• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Certainly not tragic, not even heroic". How far do you agree with this estimation of the character Macbeth?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'CERTAINLY NOT TRAGIC, NOT EVEN HEROIC' HOW FAR DO YOU AGREE WITH THIS ESTIMATION OF THE CHARACTER MACBETH? The character Macbeth's personality undergoes a major upheaval during the play Macbeth. To depict what kind of a person he is entails describing what kind of fluctuations in probity and integrity his character goes through, and what kind of man he is perceived to be throughout the ages and his place in cultured history. In the First Folio, Macbeth is branded as a definite tragedy. However, Macbeth has spawned a number of works of art, ranging from the operas both entitled Macbeth by Giuseppe Verdi and Ernst Bl�ch to The Lion King (which is based loosely around Macbeth). This suggests a much deeper and more complex character in Macbeth, not simply a clear cut tyrant or a valiant hero with a tragic flaw that scuppers him despite his best efforts. Therefore, the definition of the Macbeths as a 'dead butcher and his fiend-like wife' does not do justice to the multitudinous perspectives from which one must view the Macbeths to get a complete picture of their thought patterns. When considering whether Macbeth is a hero, it becomes evident that at the start of the play, before we even meet him, he is a successful general, noble and valiant in all he undertakes. This is shown particularly in the Captain's speech: 'Doubtful it stood, As two swimmers that do cling together And choke their art. ...read more.

Middle

Duncan in which he may yet stay a good man as before, with no desire for evil, or progress and transform into the tyrant he becomes. It is his morals, not any cowardice, which initially restrain him from killing King Duncan: 'He's here in double trust: First, as I am his kinsman and his subject, Strong both against the deed; then, as his host, Who should against the murderer shut the door, Not bear the knife myself.' This proves that, while he may not be the same indefatigably loyal subject he once was, he is still good at heart and is still reasonable. Macbeth goes on in this soliloquy to admire the characteristics that make Duncan such a good king, and seems to stray from the murder more and more. He wrestles with himself for some time in this vein, deliberating and worrying. Finally, though, he is convinced that killing him is the right thing to do by his amoral wife, Lady Macbeth. Lady Macbeth, unlike her husband, has no conscience. Before the murder of Duncan, she is the stronger of the two. Shortly after it, Macbeth is horrified by what he has done, whereas she is confident and unmoved, as she doesn't understand that killing such a good man for her own benefit is immoral. However, as the play progresses, Macbeth becomes more and more ruthless to ensure that Duncan's murder was not in vain and that he should reap as much as he can from committing such a terrible crime (i.e. ...read more.

Conclusion

'Macbeth' gives an account of two different men. The first, an steadfastly loyal servant to the throne, who holds his friends close to his heart and would never do anything morally wrong; the second, a conceited tyrant whose actions directly benefit himself and bring unthinkable suffering to other, indeed a 'dead butcher'. However, while the statement 'Certainly not tragic, not even heroic' is not incorrect, it doesn't paint the whole picture. Macbeth is, at different stages of the play, heroic, such as in battle with the traitorous Macdonald and, to some extent, at the end when facing Macduff in his last epic showdown. He also shows the characteristics of a hero when he acknowledges that he has been duped by the witches' apparitions before deciding upon the manner of his death. Also, though, he is tragic in a way, as his fall from nobility was a result of a flaw that arose from his evil wife and the witches; his hamartia, in a sense, was his ambition. However, there is no real anagnorisis; no point of illumination. In addition, Macbeth is still not moral or remorseful enough towards to latter stages of the play for the audience to identify with him as a tragic hero. He is not allowed (or does not utilise) any opportunity to learn from his mistakes. It is because of these points that, in a classical sense, he is neither a tragic hero, nor and evil butcher, but something in between. ?? ?? ?? ?? BRAMAN THILLAINATHAN GCSE ENGLISH COURSEWORK ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Macbeth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a star student thought of this essay

3 star(s)

Response to the question

This is a good essay in some respects, in that it achieves a competent character analysis of Macbeth and his motivations, but it does suffer from structural issues. However, the statement given for discussion is 'Certainly not tragic, not even ...

