• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast Tennyson's 'Mariana' with Browning's 'Porphyria's Lover'. What is the emotional state of each speaker and how effectively is this conveyed?

Extracts from this document...


Compare and Contrast Tennyson's 'Mariana' with Browning's 'Porphyria's Lover'. What is the emotional state of each speaker and how effectively is this conveyed? Tennyson and Browning were contemporary Victorian poets. During his lifetime, Tennyson was made Poet Laureate. His poem 'Mariana' is very cyclical and minimal. The mood is depressive, which reflected Tennyson's family traits, as Tennyson himself was very susceptible to depression. However, Browning's 'Porphyria's Lover' is very linear as the action clearly moves from one stage to another and is not so repetitive. The remote and rural location of each poem portrays a sense of loneliness and isolation that is directed towards the central character. This heightens feeling and emotion and enables them to be introspected and egocentric. Both Mariana and Porphyria's Lover as people are unhappy with their current lives. They both desire love, as they feel frustrated because of their lovers. However, the two are slightly different. Mariana has been dejected whereas Porphyria's lover needs to control the relationship. In verse one of 'Mariana', the overall theme is one of isolation and neglect. The 'rusted nails' and 'broken shed' set the scene that Mariana too is neglected throughout the poem. 'My life is dreary' is Mariana showing her depression and also turning the misery in on herself; her lover 'cometh not'. ...read more.


The tree is a masculine symbol. The fact that there is only one tree suggests that there is only one man for her and because he doesn't come, there's no chance for Mariana's life to change. The symbolism picks up over the next few verses. The end of the stanza shows how the cycle continues for Mariana because she is back to saying how 'Her life is dreary' and repeats the same order until the last verse. The vocabulary used in verse five is more violent and visual than the nature words before. The poem moves into her room on the first line, 'And ever the moon was low.' The white curtain is the symbol of Mariana's fading light and hopefulness as the shadow starts to cover the curtain. The curtain is like Mariana's white flag as she surrenders to hope of a change. Her emotions are portrayed really well as 'Wild winds bound within their cell.' The winds pick up at the same time as her emotions and she is again like the sluice because her thoughts are held up like the water. The shadow of the tree falling across the bed is a clever way of showing he sexual frustration because only the tree's shadow will ever be on her bed, not the real man. ...read more.


The verse ends with 'I am very dreary' and 'He will not come'. She is now more tired than ever before and gives up on all hope of her lover coming. We know this because she uses definitive future tense for the first time in the poem. She accepts it but is not happy about it and even cries because of it again. Both central characters appeal to God at the end of the poems. Porphyria's lover is in another world. He thinks that God endorsed his actions, 'God has not said a word.' Mariana realises that the only way to overcome her problem is to kill herself, 'O God, that I were dead!' Another similarity is obvious here because both solutions are death but the difference is that Mariana but must commit suicide. 'Mariana' is very much a Victorian feminist poem in stressing female passivity, which was very prominent in that era. 'Porphyria's Lover' reinforces the idea of male activity and dominance compared with females having the over ruling power. Both poems are very successful in portraying desperate situations but focus on different points. Tennyson is very effective in showing a switch in power and the thought process of the central character. However, Browning's depiction of detail around Mariana's entrapment is most impressive. The way we can see her life going round and round in circles with amazing background ingredients is fantastic imagery by Tennyson. Therefore I think Mariana is more effective. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Robert Browning section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Robert Browning essays

  1. Browning's philosophy of life.

    This faith that man's success would be judged not by achievements only but by his efforts and endeavors too, is voiced fervently in "Rabbi Ben Ezra": "But all, the worlds' coarse thumb And finger failed to plumb, So passed in making up the main account, All instincts immature, All purposes

  2. Porphyria's Lover by Robert Browning - an Analysis and exploration of the poem and ...

    For Browning, the genre provided a sort of play-space and an alternative persona with which he can explore sometimes-controversial ideas. He often further distanced himself by employing historical characters, particularly from the Italian Renaissance where art and religion were two juxtaposing issues.

  1. Compare The ways In Which Tennyson And Browning Present The Theme Of Love In ...

    the reader because of the poems mysteriousness of the lovers, it would also be very effective to Victorian readers as they liked mysteries and murder stories and poems. In "The Sisters" we have the line, "O the Earl was fair to see," but this is a refrain at the end

  2. comparing porphyria's lover and the sisters

    This could be because the sister is obsessed with the Earl that even after his death she still wants to be near him. The sister's mood is again reflected in the weather. "The wind is blowing in turret and tree."

  1. Comparing the way two different authors portray love and saying which one was the ...

    Sir twas not her husband's presence only, called that spot of joy into the Duchess' cheek" (13-15) It is as if he was so confounded by the fact that she could possibly seek happiness in anything that wasn't him.

  2. Comparison between two poems - We have been reading two different poems 'Porphyria's Lover' ...

    This sister needed revenge on him because of this. It was something she needed to do because he didn't chose her. In the poem he is a bit of a fool to let himself be sucked into her plan. He went to a feast that she invited him to and there she "won his love".

  1. “Occasionally an anti-climax can be suprisingly effective”[Andrew Crocker-Harris] How successful is the ending of ...

    a second grave wrong and why they do not even discuss splitting up or divorce. The divorce would ruin all of Millie aspirations of social climbing and joining the aristocracy. The Browning Version is named after a translation of the Agamemnon, written by Aeschylus as one third of the Oresteia, by Robert Browning (1812-1889).

  2. Browning's porphyria's lover

    us twice he is certain Porphyria felt no pain; in addition to this, he describes opening her eyes after he strangles her and seeing that "again / Laughed the blue eyes without a stain" (44-45). Equally perplexing are his reports that after he "untightened" Porphyria's tresses from around her neck,

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work