• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Both Mr Birling From ‘An Inspector Calls’ And Ebeneezer Scrooge From Christmas Carol Are Visited By Outsiders. Compare And Contrast The Two Characters And How They Are Influenced By The Outsiders.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Both Mr Birling From 'An Inspector Calls' And Ebeneezer Scrooge From Christmas Carol Are Visited By Outsiders. Compare And Contrast The Two Characters And How They Are Influenced By The Outsiders. 'An Inspector Calls' is a play written by J.B Preistly in year 1908. 'An Inspector Calls' and Christmas Carol have a main theme to them, which is about holism and individualism but we see how two similar characters dealing with these issues. The author is showing how wealthy rich business owners deal with social considerations and responsibility also. Charles Dickens writes the Christmas Carol. The play concentrates on responsibility and social considerations and also four outsiders visit the character in Christmas Carol. Mr Birling is the one of the main characters out of six in 'An Inspector Calls.' Mr Birling is a wealthy business owner who we see fails to deal with responsibility and social considerations. In Christmas Carol Ebeneezer Scrooge is main character, he also owns a business. Scrooge also shows how he succeeds to deal with responsibility and social considerations. An outsider called Inspector Goole visits Mr Birling. ...read more.

Middle

Christmas day, but in the end he lets him have Christams off but he can not have following day off: " A poor excuse picking a man's pocket every twenty-fifth of December." However Scrooge is moaning to Bob that he pays him for nothing because he doesn't do any work: " You don't think me ill-used when I pay a day's wages for no work." Both of the characters are tight fisted, they are very selfish because they do not let their workers have a pay increase. Both characters do not let their workers wages go up. Mr Birling sacked five ringleaders because of this. One of those ringleaders was Eva Smith, this was one of the first chain of events, which lead to her death. Mr Birling is not responsible because he does not care for his workers or their lives. All he wants is his knighthood: " I might find my way on to the next Honours list. Just knighthood, of course." Mr Birling wants his knighthood because he wants to be important in the town. ...read more.

Conclusion

The outsiders, who visited Scrooge, were stronger then the one outsider which visited Mr Birling. The outsiders that visited Scrooge were more effective then Inspector Goole, the outsider that visited Mr Birling. Dickens puts a message across that people can change if the are irresponsible and do not treat their employees in proper manner or if they do not respect the lower class. Consequently Priestly shows that people cannot change they will stay the same people who follow their ways of responsibility and treat their employees badly with no wage increases. Scrooge changes because he is told his outsiders his past, present and future. The future ghost informs him that he is going to die. He also changes because he is a loner. When he changes his character he start believing in Christmas. Nevertheless Mr Birling does not change because he finds out that the Inspector that visited him was a ghost. Mr Birling goes back to his old ways of responsibility, treatment of employees and social considerations. This is because Priestly shows in his 'play' that the character cannot change. Conversely Dickens shows in his novel that characters can change their ways of beliefs in life like Scrooge. 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE J.B. Priestley section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE J.B. Priestley essays

  1. How Would a Modern Day Audience Respond To a Performance of ‘an Inspector ...

    Inspector Goole's name is obviously a pun on the word ghoul (a spectre or ghost). The inspector could be seen as a ghost sent by the dead girl in order to torment the family's' consciences, or comic policeman conduction an enquiry preliminary to the day of judgement, or as a forewarning of things that are to come.

  2. Both Mr Birling from ‘An Inspector Calls’ and Ebenezer Scrooge from a Christmas Carol ...

    He accepts no responsibility for Eva's death. Outsiders visit Scrooge because he is a lonely man and only cares about himself. He is horrible to other people and does not care about them. The outsiders that visit him are (unlike 'An Inspector calls')

  1. Examine the role of Eva in ‘An Inspector Calls’

    If something like that happen at Birlings then she could have challenged for an unfair dismissal as you had a trade union at factories. What happened in Milwords just showed Sheila's character. At the start of the play she was very immature and very na�ve.

  2. Imagine that you are directing a production of ‘An Inspector Calls’. Write to the ...

    appropriate face such as when the fact about the store incident came out you should do nothing. During the questioning of Gerald you should sit and listen but give appropriate facial expressions for the fact found out, but when he finds out about the affair he should sigh in anger and screw his face to show his anger with Gerald.

  1. The Main Themes in ‘An Inspector Calls’

    Within this speech he mentions how he thinks that we are all intertwined within each other, that lots of people doing little things to one person can lead to a very serious thing, in this case, death. Also within this speech he also emphasises the point that there are many

  2. Show how the production of ‘An Inspector Calls’ enhanced the script and furthered your ...

    the rest of the world was shown by the way that until the inspector arrived they were all inside the house and we could not see in and could not hear their voices as well as when they came out of the house.

  1. What is the Function of the Inspector in ‘An Inspector Calls’?

    Before Mr Birling can finish his sentence the doorbell rings this upsets the celebratory mood of the evening. Mr Birling is much less vocal when the inspector starts asking tricky questions. The Inspector destroys their smugness. As a policeman, the Inspector, straight away takes charge of the situation.

  2. Discuss this view of responsibility, guilt and blame in ‘An Inspector Calls’ and discuss ...

    These were mainly based on how much profit they could make and they rarely considered the welfare of the workers. In the play itself the main family, the 'Birlings' are wealthy middle class landowners and proprietors of a large factory that was built up by the father of Mr. Birling.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work