Read full review

Response to the question

This is a good essay in some respects, in that it achieves a competent character analysis of Macbeth and his motivations, but it does suffer from structural issues. However, the statement given for discussion is 'Certainly not tragic, not even heroic'. The candidate does not discuss these aspects in the main body of the essay, and only really addresses them when drawing his/her conclusions in the final paragraphs. In an essay such as this, it is also important to set the parametres of the discussion, i.e. define 'tragic' and 'heroic', clearly set out an argument for or against the statement (although ideally more nuanced than this), and qualify it with reference to the text and referring back to the original statement. The candidate has failed to do this, thus making their line of argument somewhat difficult to follow.

Level of analysis

The candidate's analysis is very good in many respects; s/he closely references the text and discusses the use of literary devices and motifs well. The essay could benefit from closer quotation and reference to the text in places, although generally it is good. However, the structural problems I have highlighted above have to be rectified before the literary analysis could be considered useful as it should be used to strengthen an argument not as a substitute for one. It is likely that this candidate studies Latin and/or Greek and as a result has used some of these literary terms in his/her essay. While this can be impressive, it is important to ensure it is done appropriately. The use of the word 'hamartia' (presumably to mean 'tragic flaw') jars somewhat and seems slightly inappropriate as it is a complex term which has attracted a lot of debate on its precise meaning. If you are unsure it is better to express your ideas in plain English rather than using Latin or Greek terminology.

Quality of writing

The quality of writing in this piece is of an exceptionally high standard for GCSE level. The candidate has demonstrated a command of a large vocabulary, a high standard of grammar and a fluent writing style.


Did you find this review helpful? Join our team of reviewers and help other students learn

Reviewed by medbh4805 07/02/2012

Read less
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Macbeth essays

  1. Macbeth (Analysis of The Banquet Scene)

    When the ghost finally disappears, and Lady Macbeth asks him, 'What, quite unmann'd in folly?' inquiring why he has been so foolish. Macbeth appears uncertain of what he saw, just by the way she asked him. 'If I stand here, I saw him.'

  2. 'Macbeth' gives us a classic example of the literary definition of a 'tragic hero'. ...

    Yet for the moment he adopts this sensible attitude: If chance will have me king, why, chance may crown me, Without my stir. Subsequently, we encounter an event where Duncan is to bestow upon Macbeth his new title of Thane of Cawdor.

  1. To what extent is Macbeth wholly responsible for his ruin, which destroys not only ...

    history, the Divine Right of Kings deemed regicide an awful offence - the worst infact. Kings were God's regents to be given complete obedience. Thus, Shakespeare would ensure Macbeth a brutal and quick demise immediately after he'd killed Duncan in order to please the Jacobeans, as this was a firmly believed philosophy of theirs.

  2. Macbeth Soliloquy Analysis

    Banquo is the only person that he cannot control at this moment in time as proved by "Our fears in Banquo stick deep". Macbeth knows that people will have "hailed him to a father to a line of kings" as Banquo is "the seed of Banquo kings".

  1. Trace the development of Macbeth's character

    other part of him knows that killing the king will be against the Divine Rights. In soliloquy Macbeth reveals his innermost thoughts and the audience can see his reservations on the task of killing king. This shows a major turning point in his behaviour and at this stage he is heavily influenced by Lady Macbeth.

  2. " Macbeth is a villain with heroic qualities. How far do you agree?"

    "Then you were a man" she questions his manhood which he can't take and feels he must prove himself. After the actual "deed" Macbeth has to deal with enormous amounts of guilt, he can't sleep and because of the murder the relationship with his wife deteriorates.

  1. Lady MacBeth - Character Assessment

    She calls to the 'spirits that tend on mortal thoughts' - these are the spirits that tend on any murderous thought or ambition. She asks them to, 'stop th'access and passage to remorse'. I can imagine she would almost spit out the phrase 'passage to remorse', she sees it as weak minded (something that she detests)

  2. Lady Macbeth's Character in Macbeth.

    decision to fall for the temptation, or to be strong enough to resist their captivation. The three Witches are only responsible for the introduction of these ideas and for further forming ideas in Macbeth head, but they are not responsible for his actions throughout the play.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work