• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast 2 different film versions of the opening chapters of the Christmas carol - Version 1- 1999 starring Patrick steward, Version 2 - 2000 starring Ross Kemp.

Extracts from this document...


English Language Coursework Compare and contrast 2 different film versions of the opening chapters of the Christmas carol. Version 1- 1999 starring Patrick steward Version 2 - 2000 starring Ross Kemp Version one is based in nineteenth century London. Society is shown to be split into two very different classes, the poor workers and beggars and the rich businessmen. There are many people dressed in ragged clothing that look thin and dirty. However, these people also tend to look cheerful and happy when compared to Scrooge. He is shown wearing black clothing, looking very intimidating. He has a very serious look on his face. This reflects the idea portrayed in both versions that wealth does not give you happiness, in fact, much the opposite. Buildings in London are dirty and old, such as Scrooge's office where a window cleaner has to wipe his windows just to look inside. Likewise, in Version two, set in modern day London, the flats that Scrooge rents out to people are also old, dirty, but this filth has been modernised to show graffiti, and with a broken lift. Poverty is shown in both films quite differently, firstly, in version 1, the busy London streets, not only show a thriving community, but also show a high population density with lots of overcrowding. Collectors come to scrooge's office asking for money for the poor and Scrooge bluntly refuses and ignores them. ...read more.


Scrooge also appears to have no emotions, when he asks his nephew why he got married, and when he replies he laughs `Because you fell in love?!' When Bob Cratchit asks for Christmas day off to be with his family, Scrooge agrees reluctantly. In the second version, light is more emphasised, at the beginning, we see Christmas lights before the camera pans over to the block of flats that scrooge owns which are very dark and dirty, similar to the scrooges office in version 1. In both versions, scrooge lives in a expensive, and dark home, he makes himself suffer by not lighting his home just to save money. In version 2, music plays a strong part in the film. It begins with carols, which overlay crime scene, this creates a shocking contrast of Christmas joy and murder which gives dramatic effect. It has also modernised the film by using Christmas carols as disco tunes, which inject entertainment and energy into the film. When we see images of young people, including Scrooges girlfriend, a poor nurse, dancing and enjoying themselves contrasted against Scrooge sat on his own looking depressed, it backs up the view that wealth does not buy you happiness. There is little use of music in version 1, however, music is used to build up the tension when the bells are ringing in scrooge's house, and scrooge hears chains rattling in the basement, it is slow, eerie and dramatic. ...read more.


However, the more traditional scrooge, like in the original text is cold and harsh. The two films although they are set over a century apart still retain the principles of the original stories. It is inevitable, that with two different films, the producers will have different ideas about the final product, however, the differences are quite remarkable between these two. Apart from the obvious differences, including the year and the setting, a coloured man has also replaced Marley. This draws out the issue of racism and racist crimes, as Marley was obviously murdered. Although we do not know that it was a racial motive, it represents the murder of teenager Stephen Lawrence as it remains unsolved. The modern version has been used to draw attraction to other issues as well such as homelessness. It makes us think of how we treat them in the streets as Scrooge's chases off the homeless and shouts abuse at big issue sellers. Version one keeps to the traditional roots in Dickens's original text. Much remains unchanged, apart from the occasional line `You may just be a bit of undigested British Beef'. Both stories show Scrooge as a lonely man, with few friends, and living in a dark flat alone. I think that the modern version is the better, as I think the producer had a more difficult job of retaining the principles of the story whilst giving it a modern influence to appeal to a younger audience. It translates parts of the story that we would otherwise have difficulty understanding. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE A Christmas Carol section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE A Christmas Carol essays

  1. A Christmas Carol - Marley's Ghost.

    If I could work my will,' said Scrooge indignantly, 'every idiot who goes about with ''Merry Christmas'' on his lips should be boiled with his own pudding, and buried with a stake of holly through his heart. He should!' 'Uncle!'

  2. The novel 'A Christmas Carol', by Charles

    Scrooge replied " A golden one". And so she left him and they parted. We could see there that Scrooge had lost all interest and that his only love from then till the present was his love for money. The ghost then showed Scrooge the life he could have had if he had not left his love.

  1. Show how Dickens presents the change in Scrooge's view of life and death. Look ...

    Scrooge gets a strong feeling that Bob wants him by his side forever but knows he won't be there for long. "Spirit... tell me if Tiny Tim will live" From this quotation we see for the first time that Scrooge cares for Tiny Tim and feels for Bob Cratchitt.

  2. Dickens is trying to change Victorian society. How does he use the ghosts to ...

    what will happen, whether Scrooge is going insane or whether there really is a ghost. Marley reappears later that night, dragging with him a long and heavy chain, and Scrooge still refuses to believe in the apparition. Marley warns Scrooge that he is forging a chain in life that he will wear in death.

  1. Examine how dickens uses the supernatural as a vehicle for change in 'A Christmas ...

    because of Scrooges job, "it was made of cashboxes, keys, padlocks, ledgers, deeds and heavy purses wrought in steel." The third ghost is the "Ghost of Christmas present." This ghost is rather different to the other three as it is more human like than ghostly, also it is more pleasant

  2. To What Extent does Dickens's 'A Christmas Carol' fit into the Genre of the ...

    The plot is always important to any story but to a supernatural story it is usually simple with a battle between benevolent and malevolent forces. 'A Christmas Carol' has the good, the Cratchitts, Fred and to a certain extent the spirits, and the bad, Ebenezer Scrooge.

  1. Nesta Robert Marley.

    They called themselves the Teenagers.Nesta acted as the leader, writing most of the material. "It was kinda difficult," said Joe Higgs later, "to get the group precise -and their sound - and to get the harmony structures. It took a couple of years to get that perfect.

  2. A Christmas Carol - Aspects that would appeal to the 18th century audience and ...

    I think a lot of people who knew Scrooge would fear him because he was so wealthy and also very powerful, of course money is power and I don't suppose it was any different then in 19th century. The modern day audience would have many high expectations for Christmas time.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work