• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast blackberry picking and death of a naturalist both by Seamus Heaney

Free essay example:

Compare and Contrast Blackberry Picking and Death of a Naturalist both by Seamus Heaney.

The purpose of this assignment is to compare two poems Death of a Naturalist and Black Berry picking both by Seamus Heaney. I will look for similarities and differences between the two poems by looking at content, voice, structure, setting, theme, tone and imagery.

The content of the two poems are both similar as each are about life cycles, fascination and disappointment in nature. The general idea of each poem is Seamus Heaney as a child going out into the countryside collecting samples of nature, either blackberries or frogspawn and storing or displaying his findings until they grow up or rot. In Blackberry Picking Heaney also writes about how year after year he picks and stores blackberries when in the back of his mind he knows that they won’t last forever, or as long as he would like them to. Death of a Naturalist explores the idea of growing up and when he returns to the place he collected the frogspawn he feels threatened by adult frogs.

The voice is the poet as a child describing and recalling childhood memories and experiences Occasionally the voice of a child comes though as well to show his childish points of view and opinions, in Blackberry Picking Heaney says,

‘It wasn’t fair…’

An adult would not say this. I like the way Seamus uses this technique because it helps you to believe that he is experiencing the moment as an immature child, instead of an adult looking back. Also, in Death of a Naturalist Heaney refers to the male or larger frog as a Daddy instead of a Father.

‘The Daddy frog…’

An adult would not say this or refer to the Father as a ‘Daddy’. This childish language again reinforces the point of view as being from a child.

In both poems the structures are both very much the same. Each one has a longer stanza that is full of lust and happiness and is twice the size of the second stanza, which is full of disappointment and letdown.  His use of nostalgia in the larger stanzas, demonstrates how it can give childhood memories a happy return.  The shorter stanzas which are full of disappointment and let down show a lower more solemn tone which show the fact that he does not want to dwell on the negative part of the life cycle. Both poems have a break between the two stanza’s giving time to change the mood.

Another similarity is the setting. Blackberry picking is set in the countryside in co. Londonderry. We know they’re both in Londonderry because that is where Seamus Heaney grew up, and the poems are about him as a child. Death of naturalist is also set in the countryside although it also has references to his school and the flax dam. Whereas blackberry picking tells us he is walking round fields to find the ripe blackberries.

‘Round hayfields, cornfields and potato drills’

This gives the carefree image of the children involved in the poem walking round the countryside looking for the ripest blackberries that they can find.

The first theme that links the two poems together is nature and lifecycles in nature. Both talk about how everything comes to an end and dies or rots away. In Blackberry picking. Heaney tells us how he loved collecting ripe blackberries and just looking at them and their changing colours. Where as in Death of a naturalist he talks about frogs and their changing lifecycles from frogspawn, to tadpoles, to frogs and how the child feels threatened by this change. At the same time the child is growing up and learning more about life and growing up by beginning to question things instead of taking on board everything he is told, like a child does. Another similarity is letdown and disappointment. The title its self ‘Death of a naturalist’ could also signify a part of his own lifecycle and how his life cycle has ended. In the first stanza of each poem it is full of enthusiasm and optimism which contrasts with the second stanza, about disappointment and negativity. This tells us how nature isn’t what you expect it to be, it’s full of surprises, good and bad. The sub theme which is more hidden in the poems, mainly blackberry picking is religion and its connexion to nature. Deeper thinking leads us to believe it is telling us about the power of the universe contained in nature. It also hints at Christianity by giving references to Jesus Christ by using words like ‘blood, flesh, thorns and wine’ that are all things mentioned in the bible.

The tone in the two poems is very similar in the first, longer stanza of the two the tone is positive. In blackberry picking Heaney uses words like ‘Lust, sweet and glossy’ Death of a naturalist uses words like ‘nimble and delicately’ however in the second stanza of it poem it gives us a bitter feeling of death and disappointment. Death of a naturalist does this best by using words like ‘Rank, vengeance and sickened’ Black berry picking also uses powerful words like ‘fungus, glutting and sour’ This is effective because the poem is contrasting tones with the first stanza.

