• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Analyse the techniques used to make the opening battle sequence of Saving |Private Ryan both shocking and realistic. Comment on how effective it is as an introduction to the film.

Extracts from this document...


Analyse the techniques used to make the opening battle sequence of Saving |Private Ryan both shocking and realistic. Comment on how effective it is as an introduction to the film. Saving Private Ryan is a war film with a difference directed by Steven Speilberg depicting the world war battles of Normandy. It was made in 1998 and was based on a true story, the main character playing the part of 'Sgt. Frederick (Fritz) Niland'. However, some details were amended when making the film; for example the real mother of Sgt. Frederick was not a widow, nor did she receive all letters confirming the death of her sons at once. On top of this, one of the brothers presumed dead was actually found later on as a prisoner and was returned home. Saving Private Ryan, on the other hand follows the mission of a band of 8 soldiers sent to save a lowly Private to console his mother's grief over the deaths of her other 3 children. The slight change in the plot, although not exactly true, helps to personalise the war by focusing on a group of main characters and putting us more in the position of soldiers, feeling the sense of loss and disheartenment when they lose a man, and seeing everything through their eyes, particularly those of the main protagonist 'Captain Miller'. Unlike most traditional war films, which can often 'glamorise' war, Saving Private Ryan breaks the concept and instead focuses on the sheer carnage and the mental, physical and emotional damage war causes. Speilberg says 'The last thing I wanted to do in this picture was use the war simply as a springboard for action-adventure. I was looking for realism all the time'. Most noticeably, the plot revolves around a group of eight soldiers who don't actually believe in their mission, continually questioning-and making the audience question- the sense of it all. ...read more.


Even underwater though, the bullets still zap through to the men, which makes the audience realise that in a battle, there is nowhere they can hide to be safe. Throughout, the diagetic sound of gunfire dominates scenes, though there are other intervals in which Steilberg ceases it to enable the audience to concentrate on other things. For example; halfway through, the Captain is shell-shocked as an Image 2: soldiers shouting to Captain Miller for help Show the desperation of the situation as even the Man in charge is helpless. explosion occurs right near him, and the sound is again muted as if to get inside his persona and experience it through his eyes. At this point the audience get a chance to look round at various, individual snapshots of the battle: men crying, screaming, explosions. A man shouts out to him 'What now Sir??' which we only know from lip reading, but Captain Miller stays shocked and confused. It is times like this in the scene that makes the viewers realise how chaotic everything was, the fact that the man who was supposedly in charge can't give out instructions, let alone hear others. This is shocking for the audience because they see how helpless the soldiers were in combat like this. Towards the end of the scene, the relentless gunshots and bullets go quieter for a moment, as a sniper waits to take his shots. There is a moment of quiet, and we hear him muttering prayers and bible quotes. This keeps the audience alert to everything, shows the different parts people had to play. Camera techniques are extremely effective in the film, being jerky and with the characters all the time. Steilberg quotes 'I wanted to hit the sets much like a newsreel cameraman following soldiers in to war' and this was certainly achieved. Everything is always jerky, like the viewpoint of one of the running, uncertain soldiers, to make the audience relate the film to a news documentary and this is achieved with the use of unsteady, handheld cameras. ...read more.


These jump cuts between the german's and American's enable the audience to witness the battle from both points of view, to prevent any biased views given that Speilberg is American. It also enables the audience to put themselves in the same position as the troops and see themselves what they were having to deal with. Again, the words 'Omaha Beach June 1944' are edited, and this is for the newsreel/documented event effect, which makes everything more shocking for an audience. Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed the film, despite its not so endearing theme and horrific content. Speilberg started the film with a violent, shocking scene so as to surprise the audience, particularly with the contrast of the peaceful scene before it. Although I don't think anything could prepare you for scenes like the one this film held, the Omaha Beach battle certainly gave me an idea of the awfulness and terror of war and therefore the following events in the plot. In response to the main question, I did find the opening scene-and whole film- shocking, but I am not sure how realistic it was, and I don't think anyone can judge it unless they have been in that situation themselves. Speilberg makes it as realistic as possible though, particularly with the use of the hand held cameras, and throughout the audience will have felt extremely close to all the action. It is an excellent introduction to the film because of the action, not just Captain Miller's, but other soldiers who the audience are later introduced to. Speilberg always had chaos on screen and there was never a dull moment; as dull as a moment can be in a battle. This film was a great award winner, and stood out from other films because of the emotions it could provoke in people, and the highly effective directing skills of Steven Speilberg. A fantastically, depressingly, shocking and realistic war film. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Writing to Argue, Persuade and Advise section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Writing to Argue, Persuade and Advise essays

  1. How do H.G Wells and W.W Jacobs create tension and fear in The Monkeys ...

    Maricel fact file continues by stating; 'He does casual work as a fisherman and labourer, but even the work is available his pay does not meet the family needs'.

  2. Of Mice and Men - Loneliness

    Crooks is the sole Negro on the ranch. He is described as a "proud, aloof man...his eyes lay deep in his head, and...seemed to glitter with intensity. His lean face was lined with deep black wrinkles, and he had thin, pain-tightened lips..."

  1. -With detailed reference to Act 1 Scene 5 of Romeo and Juliet, explain how ...

    he was madly in love with Rosaline just before the party and know he is comparing Juliet to doves and light, this shows Romeo's character to be very fickle, line 51, "Forswear it sight, For I ne'er saw beauty till this night" this is another example of how fickle Romeo

  2. How Is tension created in Jaws the Film

    Another device the director uses is to have the background sounds only playing straight after an attack. The use of the camera can show and create a lot of built up suspense and tension through the way it is used.

  1. Analyse Review Comment- Sexism

    As well as this, women's' achievements in the workplace are now being shown in the media. Of the thirty-two consultants on Holby City and Casualty, twenty-five were women, according to data from the BBC. This shows that women are being more readily recognised as top earners, and that the position

  2. Analyse, review compare and comment on the features used in advertisements.

    - it's a very simple advert giving a direct message: buy Skechers because Christina Aguilera wears them. However, it is also slightly unconventional as this advertisement, unlike most examples of celebrity endorsement, seems to be working both ways - her album cover appears top right with the message 'get stripped'.

  1. Coursework- a shell game

    How am I supposed to know about this funny place and its funny names! Agnes's house after school I just finished packing my bags for tomorrow's trip to Mikumi National Park. Agnes told me that Mikumi National Park wasn't really a national park; it was just forest area where a

  2. How does the director of Saving Private Ryan makes the opening sequence shocking for ...

    Steven Spielberg chose the battle of Omaha beach as the beginning of the movie because Omaha beach was the bloodiest battlefield and it took 15000 lives of young, ignorant and uninformed Americans soldiers to capture the beach. At the beginning of the film, an old man who was one of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work