• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast the Images of London Presented in Wordsworth's 'Composed Upon Westminster Bridge' and Ian McMillan's 'Wordsworth's Return to Westminster Bridge.'

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and Contrast the Images of London Presented in Wordsworth's 'Composed Upon Westminster Bridge' and Ian McMillan's 'Wordsworth's Return to Westminster Bridge.' 'Composed Upon Westminster Bridge' was a poem written by the famous poet, William Wordsworth in 1802. Poets traditionally studied pastoral images because cities had not evolved into the important place which they have now. Wordsworth realized that more people where beginning to live in cities and that they were becoming more important and more significant in peoples' lives. Ian McMillan created a 21st Century version of Wordsworth's poem, which shows how much places can dramatically change over a period of time. I shall compare and contrast the way in which each poet uses their language to convey their different images of past and present day London. William Wordsworth was born and raised in the Lake District, in England. He had a great appreciation for nature, which is apparent in many of his poems. He also had strong beliefs in pantheism. He was a crucial figure in the English Romantic Movement. He wrote the poem 'Composed Upon Westminster Bridge' in the early hours of the morning on the third of September 1802. He composed it as he travelled across Westminster Bridge in a carriage and looked over London city, while most people were still sleeping in bed and when London was at its most dormant. ...read more.

Middle

Wordsworth's poem builds a clear message, which is enforced in many linguistic techniques and styles. He uses several examples of personification to share his message. He makes an extremely clear message that London is at its most beautiful during sunrise, and possibly the most beautiful sight ever. Commissioned by the Globe Theatre in the year 2002, Ian McMillan wrote the poem titled 'Wordsworth's Return To Westminster Bridge'. It strikes me immediately how very different both poems are. This is most definitely because of the effect 200 years has had on London. In the space of two centuries an industrial revolution has occurred making the city of London larger, with more people and more buildings. In fact, land which used to be fields is now covered with buildings and roads, in contrast to Wordsworth's time. The message of McMillan's poem is that London is an awful dirty place and that he is reluctant to live there. As McMillan is working off Wordsworth's poem, it seems that he is arguing and trying to prove a point to Wordsworth, that his image of London is wrong. McMillan's poem is structured around a Shakespearean sonnet. The rhyme scheme, which he has achieved, is not exactly a Shakespearean sonnet, but very similar to one. ...read more.

Conclusion

This confusion makes the audience unsure, which gives the impression of London being a mess. The final line of the poem shows how much McMillan loathes London. He says how he is happy that he lives in the 'civilised' north, referring to the north of England. This would imply to the audience that London, the south, is not civilised, but savage and dirty. I have compared and contrasted the differences in poetic style and imagery in both poems. Wordsworth's poem brings out the full potential beauty in London, whereas McMillan's poem shows the modern day reality of dirt and pollution, which is now found in most cities. London would have dramatically evolved from what it was 200 years ago because of advances in technology, meaning people depend on machines more than manual labour. This would draw people from the countryside into the city and the city would therefore get larger with more and more buildings. Personally I prefer McMillan's version of Wordsworth's 'Composed Upon Westminster Bridge '. 'Wordsworth's Return To Westminster Bridge' is more realistic and a clearer picture of what a city is, for me. This is probably because I could not depict a city as being beautiful. Andrew Gregg English Coursework 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE William Wordsworth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE William Wordsworth essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    William Wordsworth, known as one of the first generation of romantic poets lived from ...

    4 star(s)

    The hyperbole 'ten thousand' is developed further when he follows it with 'saw I at a glance', suggesting that with one quick glance he manages to see ten thousand daffodils. Originally the use of the hyperbole 'ten thousand' was repeated at the beginning of the third stanza- 'Ten thousand dancing

  2. Peer reviewed

    Discuss the way in which Wordsworth and Heaney present nature and rural life in ...

    4 star(s)

    helps the reader to create images of the daffodils, movement in the wind. Wordsworth uses personification a second time to create imagery in the second verse, where he describes the daffodils as, "Tossing their heads in sprightly dance." This use of pathetic fallacy to produce imagery and use of the

  1. In " The Daffodils" and " Upon Westminster Bridge" the poet shows appreciation of ...

    This is hyperbole, as Wordsworth has not seen the whole world so he can't say there is no better sight in the world than London. It is a strong comment and shows that the beauty of the scene strikes the poet.

  2. Compare 'Lake Isle of Innisfree' by WB Yeats with 'Composed upon Westminster Bridge' by ...

    This is Yeats' land. He is imagining this place and everything he will have there. Yeats wants 'a hive for the honeybee.' I think it's fairly relaxing when you hear a bee buzz. And I think that this is another sign of Yeats' idea of peace.

  1. Compare and contrast how Lord Byron's She Walks in Beauty and William Wordsworth's She ...

    in the dark perhaps she has horrible looks or he only sees her in the dark such as a prostitute. The idea of prostitution is continued in line 8, "nameless" and the idea that she is better in the dark is furthered in line 7.

  2. What are the poet's feelings about the city and how does he convey those ...

    reinforce his feelings of wealth, power, and beauty within London which at this stage of the poem is most obvious. In the octet the tone is very descriptive of the man made sights in London "Ships, towers, domes, theatres, and temples lie. All bright and glittering in the smokeless air."

  1. The extract from "The Prelude" is written mainly in the first person singular and ...

    Onomatopoeia is also used by Wordsworth in "The Prelude." Words such as "hissed" and "tinkled" are effective in this poem, as they resemble the sounds actually made. The sonnet "Composed upon Westminster Bridge" is all written in a mood of happiness and pleasure, the same mood that the extract from "The Prelude" begins with, whilst describing the "time of rapture!"

  2. 'Write a Comparison of 'Composed Upon Westminster Bridge' by William Wordsworth and 'London' by ...

    This is shown by 'curse' the use of no positive observations. His use of repetition 'misery' also conveys his dislike for London. Blake is talking about the people, the way their lives are being destroyed by the city 'every cry...every man'.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work