• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

After Reading Three Crime Stories, Which Detective Do You Find Most Believeable?

Extracts from this document...


AFTER READING THREE CRIME STORIES, WHICH DETECTIVE DO YOU FIND MOST BELIEVEABLE? Over the last few weeks I have thoroughly analyzed four uniquely different detective stories. Each story was gripping and compelling in its own way. The first story I read was titled 'A Wife in a Million' by Val McDermid. Basically in this story detective Maggie Staniforth is called in to investigate mysterious murders occurring in the area, whilst trying to keep her relationship under control. The second story is titled 'The Man with the twisted Lip' written by the legendary Sir Arthur Conan Doyle'. In this detective story Detective Sherlock Holmes and his partner Dr James Watson try to unravel an ominous case where a man seems to vanish without a trace. In this case Holmes has to use all his legendary detective qualities to unravel a truly bizarre case. The third story which I read was titled 'superfluous Murder' written by Milward Kennedy. In this ironic story Mr. John Mansbridge attempts to kill his cousin Felix Mansbridge in a bitter money dispute, however it becomes evident that John Mansbridge is too smart for his own good, and it is up to the detective to unravel a truly superfluous murder. ...read more.


evidence, looks at something from all angles, comes to a conclusion and unlike the detective in 'Superfluous Murder' is open to other ideas "The impression of a woman may be more valuable than the conclusion of an analytical reasoner..." and "...maybe you will see a spark where all is dark to me" Also what makes Sherlock Holmes more believable is like Maggie in 'A Wife in a Million' he is devoted to his work "...his mind would go for days, and even for a week, without rest". Also unlike Maggie in 'A Wife in a Million' Sherlock Holmes always keeps his emotions under control and doesn't let anything get in the way of him solving the case. Something else which makes Sherlock Holmes believable is that he was not the perfect detective as he did make mistakes whilst trying to solve the case. For instance Holmes assumed that Neville St.Clare was dead before he read his letter, but then later he finds out that Neville St.Clare is still alive. Despite all of this I believe that the ending of the story made the detective a bit less convincing, as I believe that it would be unlikely for a detective to just waltz into a murder suspect's room without any objections from the police officer on duty. ...read more.


Since he came from America "I am American by birth and by upbringing" it is surprising that he doesn't sound very American at all, in my opinion he sounds more British than American. So basically it would take much more than an once of shag and five pillows to make me believe that these detectives were something other than a work of fiction. My conclusion to reading all four of these stories is that the detective in Superfluous Murder is the most convincing out of all five detectives I have studied. I believe this as this detective basically had all the good points of all the other detectives and very few of the bad points. The only debatable thing about this detective is the fact that he is not described as a character and you do not get any idea of his personal life like Maggie in 'a wife in a million'. However the sheer ease in which he solves a bizarre crime is excellent and he uses all the skill a real life detective would need. To sum it up, this detective was so believable that it was hard to believe my self that the detective in 'superfluous murder' was fictional. 1736 words English Homework Folasayo Ogundele ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Arthur Conan Doyle section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Arthur Conan Doyle essays

  1. Compare and contrast four different crime stories, 'A wife in a million', 'Superfluous murder', ...

    Of the four detectives, I find Maggie one of the most realistic but I do not believe that she has the skills of some of her rivals. One of these rival detectives is the Superintendent who doesn't work very hard but has great detective skills which help him easily solve the case.

  2. An essay to investigate the disturbing and reassuring aspects in the three stories

    The author uses very 'gothic' features in the Speckled Band. For example, there is reference to the middle ages as Dr. Roylott comes from 'one of the oldest Saxon families in England' which is an illustration of one gothic feature.

  1. In the beginning of my second story, written by Charles Dickens, The Signalman, the ...

    In my opinion, the reason he accepts the job offer, although he has aknowledged/he is aware of the suspisious terms/circumstances, because he seems to be in a desperate stage in his life. The reader may have the opinion that he is vunerable, but after reading through to the end, the

  2. How do the two detective stories reflect the eras they were written in?

    there is perhaps a slight element of mystery/deceit to his hero: The movement seemed to be a thing imperfectly perceived, an error of vision. But this touch of mystery is masked by Reseck's lack of self-belief and relatively un-dynamic approach when compared to Holmes.

  1. Introduction and Conclusion

    However, Holmes does not only have a methodical approach to solving crime, but a scientific approach that many other detectives do not possess. This scientific approach to problem solving is shown numerous times throughout the novel; an example of it is when Holmes is analyzing the walking stick in the opening chapter.

  2. Comparison Of Two 19th Century Crime Stories.

    Not in any way, does Watson articulate a sentiment of jealousy towards his partner, though he performs his best to assist his partner in his cases. Holmes, one of the more prominent characters, is much more consistent and knowledgeable

  1. To what extent do the detective fiction stories looked at imitate 'The Murders in ...

    This gives the reader the impression that Dupin doesn't like the Police and that Dupin thinks a lot of himself. This is also apparent with Holmes. There was a case in 'The Speckled Band' when Holmes criticised the Police because they did not search the room thoroughly.

  2. After reading four crime stories, which detective do you find most convincing?

    The detective in 'The Man with the Twisted Lip' is the worlds most heard of detective called Sherlock Holmes. From the beginning of the story you hear of him unlike the detective in 'Superfluous Murder'. From the story we find out that Sherlock is very assertive "it was difficult to

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work