• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast 'The Chrysanthemums' and 'The Odour of Chrysanthemums', paying close attention to the 2 main characters and say which story offers a better ending

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast 'The Chrysanthemums' and 'The Odour of Chrysanthemums', paying close attention to the 2 main characters and say which story offers a better ending Women in the 1900s were given little attention. John Steinbeck and D.H Lawrence however have chosen to base their short stories on a single woman character and around a type of flower, which is the chrysanthemum. Though written by male writers, both stories give an insight of the feelings and actions of a female character in that time period and how chrysanthemums can mean an entirely different obsession towards the two main characters. John Steinbeck's 'The Chrysanthemums' is about a tinker who confronts Elisa Allen while she was working on her prized chrysanthemums. Elisa was impressed of the tinker's freedom and his way of life. The tinker offers his service, repairing pots and pans, to Elisa, but she refuses at first. However, the tinker does not give up and tells Elisa about a customer that would be interested in her chrysanthemums. Elisa's attitude instantly changed and after her discussion with tinker she finds some work for the tinker to work on. ...read more.


Elisa 'raises' her chrysanthemums as though they were like her children. The flowers were her passion and pride and her flower garden was her prized possession that she was very proud of. However, she seems to want more from life than taking care of the garden, 'the chrysanthemums seem too small an easy for her energy.' This is further exposed when Elisa is awed by the tinker's freedom. In the other story, the chrysanthemums are described to be pink, wild, small and fragile. The flower reminds Elizabeth of the different episodes of her life with the husband. It is the symbol of their marriage but Elizabeth doesn't think the chrysanthemums are beautiful. This can be shown in her short laugh as she responds to her daughter's positive remark on the chrysanthemums. Just like her marriage. The chrysanthemums represent the love and bond between she and her husband that has long ceased. This can be felt with her description of chrysanthemum to Annie, her daughter, "... chrysanthemums when I married him, ... chrysanthemums when you were born, ... brought him home drunk ... brown chrysanthemums in his button-hole". ...read more.


In 'The Chrysanthemums', Elisa reveals her weaker side by 'crying weakly - like an old woman.' She has to settle for wine as it has become evident that she will always be trapped in her garden; the wine is as good as it gets for her. Elisa also learns through the hard way that trust should not be offered to strangers. However, in 'Odour of Chrysanthemums,' Elizabeth realises she has never really known Walter and is ashamed to handle him. She experiences fear for she is aware that she has no control over her destiny and that she cannot escape death. Both stories do not have a happy ending, but instead deal with different aspects of life. 'The Chrysanthemums' with society and trust, whereas 'Odour of Chrysanthemums' with fate and death. I feel that John Steinbeck offers a better ending because it teaches us not to trust strangers with ease and gives us the message that we should be happy with what we have, not to envy others. Then again, the ending in 'Odour of chrysanthemums' is also true but I feel that it is too harsh. It is a fact that every creature will encounter death but death should not be Elizabeth's or anyone's 'ultimate master.' Edwin 10K ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Jane Austen section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Jane Austen essays

  1. To compare the portrayal of marriage and representation of women the three texts that ...

    She was very narrow-minded and did what society expected of her. She felt that her decision for bringing a new wife into the family was justified, as that was what society expected her to do. She had fulfilled her role and the expectation that society had put upon her and

  2. Titanic- A Survivors Story

    Rushing back to my room I found the door already open and a mother and child were sitting at the table opposite one of the beds. "Hello dear, I suppose you're our roommate for the journey? This is my daughter Elizabeth and my name is Emily.

  1. Individual Female Rebellion in Madame Bovary and The Unbearable Lightness of Being.

    day, burst forth all the more savagely in her dreams, each of which ended in a wall he could silence only by waking her"5. Tereza rebels against this situation by cheating on Tomas, due to her lack of lightness involved in short sexual affairs, she eventually regrets her actions.

  2. Describe how D H Lawrence depicts the turning point in Elizabeth Bates' life. How ...

    He is often skulking in the shadows and is portrayed as evil with "an evil imagination". "He tore at the ragged wisps of chrysanthemums" shows that he has a destructive nature. He doesn't listen to his mother much and rarely does as he is told.

  1. Write a character sketch of anyone of your choice in ‘Pride and Prejudice’. This ...

    She called the Bingley sisters ' charming women '. She had not spoken with them yet this shows her to be judgmental. A most comical scene indeed must be chapter 5. At the Lucas Lodge Mrs Bennet exposes herself to be rather ridiculous. '" Oh! You mean Jane, I suppose because he danced with her twice.

  2. Discuss the treatment of marriage and class in The Son's Veto and The Odour ...

    Hardy compares the village of Gaymead, from where Sophy and her husband came from, with the house they move to in London, after they are married. Gaymead is described as being "pretty, with tress and shrubs and glebe" the description of Gaymead is very different to the description of the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work