• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast "Pneumoconiosis" and "He loved light, freedom and animals".

Extracts from this document...


Huw Liddell 16/11/03 Compare and contrast "Pneumoconiosis" and "He loved light, freedom and animals" Both poems have a connection with coal mines. Pneumoconiosis is a disease caught in the mines by many coal miners, which affects the lungs. The background of "He loved light, freedom and animals" is about a mining disaster in Aberfan. A slag heap on the side of a mountain gave way and engulfed parts of the small town. "Pneumoconiosis" is written by Duncan Bush and is written in the first person, "But it's had forty years in me now" He talks as if it's happening to him. This is affective because we can relate with this character better by understanding what he is feeling and going through. Mike Jenkins wrote "He loved light, freedom and animals" as if he were an eyewitness to the disaster. Throughout the poem Mike Jenkins uses past tense to recall back to the moments like memories. "His scream was stopped mid-flight!" This gives us a clue about the father's denial throughout the poem, as he constantly recalls back to that day. "Pneumoconiosis" is an old man talking about the effects of the disease on his life. We know he's old man because he talks about this life. ...read more.


Take stanza three for instance. "When the tumour on the hillside burst and the black blood of coal drowned him, he ran forever with his sheepdog leaping for sticks, tumbling together in windblown abandon." Notice that the first three lines are associated with death, "tumour", "blood" and "drowned". The last couple of lines are about freedom and happiness, "ran forever" and "leaping". Therefore I find that the poet is trying to hide the fact that this boy died by remembering times while he was alive. This is affective because by trying to be positive it highlights the sadness of the father and the poem thus creating sympathy. To me the title of "Pneumoconiosis" makes me want to read the poem. I was curious to know what pneumoconiosis is because I never heard of it. The opening line immediately wanted me to read on. It is a short, blunt line, spaced out from the rest of the poem, "This is the dust," The "the" makes it more than just ordinary dust - something far more powerful. The following line also had an impression on me. "Black diamond dust." All of these words start with a hard sounding letter, giving a bitter sound to it. ...read more.


There is a good use of repetition at the beginning of the second stanza. "Buried alive - alive he is" This emphasises that he hasn't died. I get the feeling that the poet is in denial of this boy's death. Also the first line is almost a contradiction in terms. With "Pneumoconiosis" the poet brings up thoughts of death instead of life. Unlike "Pneumoconiosis", "He loved light, freedom and animals" has a lot more personification. This brings a descriptive element to the poem, which helps us understand it better. "Tumour on the hillside" This is effective because everybody knows that tumours are connected with death, and tumour is being used instead of slag heap. At the end of the poem, Mike Jenkins uses far more poetic techniques than Duncan Bush. He uses more personification, alliteration and run-on lines. To me this makes it a better read because it's more enjoyable and creates better imagery in my mind. After studying both poems I preferred "Pneumoconiosis" to "He loved light, freedom and animals" because I felt more sympathy towards the old man than to the father. Although "He loved light, freedom and animals" had more poetic techniques and descriptive writing, I found that the lack of them in "Pneumoconiosis" added to the affect of sympathy to the old man. I also found that Duncan Bush had conveyed the character of an old man extremely well and affective. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE War Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE War Poetry essays

  1. Compare and Contrast Beautiful Old Age by D.H. Lawrence with Geriatric Ward by Phoebe ...

    This line means that peaceful old people should be like apples (be complete) like in the second stanza) when they are tired of love. The last two lines of the second stanza compare the feelings of the aged to autumn, "Fragrant like yellowing leaves, and dim with the soft stillness

  2. Compare and contrast The Charge of the Light Brigade by Tennyson with The last ...

    This is shown, as Tennyson does not repeat the line "But not, not the six hundred." This line does suggest the amount of casualties but is only skimmed over. In contrast to this Tennyson uses repetition to reinforce his own message, Tennyson writes "Honour the charge they made, Honour the light brigade."

  1. Compare and contrast the ways in which writers present their attitudes to the First ...

    I don't think the poet is on anybody's side, and is just bitter towards the situation caused by the war. I think he feels sympathy for the mother, because not only has her son died, she will never know the truth about him.

  2. Compare and contrast "White Roses" with "Stop all the Clocks."

    the word "bones" instead of flesh or skin to perhaps emphasize how weak and fragile he is. Like an eldery person. In the fifth stanza the poet uses s metaphor to describe how much pain was inflicted upon the boy, by the cats paws, "Kneading, with diamond paws his dry

  1. Compare and contrast two different media treatment of the Charge of the Light Brigade..

    Because of this, the second stanza ends on a sour note and there is a great emphasis on death, on togetherness and on the glorious soldiers. The fact that all three of those lines begin with the same word (their's)

  2. Prize Giving - review.

    Believing she could walk on water, she jumped in and had to be rescued by her father. After saving her he was 'half comforting, half angry'. Just as she thought she could defy gravity and walk on water, so the pumpkins in her friends' garden 'in airy defiance of nature'

  1. Comparing Mountain Lion and Badger.

    The alliteration of 'f' in 'face', 'frost', 'fashioned', all add to the perfection of this creature and how amazed the poet is. As the 'f' sound is quite soft. In Badger the poet sets the scene very differently to that in Mountain Lion.

  2. Critics have spent entire books interpreting Gray's

    Last, "uncouth rhymes," "shapeless sculpture," and "many a holy text" that characterize their "frail" cemetery memorials, and even those markers with only a simple name and age at death, "spelt by th' unlettered muse" (81), serve the important universal human needs: to prompt "the passing tribute of a sigh" (80)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work