• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast Lear and Macbeth's effectiveness as Kings.

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast how effective King Lear and Macbeth are as monarchs In order to assess how effective King Lear and Macbeth are as monarchs, it is first necessary to look at the qualities that a 17th century leader should have, compared with a 21st century leader. In the 17th century there was a strong belief in the Divine Right of Kings, that the monarch was anointed by God. It was believed that only God could change a monarch and if anyone tried to interfere, God would wreak his revenge and spread disorder and chaos. Although the monarch was anointed by God, this did not mean that they did not have responsibilities. They were expected to love and serve God and also love and serve their people. The monarchs were also supposed to possess certain qualities which would help them create a strong nation. God gave them the qualities of wisdom, good judgement, justice and mercy, by using their power without destruction. Monarchs were seen as the people's leader and people looked to their monarch for guidance, strength and hope. Today, we look for different attributes in our leaders. We elect people who are charismatic, decisive, open minded and trustworthy. ...read more.


However he is not wise enough to see that he is being manipulated by Lady Macbeth. "And live a coward, in thine own esteem" Macbeth has proved in battle and to the King that he is not a coward, and has been rewarded for his loyalty and bravery. Yet he allows himself to be persuaded to murder Duncan, even though his instinct tells him it is wrong because Lady Macbeth challenges his masculinity. Lear is also manipulated and lied to by women. Gonerill and Regan persuade him to give them half his Kingdom, pretending they love him and him alone, even though they are married. In her declaration Regan says; "I profess Myself an enemy to all other joys." Lear is unwise to the fact that both Gonerill and Regan are deceiving him in order to inherit the Kingdom. He fails to see that he cannot keep the name of King and give away his Kingdom. A leader should be able to recognise when he is being lied to, but he is too blinded by flattery to realise. However is it unrealistic for a father to expect loyalty from his three daughters? As a father, it would be unnatural to question the promises made by Gonerill and Regan. ...read more.


From here we see Macbeth slowly become mad with power and he goes back to the witches for advice. By going back to the witches, not only does he go to God's enemy for advice thus failing to love and serve God, but he also displays a total lack of wisdom. At this point in the play, the audience believe Macbeth has allowed himself to get so immersed in evil that it is impossible for him to have any kind of positive effect on his people or country. However, at the very end of the extract, I feel respect for Macbeth. Even after every hope had been lost, he continued to fight and died defending his people and country. Despite losing his mind, Macbeth still shows bravery, loyalty and love of his country and people. Macbeth is a survivor who did what was necessary to defend his Kingdom. King Lear and Macbeth are two very interesting and unpredictable characters who change a great deal throughout the two plays. Ultimately we have to consider who is the more effective monarch. Is it Lear, alone, bitter, blaming everyone around him for his mistakes and blinded by anger and revenge or Macbeth, who died in battle to protect his Kingdom? ?? ?? ?? ?? 3 Jamie Boughen Compare and Contrast King Lear and Macbeth's effectiveness as Kings ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE King Lear section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE King Lear essays

  1. Representation of Women in 'King Lear'

    Unlike her sisters, Cordelia does not, and will not, use "...that glib and oily art," of her sisters "...To speak and purpose not;" (to say what one does not mean), (Act I, Scene I, Lines 219-220). In return for not lying as her sisters have done, she is banished by her father and given nothing.

  2. King Lear an essay about Shakespeare's presentation of women in "King Lear".

    The scene also shows that Goneril is going to join forces with Regan to stop Lear from overruling them. "I'll write straight to my sister to hold my very course" There Goneril is telling Oswald that she is going to write to Regan, and tell her that she should act like her when Lear goes to her house.

  1. King Lear - Lear Exclaims in Act 3 That He is "More Sinned Against ...

    He asks, "Is there any cause in nature that makes these hard hearts?" (3/6/35) He has now fully realised the extent of his daughter's wickedness. The mock trial has finally exorcised the obsession of ingratitude and King Lear's redemption is almost complete.

  2. King lear

    Gloucester's title by writing a letter to Gloucester saying that Edgar will kill Gloucester for his power and making out it was Edgar that wrote it. The audience gets hope because at the end of the play Edgar survived and the others die, promoting that good triumphed over evil in the end.

  1. How Does Lear change throughout the play?

    He has unquestionable obedience. Lear can't take advice from others. We see this as Kent disagrees with Lear's decision to banish Cordelia. "Come not between the dragon and his wrath" We see Lear as stubborn and hot-tempered after Kent just tries to give him some friendly advice after he mistakenly banishes Cordelia.

  2. Character Analyses - King Lear

    Albany leads his army in defense of the kingdom, although with great reluctance. The audience witnesses his personal growth, and the culmination of change is clear when he assumes control of the kingdom following the battle's conclusion. Character Analyses Duke of Cornwall Cornwall is Regan's brutal husband, vicious and savage when thwarted in his efforts to seize ambition.

  1. King Lear

    The quote where Lear casts her out is in Act 1, scene 1, lines 111-115, and is shown below... "From whom we do exist and cease to be, Here I disclaim all my paternal care, Propinquity and property of blood, And as a stranger to my heart and me Hold thee from this for ever."

  2. An Analysis of the Role of Comedy in Shakespeares Great Tragedy King Lear

    This shows the widespread effect that Lear?s actions have on the country he used to rule: what he does in Act One, scene one, affects not only him and his daughters, but also the land and people he once ruled over.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work