnecessary the entire scene is made, and how pointless a court system is when the decision has been made behind closed doors. The court scene of 'A Man For All Seasons' is interesting in that it offers a multitude of insights into a couple of the most interesting characters in modern written drama. The characters of More, Cromwell and Rich all have very intriguing nuances in their characterisation that make this scene, and its setup as a clash of, in particular two, heavily opinionated and heavily driven characters. In terms of logistics, this scene depicts a realistic court of the time superbly, but beneath the surface of it lie some of the most contentious issues - and most intriguing characters - in the modern English language. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Other Authors section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Other Authors essays

  1. How does Ayub Khan-Din portray conflict in the play East is East

    And they were laughing at me because I was laughing." This links with not only Abdul developing as a character, but with the theme of culture, which the writer uses to portray conflict. This is because racist jokes are being made in a time when there was a lot more

  2. Looking closely at Pygmalion, consider the relationship between Higgins and Eliza. Where do ...

    Eliza begins to speak to Pickering, leaving Higgins out of the conversation and when he interrupts, Eliza answers him with confidence and continues her original discussion.

  1. How does Shaw draw the audience's attention to issues of social class in Act ...

    that one would have if they belonged to either the working or upper class. Shaw uses several different techniques to convey his ideas about social class and equality. The humour in the play and Act II in particular really draws the audience attention to matters of social class especially an audience in this day and age.

  2. What Do The Audience Learn About Sheila Birling In Act 1?

    For this she blamed the girl. Finally, she uses her social class to her advantage and even admits it as when the Inspector asks, "So you used the power you had, ... to punish the girl." In defeat she admits "Yes, but it didn't seem to be anything terrible at the time."

  1. Arcadia Essay - Thomasina

    This line from Lady Croom demonstrates to the audience that she clearly does not spend any time with her daughter, so little that she does not even know her age. She also asks her age again later on in the play.

  2. An Essay Comparing the Different Techniques Used In Supernatural/Horror Stories

    "But I am troubled sir, I am troubled." He is a grave, remarkably exact and vigilant. Maybe this is all to do with his past life; however it's been said that he was highly intelligent and "about his stations". This makes you wonder why he was signalman, when he could've had a better job.

  1. Bamforth essay

    He is an unlikeable character who tries to control the men by using brute force and pulling rank on the others. When the Japanese soldier is captured Johnstone has no respect for him and doesn't see him as a human being, treating him very cruelly.

  2. Comparing the characters of Walter Mitty and Billy Liar.

    4--- 5--- Walter Mitty has in fact an invert personality that leads the people around him to neglect his opinions, though he has very few that he expresses. ?Does it ever occur to you that I am sometimes thinking??, I could infer from this quote that Mitty reveals what goes through his mind to his wife.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work