• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Charge of the light brigade poem and film comparison

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

The charge of the Light Brigade "Compare the portrayal of the charge of the Light Brigade in Tennyson's poem and Tony Richardson's film sequence of the same event." The charge of the Light Brigade took place during the Crimean War of 1853 - 1856, when Britain, France and Turkey were fighting Russia for the control of some land in Crimea. This particular charge was made by the Light Brigade, a battalion composed of fleet, light cavalry; designed to quickly break the ranks of an opposing force, and they were adept at dashing in to deal light damage. The attack was meant to secure some cannons that had been recently stolen by the enemy; and Lord Raglan, the overall commander of the British forces, gave the order for the Light Brigade to charge for the cannons. Unfortunately, a mistake was made with the order, and a young Captain Nolan, in his haste to get Lord Cardigan and Lord Lucan to execute the order, pointed to a different valley to the one they were intending to charge. Cardigan was slightly shocked by this, but nonetheless went ahead with the charge - even though in the valley fixed guns awaited their charge; and as Cardigan remarked to Lucan, "It is against all practices of war to have cavalry charge fixed guns." ...read more.

Middle

When the film camera changes from the Light Brigade to the leaders, who are safe on top of a nearby hill, it almost seems as if we have been transported away to a different place, far from where the compact, ready Light Brigade have been stationed, for they do not ever appear to be troubled or concerned at all by the war, as while their guns are being towed away, one of them is talking to a woman about her position in this war; and that he thought women should be dealing with 'pretty things'. This seems worrying that he should be almost chatting to the woman, while their guns were being stolen, and the Light Brigade was needed to mobilize and attack the enemy to regain the use of their cannons. All the way through this extract, the film attempts to get you to look up to, and admire the young people, such as Captain Nolan and the Light Brigade itself - and this reflects the time at which this piece of film was created. All the time, Richardson is subtly trying to side us against the established elders, affecting what we think of them, by portraying them as inefficient and incompetent. ...read more.

Conclusion

At first we may interpret this as courage, and think him a very brave man - but as the attack continues we start to see him under a different light. He does not seem bothered at all by all the gunshots and explosions around him, as if he does not care what happens to him during the charge. Gradually, we see the Light Brigade battered, until they burst through to the fixed cannons, and there they brilliantly attack the Russians, proving that the Light Brigade would be worthy of such a task if not for the sprawling guns present. A retreat is called, however, and the severely reduced brigade staggers and stumbles back to it's own territory - only to be greeted by a cacophony of old men arguing over whose fault the incident is. The Light Brigade was wounded and shattered, but all they could think about was with whom the blame was placed upon. Both the poem and film portray something of what happened on the day the Light Brigade charged, but also include something of the time in which they were produced in - Tennyson's poem does not address the issue of blame, and tries to keep up the country's morale, whereas Richardson's film shows characteristics from the 1960's, where they began to question their establishment. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Miscellaneous essays

  1. Baz Luhrmann act.1 sc.5 film techniques

    This is seen as the beginning and the end of the whole relationship. This event helps the viewers feel more sympathetic towards Romeo and Juliet because so far both Romeo and Juliet's characters are seen as pure and loving. While Juliet is dancing with Paris after being taken away from

  2. The Long and the Short and the Tall - Examine the Characters of ...

    When he finds out that Bamforth gave the prisoner the cigarettes he becomes wildly defensive and apologetic towards the prisoner; 'How was I to know? I...1've told you boy, I thought he'd knocked them off them off.' However, as soon as he thinks that the prisoner has, after all been

  1. Dead Man Walking

    When Poncelet and Sister Helen first meet, there is wire between them and Poncelet's eyes are a dull blue. This shows they are not yet in a spiritual relationship and also Poncelet is not yet "a Son of God." Personally, my favourite visual metaphor is in the death chamber, as

  2. Iago has been called a motiveless malignity. Discuss your personal response in this.

    lieutenant instead of him, he wanted the position Cassio is currently sitting on so he made Cassio loses his job by getting him drunk and persuading Roderigo to start a fight with him, he did this so hopefully Othello would see his behaviour as utterly unacceptable and take away his

  1. gothic horror

    It is also appealing that the red room is situated so far away from the room in which the three custodians gather "Along the passage...come to a door...a spiral staircase...a landing... another door...long corridor...up the steps" the solitary journey the narrator has to cross creates suspense as it is an unusual place to him and anything can happen.

  2. Memoirs of the innocent.

    He pulled my skirt from me and violated me. I shook, and shook, in a desperate attempt to break free. There was no use. Yet another clenched fist threw itself at my body, I vomited, as I felt a foreign object penetrate me.

  1. How does Peter Medak gain the viewer(TM)s sympathy for Derek Bentley in the film ...

    The first scene is then revealed. 'Hellish' and 'chaotic' seem to be the first words that appear in our minds as the camera tracks through an air raid scene of WWII. The camera is set quite low down and moves quite unsteadily in a 'point of view shot' as if we are in the eyes of a young child.

  2. How did Ethan try to escape Starkfield?

    He thought he could do the same sell the farm and give some of the money to Zeena so she could get by and then he and Mattie could move to the city and he and Mattie could get a job and send money to Zeena.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work