• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast the different attitudes to war you have studied

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and Contrast the different attitudes to war you have found in the poems you have found in the Martin anthology. Megan Clary The three poems that I am going to compare and contrast are: "Who's for the Game?" by Jessie Pope, "Dulce et Decorum est," by Wilfred Owen and "God! How I hate you!" by Arthur Graeme West. The three poets use their writing to express their opinions of the war. Jessie Pope is a persuasive journalist who wrote war poems to help recruitment and to sustain the war effort. "Who's for the Game?" tries to convince young men through propaganda that they should go to war. She portrays the war as a game, which will be fun for the men who join up and will make them heroes: whereas the men who do not join will be perceived as people who are spoiling the fun. She persuades the men to fight in 'the game' by using manipulation, which would then make them feel guilty if they did not go to war. "Dulce et Decorum est" is a poem in response to Jessie Pope's attitude to war, which aims to prove to her that war is not a game and that watching a fellow soldier die is not enjoyable. Wilfred Owen describes how he saw a man being choked to death by poisonous gas and how the war changed the soldiers. ...read more.

Middle

Instead Arthur Graeme West describes the men as slowly dying humans and he also describes the dead soldiers lying in the trenches. He describes the men as being bored of the war, as they only sit around waiting to be attacked by the enemy. He says in the third stanza, "Proved that all muddy brown monotony," which shows us the tedium of war. Arthur Graeme West describes in vivid detail how he saw a man being shot, and he describes how he saw the man slowly dying, which makes you sympathise with him and the other soldiers because who saw such horrific events. In "Dulce et Decorum Est," Owen describes the men as tired, unenthusiastic and dirty, and he gives more detail than the two other poets. On the first line of the first stanza, he describes the men with similes as, 'Bent double, like old beggars,' which shows us that the men look unwell and older then they are due to the effect the war has had on them. On the second line, he says that the men were, 'Knock-kneed, coughing like hags, we cursed through sludge,' which shows us that they had developed an abnormality in the knees, causing them to walk differently, that they were finding it harder to breathe because they were coughing like old women, and that they were cursing as they walked through mud, which shows their lack of enthusiasm. ...read more.

Conclusion

In, 'God! How I hate you,' has a loud, quite slow clapping rhythm, which seems to get louder as his anger increases. This helps the reader to see Arthur Graeme West's anger and how it helps them to feel what he is thinking. In, 'Who's for the Game?' the rhythm is approximately the same speed as, 'God! How I hate you,' because they are both loud, although Jessie Pope was probably trying to make the rhythm sound enthusiastic rather then angry. This shows us that although the two poems are making different points, they both use the same rhythm for different purposes, unlike Dulce et Decorum Est, which has a slower beat which gradually gets faster. In conclusion, the poem which I least prefer is, 'Who's for the Game'. The reason for this is because the poem uses manipulation and propaganda to try and force men to go to war. It is not as gruesome and as graphic as the other two poems, and it does not describe horrific deaths in it; instead it portrays the war as a game and as something which will enable you to be seen as a hero and bring you glory if you die for your country. It glosses over the harsh realities of war and dishonestly lures young men towards a possible grim death. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Writing to Inform, Explain and Describe section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Writing to Inform, Explain and Describe essays

  1. Wilfred Owen aimed to convey the pity of war in his poetry. How ...

    By making the reader share his helplessness, Owen has the effect of making the reader more helpless for what they went through As well as imagery, Owen uses sounds as well. In the first paragraph he describes that the gas-shells dropping 'softly' behind.

  2. "Gateway to heaven"

    Mamma went into loud bawls of agony and shed tears of love for her lost daughter. As for Baba, he kept a stiff upper lip and put on his typical Chinese father exterior, continuing to read his paper; according to him, he only had one daughter.

  1. Changing attitudes to marriage- compare three stories, Tony Kytes, Three Sisters and Teresa's wedding

    You hardly ever marry for love. On the contrary are both of Mary's younger sisters, who both have their sights set on marrying for love, respect and happiness. However, when Mr.Watts says: 'you might want to forget about those things when trying to find a husband, or else you most

  2. My Heroes.

    My mother became my heroine, and I hope she knows it now. From now on it was only going be me, my brother and my dad. My dad now had the role of two parents, and I would constantly be worried that it would become too much for him, and I still do.

  1. "Revenge is sweet!"

    The 24 hours ran away. I didn't dig Minnie up. I'll never do it. I hate her and I won't do anything that she want's me to do. 12 hours later I had changed my mind. I can hardly think about what happened. But I'll try to tell.

  2. With close reference to the short-stories you have studied, compare the ways in which ...

    the main character in the exposition; however he does this through the use of the narrator. The level of tension in this short story is extensively high as it begins theatrically right from the very first sentence 'True!-nervous very, very dreadfully nervous', this quote demonstrates the panic in the narrator,

  1. Try ... Or Die

    I drank water from the sinks situated in toilets. The feeling of hunger and the passion for money has never left my body and mind; it has stayed there ever since I had become orphaned. As a young boy, I can remember my father once taking me to this building and telling me about it.

  2. Explore varieties and attitudes to texting.

    ?There?s a waterproof jacket on Field and Trek down from 90 to 9 pounds?.Would you or Georgia be a 12 -14?xx?. However, my sample is relatively small, so it might not represent what actually happens. This could be related to the younger generation trying to rebel against parents and a

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work