• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the characters of Ralph and Jack - How do their characters affect their leadership styles?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and contrast the characters of Ralph and Jack. How do their characters affect their leadership styles? Ralph represents democracy. He rules with fairness and is not afraid to compromise. The boys on the island follow him through choice and not by force. Ralph plans for the future from the beginning and tries to replace the adults which are not present on the island, whereas Jack represents dictatorship. He rules by fear and violence. The boys on the island follow him because they are scared of the consequences if they do not. Jack's plans are superficial, he does not plan for a way to be rescued like Ralph does, and instead he organizes hunts and fun. The message Golding is trying to portray is that there is good and evil inside us all. The different leadership styles on the island represent the different ways in which the world outside the microcosm is run. Jack and his 'tribe' represent Hitler and the fascist regime that was around during the time when Golding wrote this book. Ralph and his 'tribe' represent the democracies opposing the fascists. Ralph is introduced to the reader on the first page as 'the boy with fair hair' and his physique is described as that of someone who 'might have made a boxer'. ...read more.

Middle

Although Jack does not lead all of the boys, he always maintains control of the choir who almost immediately transform into hunters. Jack is charismatic, attractive and manipulative. He is also irritable and quick to anger. When the first pig escapes he '[snatches] his knife out of its sheath and slam[s] it into a tree trunk'. Jack has no time for weakness and this includes the littluns and especially Piggy whom 'talk[s] too much'. Jack is frequently found saying 'shut up, Fatty'. Jack wants to make his own rules and is power hungry. His primitive desires and feelings mean that he feels at home in the jungle of the island. Due to his power hungry ways, toward the latter part of the novel, Jack decides to make his own 'tribe'. '[He] and [his] hunters [were] living along the beach by a flat rock. [They] hunt and feast and have fun.' Jack says 'if you want to join my tribe then come and see us'. He possesses no qualities such as deliberation and logic and rules his tribe purely by terror and aggression. This leadership style and his violent reactions soon result in the murder of Simon. One night, during a feast, following Jacks lead of 'do our dance, come on, dance' all the boys start chanting 'kill the beast, cut his throat, spill his blood, do him in'. ...read more.

Conclusion

It is later revealed that Jack wanted Piggy's glasses to make a fire at 'his tribes end of the island'. In the following chapter, castle rock, Ralph goes to visit Jack to 'see about the fire and Piggy's specs'. The confrontation ends with Jack refusing to back down or even compromise and this results in Piggy's death. At the end of the novel it is obvious that many of the boys have disregarded civilization, including Jack. They are all covered in clay and paint, so much so that the tribe becomes a 'pack of painted niggers'. This remark shows that it is no longer possible to distinguish whether the 'tribe' are a group of black or white boys. It is, however, very easy to distinguish Jack's tribe from Ralph's group. The face paints also show that the savagery is taking over and Jack is letting it. Jack has become obsessed with hunting and has no regard for matters such as being rescued. Although he stole Piggy's glasses, the fire he has created with them is no more than 'a cooking fire'. This shows that Jack has not the ability for long term commitment to any project. Jack has become callous and this has lead to two deaths and all but three boys regressing to savage behavior whereas Ralph has managed to hold on to the basic civilized behavior. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE William Golding section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE William Golding essays

  1. Lord of the Flies - Compare the leadership styles of Ralph and Jack. Was ...

    Ralph's leadership styles were based around the conch and the rules while Jack focused more on hunting and fun. Ralph is protective towards the littluns while Jack feels they are sissies and cry babies. Jack feels that because they can't hunt they are worthless.

  2. Themes, Motifs, and Symbols - Themes are the fundamental concepts addressed and explored in ...

    the boys manifests itself not as a competition to prove who would be the better leader but as a competition of sheer strength and courage. Just as Ralph went boldly into the dark caves alone to prove his bravery in the previous chapter, Jack goes up the mountain alone now.

  1. Compare and contrast the characters of Ralph and Jack. How does their characteristic dictate ...

    Follow me!''). Jack is also arrogant as he thinks highly of him self (p28 ''why should I be Jack I'm merridew''). This shows the name he wants to be called by the other boys, being his surname, seems at once to be a more superior and more formal name than that used by the other boys .

  2. Compare and contrast Act One and Act Two

    in public, at any rate, you had been more demonstrative" she said this because she knew that it would annoy her mother immensely. She also hates to be wrong and tries hard to prevent this from happening, making her seem sometimes overbearingly arrogant.

  1. Piggy's Specs

    Piggy not only knew what the rules were, as all the other boys did, but he also had the patience to at least wonder why the rules existed. This intuition made Piggy not only more aware of why the rules were imposed, thereby ensuring that he would abide by them even when they were not enforced.

  2. Welcome Home Sylvia

    "Wait, yes, wait.." replied Jack quickly. He was only half-listening to the driver and rapidly rushed inside the hospital. He had memorised the ward number from when he first came to see Sylvia and rushed straight to it walking extremely fast almost running.

  1. What do we learn in Chapters 1-5 about leadership? Look closely at Ralph, Piggy ...

    Piggy is very different to Ralph he is unattractive, fat and suffers from asthma. He is very rational but, his physical appearance and the manner in which he presents himself stop him from being a leader, "We don't want you" (page 26)

  2. Extracts from Piggy's Diary.

    So I asked his name but he was not very responsive when I was talking to him and he did not even ask for my name in return. Unlike me Ralph seemed to accept his new surroundings quite easily. I know that it will be hard for me on this

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work