"By the end of Act 1 we see both the birth of happiness and tragedy." How far do you find this to be true? Romeo and Juliet.

Authors Avatar

“By the end of Act 1 we see both the birth of happiness and tragedy.” How far do you find this to be true?

“Romeo and Juliet” is in one sense tragic since tragic also means death or killing in journalistic terms. Act 1 ends with Juliet, a dying swan, being crushed in mid sentence by an alien figure, the nurse. The nurse considers love to be the lust of “when maids lie on their backs.” Thus Juliet’s love was thwarted due to her being labelled a Capulet. Labels should mean nothing, yet the substantial barrier rises up with surprising effectiveness at the end of the scene. Perhaps through fear but it is questionable that Juliet’s obedient upper-class upbringing plays a part in her immediate departure i as she is told to “Come let’s away.” Her Capulet label almost eliminates Romeo from her grasp; she talks of this match to be a “prodigious birth of love is to me.”  She compares not having love to not having life.

This Tragedy is born out of the instant love and followed by a sonnet shared by the two lovers. It is where no intrusion can take place and at this time no tragedy is in the two lovers’ minds. This romantic exchange brought happiness into Romeo’s life for the first time in a long time. Romeo tells Juliet she is a “holy shrine.” and he is so overwhelmed with love he says, “To smooth this rough touch with a tender kiss.” Their love was at that time so innocent as the both of them did not know each other’s names, and more importantly what house of Verona they were from. The nurse, who seems to be a bringer of bad news, ended this perfect moment as she puts Juliet out of one misery and makes a new one as “His name is Romeo, and a Montague.”

Join now!

Another tragedy, again introduced by the nurse, that is not uncommon in many societies today, was proposed to young Juliet even before she had met Romeo. It was only earlier that day that Lady Capulet had summoned her daughter to her chamber. She proposed to Juliet the idea of marriage and furthermore that could she “Like of Paris’s love?” Of course the pantomime dame-like nurse was in attendance for additional tragedies, such as her daughter Susan who is “with God”.  The nurse’s husband also is no longer with us hence, “God be with his soul.” We cannot help but ...

This is a preview of the whole essay