• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

An EVil Cradling - Rape Commentary

Extracts from this document...


This passage from Brian Keenan's 'An Evil Cradling' describes in first person narrative the scene when Said beats Brian in a manner analogous to a rape. This event gives us an insight into the guard's weaknesses and their dependency on the hostages, making them - in a paradoxical way- the actual prisoners. On the other hand, Brian's and John's defiance and mutual support suggest the rising determination which gives them control over the guards. Throughout this passage, the author demonstrates us that mental resistance is more powerful than any physical abuse, and Brian even states that the later feeds the first. The narrator claims that 'There was a part of me they could never bind nor abuse nor take from me'. This suggests that physical maltreatment will never be able to reach into people's minds, because mental strength cannot be bent. Brian also discovers that his 'resistance was a joyful thing' and that the more he was beaten the stronger he became. ...read more.


A 'lover' implies a need for love and possibly sex. However, the guard's strict religious views try to inhibit these natural feelings, and as the women in Lebanon are forbidden from having relationships with men before they are married, many men might find themselves in a controversial situation. To shows their masculinity, they turn into "violent lovers" and try to prove their power by physically subduing others. Brian's summary of Said as 'a man so filled with fear' and 'fascinated by violence and obsessed with sex' seems to confirm this point. The guards are fearful and confused because of their repressed emotions that cause them frustration and anger. This explains their sudden changes in behaviour that occur throughout the novel - from being caring and innocent into beating and humiliating the prisoners. Said is illustrated by the narrator as a wild and repugnant, almost animal-like person. While beating the prisoners the guard is silent and never talks to them. This implies his savagery, almost as if he lost his ability to speak, which makes him similar to an animal. ...read more.


After the fierce scene, the two 'whispered soft words of comfort and reassurance to each other'. This emphasises the power of love, friendship, mutual support and provides a more positive and emotional sight after the violent event of "the rape". Throughout the novel the hostages and the guards try to overcome their own fears, doubts and frustrations. This passage from the chapter 'Rape' illustrates the ways in which they attempt to do so. Brian and John conquer these negative feelings by supporting, loving and laughing with each other. However, the confined fanatical views of the guards don't allow them to do so, so they seek control and relief by physically abusing others. In spite of this it seems that the psychological defiance of the hostages is a more powerful weapon than the beatings of the guards and so the ones that are somewhat in control in the prison are not the sentry, but the prisoners themselves. In this way, the author nicely concludes that humane and caring behaviour will triumph over brutality and violence. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Miscellaneous essays

  1. Adrian Mole Chapter Notes

    Adrian lied and said that the dog picked up off the streets. Pandora and the rest of the Red Sock Committee were waiting at Pandora's house. Pandora's parents were introduced to Adrian, they were both Labour supporters and admired the stand that Adrian was making.

  2. A Commentary on Idols by Tim Gautreaux

    Obie is portrayed as a realist from these actions as he knows when it is necessary to move on, however Julian is overly concerned with making an image of himself to even realize that he is living in his imagination.

  1. Defiance and Resistance

    He cleansed himself at the trial, standing for what he knew was right and died a righteous person. Though he stayed away from church, he became more pure than the common Puritans, dying as a martyr like the original apostles. He learned what truth meant through his suffering.

  2. Explore the representation of Evil in Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde

    a rather explosive reaction to meeting a complete stranger making Hyde even more mysterious. In the second instance Hyde crossed paths with a very important man called Sir Danvers Carew. They held a brief convocation before Hyde lost his temper and battered him to death.

  1. A summary of Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte

    with Blanche ended when he pretended to have less money than she considered acceptable. Rochester talks frequently of what he is doing as being wrong, but claims his love and care for Jane will atone for it. As readers, we think there could be something sinister behind this.

  2. Okonkwo - strengths and weaknesses

    At the age of 18, Okonkwo shot into fame by becoming the greatest wrestler in Umuofia and other nearby villages. With two barns, two titles, three wives and eight children, Okonkwo was on the rise.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work