• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the approach taken by the two poets, George Bilgere and Diane Thiel, when looking at their relationship with their fathers in the poems "Catch" and "Minefield".

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Caitlin Nash-Robinson 10P(X) Compare and contrast the approach taken by the two poets, George Bilgere and Diane Thiel, when looking at their relationship with their fathers in the poems "Catch" and "Minefield". In the poems "Catch" and "Minefield", the poets, George Bilgere and Diane Thiel both reveal how the difficult relationships that they experienced with their fathers have shaped both their pasts, the present and their futures. Both poets have started their poems by relating what they believed were the causes of their father's behaviour towards themselves and their families. In Diane Thiel's poem, "Minefield", she explains how her fathers past has had an effect on her childhood and parts of her adult life. The title "Minefield" has so many different meanings; it could mean that her life is like a minefield, or that the minefield was the significant event that shaped the lives of her father, herself and their family. It could be referring to the minefield that she sees in her future, or that her father is like an unexploded mine ready to go off at any time if or when someone makes a simple mistake or puts a foot out of line like his young friend did all those years ago. She starts the poem by writing about her father's worst childhood memory. The first verse is made effective because Thiel does not actually state what happened to her father; rather she describes what happened to his friend. ...read more.

Middle

She is looking towards her future and wondering if her own personal experience of growing with a difficult father will shape her ability to be a good parent or will, once again, the past rise through another generation to carry on causing suffering again. Thiel says that she "would have to run on alone" this means that she is still running from her fathers past as well as her own, and is she using his past as a justification for her actions as her father uses the past as an excuse for his own actions and as a reason for the type of man he has become. George Bilgere doesn't write about his fathers past, but about his father's obsession/hobby that did not affect his fathers past but his, George Bilgere, own past, present and future. Bilgere didn't care for his father's hobby but only paid attention to see if his father could live up to Bilgeres childhood aspirations/dreams as to what his father was, is or could be. Bilgere does not try to soften the blow in the same manner as Thiel does, because Bilgere has faced up to the fact that his father is not the man he thought and hoped he would be, but Thiel understands why her father is like he is, although they are both afraid of what might happen with their fathers in the future. ...read more.

Conclusion

The fathers throw was like a "raw confession", it was never rough around the edges or covered up to soften the blow of what his father was capable of doing. His throw was "helpless in the failing light" in which Bilgere can still feel "the balls soft kiss". "Thirty years later" makes it seem like he, Bilgere, can never escape the embarrassment which his father subjected him to as a child, always trying, but never achieving in what Bilgeres father thought he knew everything about. Although Bilgere is older and has faced up to the reality of what his father put him through he is still "afraid to throw it back" because he still doesn't want to face the humiliation that his father subjected him to, but still might think that some of his aspirations/dreams about his father may still come true. "Minefield" by Diane Thiel and "Catch" by George Bilgere are both based on difficult relationships between father and child, Thiel and Bilgere approach the subject in completely different ways. Thiel relates all her experiences to her fathers past, while Bilgere concentrates on his own feelings whilst ignoring how his father may have felt. Thiel shows some compassion for her father while Bilgere seems to be more selfish in his appraisal of his father's behaviour. Both poets express themselves as worrying that their fathers have taken over their lives, rather than allowing them to shape their own futures, while offering gentle guidance. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE George Eliot section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE George Eliot essays

  1. "Discuss some themes and characteristics of T.S.Eliot's work, using 2/3 poems to justify your ...

    Through fantasizing or day-dreaming, the individual escapes the limitations of reality, attempting to fulfil their desires and alleviate the pain of living and reality. Prufrock wished he had the freedom of "a pair of ragged claws" that are "scuttling across the floors of the silent seas" where there is peace

  2. "Analyse the representation of Multicultural Britain in the films Bend It Like Beckham and ...

    The final scene shows Jess and Jules' families at the airport saying goodbye to their daughters, giving parting gifts - again here we see the culture differences. Jules receives an England shirt whilst Jess receives a picture of Guru Nanak, and although this scene is intended to show the contrast

  1. With reference to at least 3 poems in the selection, discuss Eliot's achievement and ...

    The Hyacinth girl has many important roles sexually she could suggest something of the more profound "Young man carbuncular". An idea that is also contributed throughout the poem is that the past is continuously there "Memory" and the idea of mixing the past and future shows the inability to relate to the present.

  2. They do the Poet in Different Voices

    The acknowledgement of the multi-vocal is held within the idea of doing someone in 'Different Voices' for which voice is the one to believe? Which voice is Eliot's? He is certainly not a poet to give up his secrets easily, for you need only scratch the surface to uncover a

  1. Mary Anne Evans, better known as "George Eliot," was born on November 22nd, 1819, ...

    In the house of one of her married half-sisters she met a young man who promised, at that time, to take a distinguished position in his profession. A kind of engagement, or semi-engagement, took place, which Mr. Evans refused to countenance, and finally his daughter broke it off in a

  2. Superficiality in the poem the wasteland.

    They engage in inconsequential talk, without true depth, as a means of escaping what has been left to them after the war. Eliot indicates how the characters in The Wasteland have lost their roots and cannot establish their identity. As a result they are alive but they are not living.

  1. Forgive But Never Forget

    She had not seen where the grave was; all she remembered was the black marble. She turned her body round; it was if she could feel the other people there judge her. They should judge her, she thought, she had not been to the grave since the funeral.

  2. To what extent do you agree that social and moral analysis is required of ...

    It was only after reading the quotes that form the basis of my question that I realised how much discrimination is involved in reading the book. What I mean by discrimination is that when reading "Middlemarch" George Eliot helps us to make fine distinctions between right and wrong, we have

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work