• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Billy's Relationships with women of his own age in the play 'Billy Liar' - Why does each of them ultimately fail?

Extracts from this document...


Billy's Relationships with women of his own age in the play 'Billy Liar' Why does each of them ultimately fail? In the play 'Billy Liar', Billy manages to engage himself to two women simultaneously whilst having an affair with a third at the same time. In this essay I will focus on each individuals characteristics and their reactions to different aspects of Billy's actions. For starters I will monitor each characters responses to Billy's consistent lying, their individual motivation and who has more control over the relationship in hand. The three women's attitudes to sex and marriage and lastly the issue over whether the individual relationships will succeed or fail in the future to come, will be in addition thoroughly looked over. From Rita's attitude we can see that she comes from a poor background or at least a lower class to Billy's rank in society. She is able to see straight through Billy's lies with a casual ease picked up from the regular nights spent with 'friendly airmen', she is also streetwise in a way quite different from the other two. Barbara on the other hand is entirely on the other end of the spectrum to Rita. Billy's lies commonly deceive her and she only manages to spot the blatant remarks that are too obvious to mistake for anything else. When she realises the joke put upon her she reacts with pity and sorrow "you haven't been lying to me Billy have you?" ...read more.


Interestingly Billy receives a lot of criticism from his parents and piers over his choices [Liz is considered undesirable by most of his friends and acquaintances] yet he still is not put off by this factor: BILLY: What? Liz? ARTHUR: Yea-scruffy Lizzie. I bumped into her in Sheep-gate. Mucky as ever. It's about time someone bought her a new skirt. Rita maintains control throughout this relationship by her use of crude expressions and clich�s picked up from regular visits with friendly American airmen. "Ooh! Look what's crawled out of the cheese." Many of these terms are in response to Billy's childish lying, unable to deceive Rita who can pick them out with a casual ease. The reason for her apparent effortlessness is due to her streetwise quality unbeknown to the other two allowing her to pick up Billy's deceiving lingo and replying with sarcasm or criticism. "Pull the other one its got bells on it." The only way Billy manages to control Rita is by using a physical response to calm her vocal harassment. Due to his lack of control Billy is usually defending himself from Rita's judgements which regularly include Billy's own family [Rita shows a definite lack of respect for her elders coming from a poor and uneducated background] Billy likes to dominate the relationship with Barbara because of its unique context. He usually fails as Barbara whips out her famous oranges as defence mechanism used to passively distort Billy's plans. ...read more.


She is quite surprised and confused when she realises what Billy has accomplished during the period of their relationship. "Have you been untrue to me Billy? I've got to know." Once more, Liz is the 'middle man' because of her median views. She is not Virgo intactica nevertheless she doesn't use her views to her advantage or to gain materialist objects like Rita. On the other hand she would never wait to find a husband to discreetly have a child when no one is looking, views common to Barbara's puritan beliefs. Despite her loss of virginity she is happy to "make babies - lots of them" with Billy after a small amount of urging and influential advice. The relationship between Rita and Billy is undoubtedly going to end extremely quickly. The reason for this short-lived affair is down to the grounds that the motivation in tact between the two characters is only skin deep. Its point was only for each individual's personal gain and not for the couple as a whole. The same fateful end is imminent for Barbara and her idealistic, old-fashioned relationship. The reason for this well-chosen ending is that the context for the whole relationship was to be a form of entertainment or sport providing Billy a gateway to pass on all his troubles created by work and his other relationship with Rita. Liz yet again is separated from the other two. Seeing as she was the only one Billy really cherished, it is most likely that this couple will unite themselves as part of the new-formed generation. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Educating Rita section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Educating Rita essays

  1. Once upon a Time in the West: A Critical Response.

    Even still, Frank, lacking any sense of morality, quickly realizes he must kill his savior in order to acquire the riches that Sweetwater would bring him. However, Frank is intrigued by the mystery Harmonica presents. He simply must satisfy his urge to know Harmonica's true identity before eliminating him.

  2. Billy Liar; How would I play Billy

    In this scene I would have Billy wearing a shirt un-tucked with a tie loosened a tiny bit. His trousers would be worn slightly baggier than he would wear them during the day. And he would have his sleeves rolled up.

  1. The Three Girls in Billy Fishers life.

    She tries to help Mrs Fisher when Florence has 'one of her do's'. She says, even though the proposal is a little bit stupid considering what is happening, "Would she like an orange, Mrs Fisher?". She also insists on helping Mrs Fisher in washing up the pots.

  2. Billy Liar - In this play how is Billy presented?

    However, another irritation to Billy could be the fact that despite her not actually being able to address him, sometimes she does have quite a strong point, such as when she tells him that he, like she had to, should "get up of a morning to eat his breakfast".

  1. How do stage directions and dialogue in 'Billy Liar' help to illustrate the characters ...

    These are the kind of things middle-aged women talk about. She talks about her dream of a cottage in a very mature manner in addition to 'going over the top' in the way that she thinks. The author portrays the character of Barbara by being very 'flat' and 'cold' in

  2. Billy Liar - Discuss your opinions of Billy's 3 girlfriends. Do they give a ...

    She values the wrong items, she is too materialistic, and all the way through the play she only has eyes for the ring. I know this because she says, "You don't get out of it like that. I want that ring."

  1. Billy Liar 20th Century Drama Coursework.

    That young madam came round last night shouting, waking up the whole street. You'd better be careful or that one. But I suppose you brought it all on yourself. Alice folds the tea towel and goes back into the kitchen.

  2. Billy Liar - The characters in the play display very negative attitudes towards Billy. ...

    Billy however doesn't return the favour. He exploits his mother and constantly relies on her to back him up when he is in trouble. He has little respect for his family, especially his grandmother as she sits around getting in the way, moaning at him, and always directs her speech towards the side cupboard, which annoys Billy.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work