• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the different cultures, which are shown in the short stories 'The Gold Cadillac' and 'A Stench Of Kerosene' by the authors Mildred Taylor and Amrita Pritam.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

09/05/2007 Compare and contrast the different cultures, which are shown in the short stories 'The Gold Cadillac' and 'A Stench Of Kerosene' by the authors Mildred Taylor and Amrita Pritam. In the short stories 'A Stench Of Kerosene' by Amrita Pritam and 'The Gold Cadillac' by Mildred Taylor both authors follow the conventions of a short story to create an impact on the reader. In 'The Gold Cadillac' Taylor creates a large impact on the reader by showing how the young girl Lois is confused by racism and slowly develops a fear of it. This helps the reader to clearly see how racism affects families and cultures. 'A Stench Of Kerosene' is very similar. Pritam creates an impact by portraying prejudice, not against race but against sex. She portrays this prejudice by showing the reader how women are treated badly in an Indian society and how men are valued more in society. By focusing on these topics both authors give us their views on racism and female powerlessness. 'A Stench Of Kerosene' is about a mother who lives in India in a matriarchal society and is concerned about the betterment of her son called Manak. Manak's mother wants him to have a son, as she wants the family name to carry on. After seven years of no children with his current wife Guleri, Manak's mother buys him another bride while Guleri is away, in the hope that she will be able to give Guleri a son. ...read more.

Middle

We see this denial of her volition again when Pritam writes: 'Guleri was allowed'. Both of these lines are phrased in a passive voice, which creates an emphasis on Guleri's objectification. This is also evident during the conversation between Guleri and Manak: 'but he did not reply' and 'Manak did not ask again'. From the repetition of 'not' in both of these quotes the reader gets the impression that Manak is neglecting his wife Guleri. Although Guleri represents women from the culture portrayed in this story Manak's mother has more power than Guleri as she is a matriarchal figure and they live in a matriarchal society where all children must listen to their parents: 'Obedient to his mother' However, we could also get the impression that Manak's mother has simply internalised the cultural misogyny. We get this impression from when she says; ' Why do you croak like an old woman...be a man'. 'The Gold Cadillac' can be seen as quite similar to 'A Stench Of Kerosene; where the mother appears powerful as Dee has the power to stand up to her husband. This is portrayed after Wilbert has just brought the new car and Dee says: 'That Mercury wasn't even a year old'. And when she refuses to ride in the car: ' ...mother refused to ride anywhere'. From Dee's character we get the impression that she has power not only as a mother but also as a woman. ...read more.

Conclusion

We also see that mothers have the freedom to challenge the decisions of their husbands and are respected just like all the men. The ways in which the two stories are set are similar. ' A Stench Of Kerosene' is set in India; we get the impression that people get on well in this society. However, as the story progresses we realise the disadvantages faced by women. We are similarly misled in ' The Gold Cadillac' in fact it is not immediately that the family in the story is black until we get further into the story. At first we think that black people are equals in society until the family travels into the south and receives much discrimination. In both of the stories 'The Gold Cadillac' and 'A Stench Of Kerosene', the authors Mildred Taylor and Amrita Pritam attempt to convey the harsh realities of their respective culture. In Pritam's story women are not always treated as equals and in this case they are not respected unless they are married or are mothers. In Taylor's story she is attempting to show us that in America black people have not always been treated as equals. In each case the authors appear to be pitiful of the ways in which women and black people are belittled in society. We as the readers are shown this through the strong imagery, brevity of structure and the narrative impact. Both authors give us meaning and the reader is left with a wider knowledge of how culture informs the way in which people are treated depending on race and gender. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Mildred Taylor section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Mildred Taylor essays

  1. Individualism as a Malaise of Modernity.

    (pg 2) In other words, we are free. However, many people, according to Taylor, still think that the process of individualism is incomplete. "There is still economic arrangements, or patterns of family life, or traditional notions of hierarchy still restrict too much our freedom to be ourselves."(pg 2)

  2. Mildred D. Taylor is very successful in conveying the reality of what it was ...

    families, because Mr Granger who backs the Wallace store put the family's tax rate up. "It's-it's that list I come 'bout, David...I don't want them things no more." Also they are threatened by the Wallace's, that if they make any trouble, they will be beaten up and possibly even be hung.

  1. How does Mildred D Taylor show the ways in which black people could deal ...

    By trying to avert them into accepting dirty old books, as well as making they believe that they should be happy and thankful that they have received "wonderful books", and shouldn't care that the condition of the books are actually 'very poor.'

  2. What aspects of racism are presented by Mildred Taylor in the book 'Roll of ...

    Lillian demands an apology for "bumping into decent white folks with your nasty little self." Cassie refuses to get in the road until Mr. Sims, Lillian's father, grabs and pushes her into the road. He demands that she apologises properly.

  1. How does Mildred Taylor effectively portray prejudice during the 1930's Mississippi in her novel, ...

    Mildred is conveying the fact that the police wouldn't bring about justice, as they would be sharing the same views as the majority of the whites who were the ones who had the upper hand. The law being present at the time yet only aiding the white race is seen as being rather ironical as justice wasn't apparent.

  2. Show how Don Taylor uses historical material about the political situation, the plague, and ...

    It is not a history book. This play opens when Mompesson and his family arrive in Eyam. Mompesson is the new Rector of Eyam. The first impressions the audience have of his personality is that he is arrogant and pompous.

  1. In the nineteenth Century, in the United States of America, there was a distinctive ...

    At first, the North was fighting for the reunification of the two sides to form a great USA again, but the South was fighting for its independence. However, when President Lincoln issued the emancipation proclamation, the motive changed. The South fought against the abolition of slavery and the North fought for its abolition.

  2. A Sound of Thunder is from the science fiction, short story genre written after ...

    There was a sound of thunder. The Body Snatcher is an early 19th century short story told in the first person. The Body Snatcher is based on realism with a super natural element to it. The Body Snatcher opens with the narrator creating and atmosphere.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work