• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Analysis of Nothing's Changed and Charlotte O'Neils song

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

I have been studying poems from different cultures. The two I have been studying are Nothing's Changed, by Tatamkhulu Afrika and Charlotte O'Neil's Song, written by Fiona Farrell. Nothing's Changed was written about District 6 in Cape Town which was really racist which is now not even though it still is racist. Charlotte O'Neil's Song was written about lower class people going to New Zealand to escape the racism in England. Nothing's Changed, talks about how racist Cape Town is after white people went to the town. In the first stanza, the writer shows that Cape Town doesn't have proper footpaths, 'Small round hard stones click under my heels,' This shows that District 6 is not a very nice place to be because it has stones instead of footpaths. The writer also shows that there is long grass on the footpaths, 'seeding grasses thrust bearded seeds into trouser cuffs,' This shows that the footpaths also are grassy as well as having stones on them. The writer also shows that the area is covered in rubbish and weeds, 'cans, trodden on, crunch in tall, purple-flowering, amiable weeds.' This shows that there is also rubbish and weeds on the path where the writer is walking. ...read more.

Middle

The writer also shows that the black people were meant to be rude all the time compared to a white person, 'spit a little on the floor: it's in the bone.' This shows that the white people think it's in the black people's genes to be rude. In the sixth and final stanza, the writer shows that he has got annoyed with the inn he decides to step back, ' I back from the glass, boy again,' this shows that he is getting angry with the inn. He also shows that he is angry with racism, 'leaving small mean O of small, mean mouth.' This shows that the writer doesn't want racism to exist in the world. He also shows that he wants to smash a window on the inn, 'Hands burn for a stone, a bomb, to shiver down the glass.' This shows he wants to get into the inn through the window hoping it would shatter the white only inn and racism. Charlotte O'Neil's Song was written on a passage from England to New Zealand for lower class people, and was written by Fiona Farrell. In the first stanza, she shows how she served as a servant, 'You rang your bell and I answered. ...read more.

Conclusion

The last line is different to the rest of the poem because I think it is the most important line which makes you think about the nineteenth century servants and how badly they were treated the line is 'and you can open your own front door.' This line sets the whole poem in a way which nothing else could because it makes you think. The similarities between the two poems are that they are both about discrimination, 'whites only inn.' From Nothing's Changed and 'The poor deserve the gate.' From Charlotte O'Neil's Song, but both these poems are about the writer's journey through the world involving racism and discrimination. The differences about the two poems are that they are written from different times, for example Nothing's Changed is from the twentieth century, where as Charlotte O'Neil's Song is from the nineteenth century. Also Nothing's Changed is about racial discrimination, where as Charlotte O'Neil's Song is about discrimination of class. Personally I prefer Nothing's Changed because it lets the people reading the poem know how much racism is still in the world because it is a more modern poem than Charlotte O'Neil's which is from a later date so it I less eye opening than Nothing's Changed. ?? ?? ?? ?? GCSE English Poems From Different Cultures Coursework - 1 - ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Tatamkhulu Afrika: Nothings Changed section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Tatamkhulu Afrika: Nothings Changed essays

  1. Comparing Nothing's Changed and Charlotte O'Neil's Song

    He seems to have a bitter and hopeless tone, as though he thinks that that there is little chance that it will change as he also says "it's in the blood." He carries on the hopelessness right up until the tuning point where he say he wants to break the glass between him and the white people's caf�.

  2. History coursework on sources

    actually burned down and why it was done in the first place. In conclusion, this source shows the Abbeys role as a construction site as does source D and a home to the monks. Source D is a plan showing the changes to the infirmary in the C14th and C15th.

  1. How do the poets in Nothing's Changed and Charlotte O'Neils Song use their poems ...

    In the 1800s it was extremely common for wealthy families to employ poor girls like Charlotte as servants. Thousands of women emigrated to New Zealand in search of a new life when the government funded their trip. This was so that they could become wives of the settlers and populate the new land.

  2. How do the main characters in the poems "Charlotte O'Neil's Song" and "Nothings Changed" ...

    The rest of the poem the writer emphasizes what chores and language the maid will not use to the "mistress" any more: "But ill never say "sir" or "Thank you ma'am" and I'll never curtsey more."

  1. Compare the two poems, "Nothings changed" by Tatamkhulu Afrika with Charlotte O'Neil's song by ...

    No board says it: but my feet know... and the hot... Anger of my eyes", here he talks about there being no sign to say the name of the area he is in, but he can feel it. It seems that he does not have very good memories of this

  2. Did Saltaire change for the better?

    The rest of the village buildings have been converted for modern day use. E.g the old canteen is now a small college but some buildings are still in their original use like the Victoria hall, it is still used for entertainment and hall bookings.

  1. How do the writers of Charlotte O'Neill's Song and Nothing's Changed protest about injustice ...

    For example, in lines 6 and 7, she says; 'You lay on a silken pillow. I lay on an attic cot.' Here, Charlotte O'Neill protests about the injustice and discrimination by highlighting the separation of social classes through comparisons between the rich and the poor.

  2. I have been asked to compare two poems. I will be writing about

    Eating at a plastic table top rather than the linen table cloths and roses on the table of the white's inn further shows the inequalities of blacks against whites. The differences in the two restaurants symbolise the inequalities in this society.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work