• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast a 20th Century and non-20th Century Animal Poem

Extracts from this document...


Adam Wright 14th Nov 2001 Compare and Contrast a 20th Century and non-20th Century Animal Poem 1. Introduction/brief explanation 2. Themes 3. Structure and form a. Stressed/unstressed, iambic pentameter etc b. Form on page, reasons for. 4. Language and Poetry techniques 5. Personal preference and reason For this essay I need to compare and contrast a pre 20th Century and 20th Century piece of poetry that share animals. The Two poems I have chosen are Horses be Edwin Muir for my pre 20th century piece. For my 20th century text I have chosen "The Jaguar" by Ted Hughes. The two poets are using their poetry to inform their audience about their beliefs and thoughts on certain issues. In "Horses" by Edwin Muir the poet is informing the audience about his thoughts on the beginning of the industrial revolution and the effect it will have on the countryside and in particular the shire horse. In "The Jaguar" Ted Hughes makes us aware of his dislike of zoos and the imprisonment of animals and the feelings they encounter, boredom, hope and loneliness. Within "Horses" the poet informs us about his fascination with the shire horse. He describes them as 'like a magic power'. This fascination has been lifelong, from some 'childish hour' to the present time. The poet is fascinated by their strength and beauty, with their 'conquering hooves' on 'great hulks'. ...read more.


For a pre 20th century poem the language is not too archaic and there certainly aren't any words that need to be looked up in a dictionary to be understood. The poem is rich in imagery and to form this imagery the poet has used lots of similes and metaphors; these are very effective. Edwin Muir uses the industrial revolution's 'pistons' in a 'mill' to describe the hooves of the Shire horse in a simile. Edwin Muir also uses the metaphor of tanks to describe their 'great hulks' and their 'conquering'. This metaphor is strong and suitable; the Shire horse is comparatively the tank of the horse world, not necessarily the fastest but most definately both the strongest and toughest. When describing both their beauty and size Edwin Muir is using a oxymoron. When the poet uses the metaphor in 'their great hulks were seraphim of gold', seraphim being angelic, he is really describing them as both small and angelic but of a grand stature. Although an obvious contradiction and oxymoron I believe this is the poet in some small way describing his fascination and also confusion about these 'lumbering' beasts. Edwin Muir also uses metaphor to describe the glossy coat of the horse; the poet describes 'light flowing' off their 'bossy sides in flakes.' ...read more.


Ted Hughes describes the ability of defiance and the glimmer of hope in the Jaguar by his use of the language. The jaguar, metaphorically the eye, 'is satisfied to be blind in a fire.' Ted Hughes is saying although the evidence of life imprisoned totally surrounds the Jaguar he is able to defy it. The ear is 'brain deaf.' The Jaguar has withdrawn inside his own world. A world of defiance with a glimmer of hope but more importantly a different place outside the four walls of his cell. Both poems are successful. They both inspire strong imagery and strong thoughts about the relationship between animals and man, whether it be for pleasure or to advance man itself. Poems normally bore me immensely but by looking into these poems in detail I have found that underneath a very enjoyable surface they both have many serious points to be made within their subtext. Both also have many merits and are definitely lacking on points of criticism. Between the two my personal favourite is "The Jaguar" because of the issues it addresses. The jaguar gave me a creative impression of issues such as our new perception as animals having increased intelligence and their feelings in captivity, issues that have been in the news recently. The imagery Ted Hughes generated in my mind was also a special point for me. Some of his metaphors (thought the one about the parrots and the cheap tarts was superb) helped me understand his viewpoint of captivity. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Ted Hughes section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Ted Hughes essays

  1. Ted Hughes, the thought fox, is an effective poem on both a literal and ...

    As we are reading this poem, we may gripped by the image of the fox because it is so graphic, the movement, appearance, and behavior of the fox are brilliantly described. However we have to be aware that what we are really seeing is the formation of words, poetry, in

  2. How does Ted Hughes convey the ruthless power and violence in animals through the ...

    The hawk and pike both have physical power. They use these powers to the full extent. The pike's life is "subdued to instruments", it's "jaws hooked clamp and fangs." These lines show the killing instruments the pike has. Just as the hawk has a "hooked head and hooked feet" so to the pike has hooked jaws.

  1. Using a Selection of 20th Century Poems Compare and Contrast the Treatment of ...

    Although the poem is about nature which seems like an innocent subject the tone is slightly dark. Words like "blood" and "squander" are used which gives an image of the blackberries bleeding. Strangely the blackberry bushes are described as "hooks" which is not a very nice word and seems unnecessary.

  2. The company I have chosen to investigate is Jaguar.

    financial services. Some companies or organisations combine a mixture of both, goods and services. This company will sell goods to the customers and they will also sell services. Some companies for example will provide goods and service locally like a local newsagent or doctors.

  1. 19th & 20th Century Birds of Poetry - The eagle is a poem with ...

    He does this by using lines like "And like a thunderbolt he falls." This refers to the ancient gods and gives you an image of a god throwing the eagle at its prey. Whereas in "The Hawk", the bird is almost referred to as a murderer, or at least a

  2. Concentrating on one Poem by each Poet, Compare and Contrast the ways in which ...

    This shows that Hughes thinks of the bird and nature in general as very smooth and good at what they do implying that we should learn from it. The way Hughes says 'blue-dark' instead of dark blue emphasises the point by getting you to notice it more easily.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work