A clear link between poems is the effective use of imagery to communicate with the reader. Both poems contain positive imagery in stanza one because the mood is happy and uplifting. An example from blackberry picking is …

‘A glossy purple clot’

This works because it automatically makes you think of a blood clot. Picking up on its shape and colour. Stanza two gives us a lot of negative imagery and feeling. An example from death of a naturalist is …  

‘Poised like mud grenades’

This is effective because it makes you think of a strange object just sat there covered in mud, waiting to go off or attack. It also makes some people cringe at the fact there are frogs covered in a lot of mud.

Having analysed the two poems in great detail I have found that there are more similarities than differences. The only two differences I have found about the two poems is that death of a naturalist is set by a flux dam and inside a school when blackberry picking is set in late August and I have no proof other than the lifecycles but Death of a naturalist was probably set in spring but could have been any time of the year. The other was the surface difference, Death of a naturalist is about frogs life cycles and Black berry picking is more about childhood memories and how he used to enjoy picking blackberries just to look at and when they died and rotted away he was let down.

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Seamus Heaney section.

(?)
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Related GCSE English Skills and Knowledge Essays

See our best essays

Related GCSE Seamus Heaney essays

  1. Death of a naturalist and An Advancement of Learning by Seamus Heaney, Roe Deer ...

    Roe-deer may seem like a very weird poem. Ted Hughes has a strong belief. That is, we as humans have our own world and animals have their own. We will never understand each other but however we will live together side by side. In this poem Hughes claims he almost came to knowledge of the animal world, specifically the deer world which he says "secret deer hood."

  2. Compare and Contrast 'Death of a Naturalist', ' An Advancement of Learning' and ' ...

    There aren't any metaphors in this poem. Heaney has used some of the five senses in the poem, he has used sound ("bass chorus", smell ("farting") and sight (The poem can give you a picture in your head). Also Heaney has used words such as "mammy" and "daddy" when talking

  1. Seamus Heaney - Death of A Naturalist

    The second stanza shows the change to realising the reality. Heaney is disgusted. The smell is disgusting, like cow dung, which shows how Heaney feels. Heaney shows the atmosphere by writing about the "angry frogs", the "coarse" sounds and the "thick air, gross bellied frogs" and the "groans".

  2. Blackberry Picking

    He was so tempted as he had waited a whole year for the berries to come. The use of the phrase, 'first one' gives us, yet another indication to the fact that there will be more berries to come. We are yet again reminded of the image of blood with the use of the noun 'flesh'.

  1. A comparative study of "The Death of a naturalist" by Seamus Heaney and "The ...

    The quote in the poem, "Their blunt heads farting" What the author is trying to say is that the frog's heads had really bad odour, this is most probably why Heaney used this type of quote. The experience with the frogs has made Heaney feel much different, his view has totally changed.

  2. Compare Death of a Naturalist, Advancement of Learning and Roe Deer.

    Roe Deer is the poem told by Ted Hughes as a man, who tells it in a sort of science fiction way. The poem is all about the possibility of experiences we cannot justify in the world we live in.

  1. Compare and contrast 'Death of a Naturalist' and 'Digging' by Seamus Heaney.

    A part of this passion is being aware of a host of small things that many people would find insignificant; animals, frogspawn and all the noises of life around him. This changes in the second stanza. The poet has a change of heart and he seems to retreat from the nature he previously loved.

  2. Compare and contrast the poems 'Death of a Son', 'Mid-Term Break' and 'Remember' - ...

    Heaney himself appears bored because he counts the bells, as if longing to be "anywhere but here". Then his neighbours drive him home, and everything seems almost normal, but the reader is left feeling uneasy waiting for something to mark this "almost normal" behaviour.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work