• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'As a murder mystery story, Sir Arthur Conan-Doyle's 'The Speckled Band' is far more effective than Roald Dahl's 'Lamb to the Slaughter'. Do you agree?

Extracts from this document...


18th January 2002 Anthony Seymour 'As a murder mystery story, Sir Arthur Conan-Doyle's 'The Speckled Band' is far more effective than Roald Dahl's 'Lamb to the Slaughter'. Do you agree? The beginning of 'Lamb to the Slaughter' displays a warm atmosphere, with Mrs. Maloney knitting while relaxing and waiting for the home coming of her beloved husband. She then sets about her familiar routine of setting out a bottle of whiskey and a glass to welcome him home. She then happily awaits his return and seems to be content. It would appear the opening to 'Lamb to the Slaughter' leads the reader to believe she lives in a settled household, with no indication that Mrs. Maloney could later be capable of becoming so incensed that she should take such a drastic action as to murder her husband. 'Lamb to the Slaughter' has a more appealing beginning than 'The Speckled Band', as the reader is led to believe that the Maloney family live in a happy environment. Later the reader is shocked by the unexpected murder, to think a stable lady is driven to such violence. The 'Lamb to the Slaughter' is made effective as a murder story because it combines the element of surprise with a completely unsuspected murder. However this story is ineffective as a 'mystery' to the reader because it lacks the general layout of a typical murder mystery in as much as Roald Dahl describes the actions of the murderer so the reader already knows who committed the crime, opposed to 'The Speckled Band' which follows the detective around. The opening of 'The Speckled Band' begins with Sherlock Holmes being alerted by an unexpected early caller. ...read more.


because of this 'Lamb to the Slaughter' would not be considered by a reader as a brilliant murder mystery more of just a murder story because it does not actually involve any mystery about finding the murderer because the reader already knows who it is. The role of Jack Noonan in 'Lamb to the Slaughter' was to investigate the murder of a man in his own home. He had been a fellow detective and knew the victim's wife quite well. The fact that she was a gentle, tranquil and petit woman, who was expecting a baby, clouded their judgement. Her 'kind' behaviour towards them by offering them a drink and then later a meal was enough to prevent them from detecting her guilt. In fact not only was the evidence lying right under their nose but also they ate it. This twist in the tail is quite strange because until then even though Mary had murdered her own husband, the reader maybe understood why she was so incensed, however to make the policemen eat the murder weapon may have seemed a bit out of character. Jack Noonan featured in 'Lamb to the Slaughter' very briefly and for that reason he is quite hard to compare to Holmes, however Jack Noonan did not investigate the murder deep enough and showed no signs of thorough investigation. The detection methods used in the story were not the dominant feature and the murder was the major aspect. The murder was cleverly staged by having a harmless pregnant housewife with child as the murderer, however the story was not focused around a detective and therefore the detection sections are not very effective on the reader as a murder mystery because the reader is expecting a murder mystery to have some really tense detection work taking place as in 'The Speckled Band'. ...read more.


I actually preferred 'The Speckled Band' style of writing. Even though phrases were harder to understand, once understood, they contributed greatly to the story. 'The Speckled Band' was far more compelling, for the crime was obviously well planned and was quite unpredictable. The 'Lamb to the Slaughter' was not actually much of a mystery because the reader was aware of the killer due to the story being mainly about the murderer and not the detective. I think 'Lamb to the Slaughter' fails as a murder mystery because it lacks actual 'mystery' for the reader even though the detectives never solved the case. From the point when the murder took place - which is where the tension started to build - there is no detection work for the reader to do and therefore the reader can then only become curious about whether Mrs. Maloney will succeed. 'The Speckled Band' succeeds as an effective murder mystery because for one it involves Holmes, so a reader familiar with him already knows that it will be a excellent mystery. Also the story actually leads the reader to keep following because it gains tension as each little piece of the mystery unfolds. Overall I enjoyed and found 'The Speckled Band' more appealing due to its complex structure and excellent detective content, which was lacking in 'Lamb to the Slaughter'. I do agree with the statement that Sir Arthur Conan-Doyle's 'The Speckled Band' is more effective as a murder mystery than Roald Dahl's 'Lamb to the Slaughter' because it has a more interesting plot and has a wider range of interesting characters to liven up the story. Also 'The Speckled Band' was an actual mystery for the reader to work out, whereas the only mystery in 'Lamb to the Slaughter' was whether Mrs. Maloney would succeed or not. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Roald Dahl section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Roald Dahl essays

  1. Lamb to the Slaughter" By Roald Dahl

    "On the other hand, what about the child? What were the laws about murderers with unborn children? Did they kill then both-mother and child? Or did they wait until the tenth month? What did they do?". Another thing she did was put the murder weapon in the oven to get rid of it.

  2. The Case for the Defence and the Call Waiting.

    there is as in a traditional detective story, a detective. Also in one the murderer is convicted and in the other there isn't a convicted murderer but one twin does get killed but whether he was guilty or not- it is not known.

  1. Lamb to the Slaughter

    She is very thoughtful and has a lot of time on her hands during the day, her sentences and long and drawn out, explaining everything that is happening. He obviously has no time for her and so his sentences are short and abrupt.

  2. The Signalman by Charles Dickens and Lamb to the Slaughter by Roald Dahl

    The climax comes at the end of The Signalman. The warning words "Below there! Look out! Look out! For God's sake, clear the way!" make us realize why the man came to the railway in the first place. The story involves the reader and we are left to feel helpless

  1. Compare and contrast “Lamb to the slaughter” by Roald Dahl with “Vendetta” by Guy ...

    When Saverini returned home, she tied her dog up in her kennel and for three days fed her nothing but water. After three days, Saverini made the figure of a person using old clothes and straw. She then cooked some black pudding on a fire next to the kennel.

  2. Comparing the Build up of Suspense in "Lamb to the Slaughter" and "The Speckled ...

    In comparison, the structure "The Speckled Band" can be broken down into four sections, "Introduction", "Situation", "Solution" and "Outcome". The introduction being Watson introducing the story, the situation being that of Helen Stoker's, The Problem being that of Holmes' to explain the strange happenings in the Stoke Roylott's household,

  1. How did Roald Dahl create atmosphere and tension in the story Lamb to the ...

    She asks him "Tired darling" he answers in an unusual briefness When he tells her there is no text explaining what he is saying only what her reactions are. We presume that he is leaving her for another woman. The atmosphere changes and a nervous tension created.

  2. Comparing Roald Dahl's 'Lamb to the Slaughter' 1954 and 'The Speckled Band' by Sir ...

    This is not needed in 'Lamb to the Slaughter'. If it had been included then the story would not have the intended message. The victims of the murderers are also quite different. In 'Lamb to the Slaughter' Patrick Maloney is introduced as a man on edge. The reader is shown that there is a normal routine that he doesn't follow on that particular evening.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work