• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Carol Ann Duffy, (born 1958) tackles the issue of love in her poem "Valentine," as does Percy Bysshe Shelly (1792-1822) in the poem "Love's Philosophy," and finally Robert Burns (1759-1796) considers the topic in "A Red Red Rose."

Extracts from this document...


"The course of true love never did run smoothly," (William Shakespeare.) How far do you think the three poems you have read conform to this view? Throughout history love has been a favoured theme with many poets in their writing. Carol Ann Duffy, (born 1958) tackles the issue of love in her poem "Valentine," as does Percy Bysshe Shelly (1792-1822) in the poem "Love's Philosophy," and finally Robert Burns (1759-1796) considers the topic in "A Red Red Rose." As different poets throughout history have written about the topic it is not surprising that all three contain different and contrasting messages and viewpoints. It is clear that with the passage of time, views have become more pessimistic or some may say realistic. However, poems written in the eighteenth century still have relevance today. "A Red Red Rose" by Robert Burns portrays a very positive image of love. Firstly, Burns compares love to " a red, red rose." This is a traditional object linked with the theme of love and through this comparison it is clear Burns is praising love. Burns describes the rose as "red, red." This a bright, vibrant, sensual colour commonly associated when extolling love and appealing to the visual senses. Burns also compares love to " the melodie, that's sweetly played in tune." This vivid description appeals to the reader's auditory senses. The fact that Burns implies love appeals to several different senses demonstrates that he feels love is a powerful influence that can be experienced by all. ...read more.


In a way Shelley is presenting the poem as if he is justifying questions and criticisms of love. Once again similarly to " a red red rose" love is portrayed as a dependable emotion. While Shelley continually refers to love as a great power, he also hints that love can also be unpredictable and may fade with time. At the end of the first stanza Shelley includes a question, "in one spirit meet and mingle. Why not I with mine?" This is Shelley openly voicing his insecurities about love and admitting that he does not feel the power of love at the time of writing the poem. It is therefore evident that Shelley has seen the power of love manifest in a negative manner but he has not experienced love's forceful strength and thus leaves the reader with a slight sense of the unpredictability and frailty of love. Shelley's love poem is entitled, "Love's Philosophy," and similarly to a Burn's poem the title is used to reinforce the poem's message. The word "philosophy" is a set of beliefs that a person lives by and this poem is Shelley's attempt to create a set of rules that love follows. Shelley gives this impression so that more people will understand what a mighty force love is and in future will not reject love in turn for human advice. Like "A Red Red Rose," "Love's philosophy has a regular structure with the same number of lines in each stanza. ...read more.


Duffy has placed several words and lines on their own, "lethal," and "not a cute card or a kissogram." The aim of this is to draw attention to these important words and phrases, which allow the reader to be aware of the main message of the poem. In my opinion I feel that the two poems that are most closely related are "A Red Red Rose," by Burns and "Love's Philosophy", by Shelley. This is because both poems highlight the optimistic aspects of love to some extent. Both poems also compare love to natural elements that create the feeling that love is an amalgamating force. However "Love's Philosophy" and "Valentine" also share some similar traits. Both poems mention the negative characteristics of love but Valentine does address these issues more forcefully and in greater depth. Carol Ann Duffy wrote her poem nearly 200 years after Burns and Shelley. This means that a negative opinion of love would have been more accepted in society. Duffy may also have experienced a particularly painful relationship that may have ended on bad terms. My personal favourite out of the poems is Valentine as I feel it does show a very true side of love but achieves this in an original and exciting way. In connection with Shakespeare's statement, it is clear that Duffy most definitely agrees with it while Burn is in no doubt that the course of true love does run smoothly. Shelley, however, does not agree or disagree with the statement and I would personally agree that in some case love does run smoothly while in other relationships it does not. Hannah Boyd-Carson 5K ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Love Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Love Poetry essays

  1. A Comparison of the two poems, 'A Red, Red, Rose' by Robert Burns, and ...

    These references could be connected to the eternity of the natural world and thus the eternity of his love. The phrase, ''Till a' the seas gang dry' is repeated twice for emphasis. It suggests that his love is as vast, as deep, and as perpetual as the seas.

  2. Critical Appreciation of Before You Were Mine by Carol Ann Duffy.

    There being no rhyme in this poem is evidence to support this, her daughter feels no need to "varnish" or improve what she has to say about her mother, what she is saying should grab the reader's attention by itself rather by having the words audibly attractive to hear.

  1. In this essay I will discuss the similarities and differences between 'A Red, Red ...

    The last stanza is Burns saying that he is going for a while but will be back, 'And I will come again, my Luve, Tho' it were ten thousand mile!' this shows that no matter what happens he will come back because of their love.

  2. Carol Ann Duffy wrote the poem Valentine to express her feelings on love.

    This time she used a simile. The "platinum loops" of onion relate to with the wedding rings. That shows how love can lead to marriage. And that is really when people have decided to spend the rest of their life together. It is a really wonderful thing.

  1. In "Valentine", Duffy uses the onion to give an original and, in some ways, ...

    She is using alliteration, and the repetition of the 't' sound gives it the feeling of sincerity. In the next line she says: "Not a cute card or a kiss-o-gram". Duffy again uses a negative technique to start the line.

  2. By close study of Valentine and I Wouldnt Thank You for a Valentine, show ...

    Duffy wrote "Valentine" in 1992, so she still had strong feminist views before this affair. Duffy broke up in 2004 with her long-time lesbian partner and fellow poet Jackie Kay. Duffy has stated herself that, "I'm not a lesbian poet, whatever that is.

  1. Carol Ann Duffy - 'Valentine' and 'Before You Were Mine'

    This process is represented in the poem by the unwrapping of the onion from it brown paper enclosure. The use of a simile contributes to this viewpoint ' like a lover, love distorts one's vision. It will mislead the reader into believing something that isn't true.

  2. Valentineby Carol Ann Duffy and "One Flesh" by Elizabeth Jennings.

    I believe that "Valentine" is a poem that manages to break love down into all its faults, providing precautions on what might happen if you forget that love is mortal. I found that "Valentine" has taught me that love is only a fragile feeling that might not last and that

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work