• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Both ‘Lamb to the Slaughter’ and ‘A Speckled Band’ shares characteristics of classic detective fiction. With close reference to these two stories, compare Conan Doyle and Dahl’s different approaches to the genre

Extracts from this document...


Both 'Lamb to the Slaughter' and 'A Speckled Band' shares characteristics of classic detective fiction. With close reference to these two stories, compare Conan Doyle and Dahl's different approaches to the genre 'A Speckled band' and 'Lamb to the Slaughter' are two stories about murderers. Lamb to the Slaughter challenges the stereotypical conventions connected a crime story whereas 'a Speckled Band sticks to the conventions. In this essay I will compare the two stories about their approach to the narration, characters, setting, crime and how each story ends and show that even though 'A Lamb to the Slaughter' isn't a typical murder story it works effectively 'A Speckled Band' is written in first person from the point of view of Dr. Watson, Sherlock Holmes' sidekick. The reader finds out about the murder as the story goes along making it into a exciting classic 'who done it' Only the murderer knows who he has committed the murder and the detective is the only one with the skill to figure out the murder. Everyone else has to watch as the case unravels how the murder did it. This creates drama and tension. You don't find out how until the very end and only when Sherlock Holmes explains 'I had yet to learn of the case was told me by Sherlock Holmes the next day'. You hear all the clues and get some red herrings to make the plot thicker 'the presence of gypsies and the use of the word band... I can only claim put me upon an entirely wrong scent.' The story is written in the present but refers to the past ' it was early in April in the year 83' you know you'll get a conclusion to the case and the killer is caught or not. 'Lamb to the Slaughter' is written in third person, this gives an objective view and not a character perspective. ...read more.


The murderer in 'a lamb to the slaughter' is called Mary Maloney she is a vulnerable, pregnant woman. The reader is made to feel like she is the victim because her husband is grumpy and horrible to her, and is planning to live her, because she is pregnant she needs protecting. She treats her husband well doesn't know that her husband is going to leave her. She doesn't plan the murder and it is more an act of revenge and shock. Directly after the murder she can't believe she has killed Mr Maloney. After she clams down she plans how to get away with the murder, she goes to the shops to confirm an alibi, and then she calls the police and starts playing a victim of the murder. It is easy to do this because the state of shock she is in and the stupidity of the police. Mrs Maloney is the opposite of Dr Grimesby Roylott, she gets the readers sympathy and the reader can understand the emotions she felt but Dr Grimesby Roylott didn't have a good reason for his murder, his was premeditated and he tried to kill again. The victims in 'a speckled band' are twins, one was murdered before (Julia Stoner) and the second was an attempted murder (Helen Stoner.) Helen's eyes are described as 'those of some hunted animal' and her stepfather is hunting her. Both victims lived with their stepfather in an old mansion which the most of the rooms were inhibited. They were only two years old when their mother remarried and therefore Dr Grimesby Roylott was a father figure to them. Both victims were female and both due to get married and to be were left with a considerable amount of money from their mother to receive when they got married. 'Julia... met a half pay major of the marines to whom she became engaged' This creates sympathy because they were both venerable and innocent. ...read more.


I sympathise with Mr Maloney at the end of the story because she is now on her own with a child and having to live with the guilt of killing her husband even though she got away with the murder. She cares about her child because if she didn't have the baby then she would have turned herself in. 'she knew quite well what the penalty would be that was fine it made no difference to her, it would be a relief. On the other hand what about her child?' I think Mrs Maloney was so angry with her husband leaving her and been on her own with a child. 'A Speckled Band' has a kind of happy ending because the killer has been caught, Helen Stoner could now go and get married and even sell the mansion. Sherlock Holmes is now a hero and everything worked out. 'A lamb to the Slaughter' may not be a typical murder story but it still gives the same emotions of drama, suspense and humour. 'A Speckled Band' may not be more updated to modern days but it works as a classic murder story. I preferred 'a lamb to the slaughter' because I could believe the plot more. It is more realistic and you can make your own mind up about whether Mrs Maloney deserved to get away with the murder. You don't get a character viewpoint. You know how she committed the murder and can understand why but you don't know weather she will get a way with the murder. The only problem I had with this story was that it was to prefect because she fooled the police and twisted the police into eating the murder weapon. If it were more realistic other police officers wouldn't do this but. 'A Speckled Band' is a classic murder mystery and it still holds up the tension and drama even though it was written nearly 100 years earlier. Both stories are very effective and cleverly written because of their realism and the ingenious way they have been written. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Roald Dahl section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Roald Dahl essays

  1. In this essay I am going to discuss how Dahl uses language, characters, and ...

    They're on the third floor, both of them together." This is very evil, as the reader can imagine both men upstairs on the third floor sitting on their armchairs, dead. This explains the supposed disappearance of the two men. Once again, however, Billy doesn't suspect a thing, as he views his old but innocent landlady.

  2. How does Roal Dahl create unease and tension in 'The Landlady'

    "Your tea's all ready for you". "She placed his teacup on the table in front of him." To Billy the landlady seems like generous and kind old lady offering him a cup of tea. To the reader, however, it seems like she is extremely intent on making him drink the tea.

  1. Discuss how suspense and tension are created in‘Lamb to the Slaughter’ and ‘The Speckled ...

    for example, the dummy bell rope, the ventilator that didn't lead outside, the bed that was clamped to the floor and there was a large safe in Dr RoyLott's room. This creates suspense because as Sherlock Holmes investigates the case and uncovers clues, so does the reader.

  2. Detective Fiction comparison 'Lamb to the Slaughter' & 'The Red Headed League'.

    He also makes us feel sorry for Mrs. Maloney and judge her husband rude and heartless. This way the reader stands on Mrs. Maloney's side and makes us cheer for her to get away with her crime; and somehow feel that her husband deserved what happened to him.

  1. In this wide-reading piece I will compare two murder mystery stories: 'The Speckled Band' ...

    There is no 'mystery' to try and guess from in 'Lamb to the Slaughter' as far as how, why and where the murder took place. 'Lamb to the Slaughter' focuses on the actual crime itself whereas 'The Speckled Band' deals more with the investigation.

  2. Both The Speckled Band and Lamb to the Slaughter share some characteristics of the ...

    The reason why the detectives failed mostly was because the didn't check things out enough, they ruled Mrs Maloney out without questioning her enough, they drank on the job and also they ate all the evidence there possible was! So basically they were unprofessional, gullible and too sympathetic towards Mrs

  1. In this essay I will be comparing and contrasting the stories of the Vendetta ...

    The widow then disguises herself before she carry's out her main objective. At the end of the story we see the widow as ruthless, but we remember her as a loving mother that is determined to carry out a promise she made to her son, whatever the cost.

  2. Compare and contrast the two short stories ‘ Lamb to the Slaughter’ and ‘ ...

    When Helen Stoners sister was killed she was about to get married, and now Mary is about to get married and is worried the same is going to happen to her, "It's fear Mr Holmes, it's terror." There are several 'red herrings' in this story, such as the gypsies, which

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work