• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast the Poetry of James Berry and John Betjeman, with particular reference to the Cultural Differences. Refer to at Least two Poems by each Poet

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare and Contrast the Poetry of James Berry and John Betjeman, with particular reference to the Cultural Differences. Refer to at Least two Poems by each Poet James Berry's poems are written from the perspective of a lady named Lucy. Lucy moved to England because she had heard the streets were practically paved with gold there. She writes letters to her friend Leela in the form of poems. Lucy regrets her move to England in a lot of ways and finds it gloomy and cold. She misses Jamaica and doesn't really like London but she is too proud to admit that, so her letters also contain a number of positive yet vain sounding points about the advantages of living in England, such as, "An' doctors free." Lucy writes of how she has, "turned a battery hen," in the poem 'Lucy's Letters' because she feels trapped in London. She was used to a relaxed and friendly way of life in Jamaica so the culture in London came as a big shock to her. London is a lot bigger and much less friendly than Jamaica. In Jamaica everyone knows each other so Leela asked Lucy in a letter to her if she'd ever met the Queen. Lucy is used to the unspoilt beauty of the Jamaican scenery so London comes as a big change. ...read more.

Middle

Betjeman's poems are named after counties and describe the country lifestyle he was used to when he was younger. His county poems are written in two contrasting sections. In the poem 'Hertfordshire' Betjeman writes of how he was made to join his father's shooting syndicate. His father thought he was a milksop after he accidentally fired a gun into the ground, saying: "How many times must I explain? The way a boy should hold a gun?" In the second half of the poem, Betjeman writes of how that large, open countryside has been replaced with rows of identical and box-like houses. He writes of how the old flint churches and thatched cottages look, "strange and ill." He sums this up by writing, "One can't be sure where London ends," this relates to an earlier line in the poem, naming villages that used to be miles away from London which are now part of it. It caused his father great pain to see his son couldn't shoot, which contrasts greatly with the happy relationship between Leela and Lucy in Berry's poetry. Betjeman ends the poem with the words: "Far more would these have caused him pain Than my mishandling of a gun." This mean even though he was upset that his son couldn't shoot, it would have broken his heart to see the Hertfordshire countryside had been urbanised. ...read more.

Conclusion

The scenery described by the two poets is very different. Berry's account of Jamaica describes it as being very sunny and peaceful. The structure of the poetry written by both poets is very different. Betjeman uses very regular four lined stanzas, each with a regular rhyming pattern, which reflects his routine and uniform lifestyle. The way Berry's stanzas are irregular with no real rhyme reflect the easygoing lifestyle in Jamaica. Betjeman writes his poems in Standard English with no colloquial phrases, reflecting his uniform and very English lifestyle further. He uses archaic language, reflecting in some ways the way he dislikes change and also the way he is quite traditional. Berry, however, uses Creole phrases and grammar in his poetry. In the poem 'Lucy's Letter,' Berry uses the phrase, " I long for we labrish bad," meaning Lucy longs to gossip without restraint. Berry uses figures of speech in his poetry unlike Betjeman. For instance, in the poem 'Lucy's Letter', Berry uses the metaphor, "I really a sponge" and in 'From Lucy: Englan' Lady,' he uses similes such as, " Like a seagull flyin' slow slow." Berry and Betjeman have very different writing styles, partly because of the influences of their very different cultures. Berry's easy going Jamaican upbringing is reflected in his poetry through his use of Creole and the structure of his poetry. Betjeman reflects his English upbringing through his regular, ordered stanzas. Although they are very different they both work very well and make for very enjoyable reading. Jessica Scott 10X ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE John Betjeman section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE John Betjeman essays

  1. With close reference to two poems you've studied, show how specific places provide Betjeman ...

    One can almost feel Betjeman's anger because Slough has changed into such a depressing town. He makes the point that it should be bombed because it is so awful. In the fourth and fifth verses Betjeman talks about how much he hates capitalists, how they always cheat and win.

  2. How does Betjeman convey his attitude towards Slough?

    and make use of the land, rather than wasting it like it is being misused now. He claims the people are false and materialistic as they do not know the 'birdsong from the radio' and 'daren't look up and see the stars' because birdsong and stars are two of the

  1. Compare and Contrast the Ways in Which the Two Poets Present Their Memories

    By concentrating on these negative memories, he gives a harsh tone to these few verses. The poet also qualifies all these memories. It seems as though he has dreamt about how he could have done things, for instance, he talks of the "blinding theologies" he "did not invent" and the "splendid family" that he "never" had.

  2. Betjemans poetry reveals an unfilled longing for youth. Do you agree?

    season, which may also in fact be symbolic of the narrator's life: he nears the winter of his life. Moreover, the phrase elegantly forces the reader to confront the apparent inability of the poet to come to terms with an appropriate simile, hence greatly exaggerating this terrible coldness of age.

  1. Could The Suicide be The Executive after a life of failure?

    That messed up his life and obviously could not go on living anymore. So that brings me to 'The Suicide'. He is now a broken man. He is in major dept and is just deeply depressed about his life. 'There are the bills in the intray, the ash in the

  2. Poems by John Betjeman

    This poem is very ambiguous because on the surface it seems very innocent but underneath the surface, there is a strange double meaning to it. The poem 'Devonshire Street' tells a very different story of an old couple visiting a doctor and having the realisation that death is close by.

  1. We have been giving to 20th century poems to examine. They are "Evans" by ...

    He says that it isn't the darkness around him, which seems to fill his mouth and that it isn't the tree that the rain drips off. I think the tree is symbolism, because the speaker says, "of rain like blood form that one tree, weather tortured."

  2. Compare and contrast 'Slough' and 'Belfast Confetti' - Comment on the poetic devices used ...

    A meaning that could be taken from this is that sentences are one of a few things that differ us from animals. The fact that he was "trying to complete a sentence in his head" speaks volumes about his state of mind at the time.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work