• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the presentation of Charles Kingshaw and Edmund Hooper in I'm the King of the Castle with Gregory and the narrator in The Half Brothers.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

I'm the King of the Castle - Susan Hill The Half Brothers - Elizabeth Gaskell Compare and contrast the presentation of Charles Kingshaw and Edmund Hooper in I'm the King of the Castle with Gregory and the narrator in The Half Brothers. Examine their respective relationships, comment on the behaviour of the adults and explain how it affects the boys and helps influence the outcome of each text. I'm the King of the Castle is a fairly recent novel compared The Half Brothers, a pre 20th century text. The two texts deal with the issues that arise from family relationships. However, I'm the King of the Castle portrays bullying within a family relationship and The Half Brothers portrays jealousy in a family relationship. In I'm the King of the Castle Edmund Hooper, the son of Joseph Hooper who is the owner of Warings shows many similarities with the narrator in The Half Brothers. Both boys are the sons of successful, dominant men who are the heads and owners of their houses. ...read more.

Middle

Mr Hooper however does not display and regret or realisation of his part in the death of Kingshaw, he is oblivious to his part in the suicide. William had taught his son to be mean towards Gregory, and this is reflected in William's actions - the mistreatment of Gregory's dog and of his Gregory was often blamed on others. In the same way, Joseph Hooper tries to shift the blame of him being responsible for his son's lack of love onto others, like his first wife and compares Edmund to her 'he has the same way of not bothering to explain and of making secrets.' Mr Hooper confirms his son is not warm and affectionate. Helena Kingshaw's role helps explain why her son is insecure and unhappy. She is very unaware of how Kingshaw is being treated so Kingshaw withdraws into his isolation, how he 'copes alone' as he has nobody to console him. Despite the events in the novel, she does not have the insight to see her own child's problems and only sees ways of solving her own. ...read more.

Conclusion

She ignores Gregory and is insulting of him 'Stupid, Aunt Fanny used to call it.' Yet Gregory shows no resentment 'and would try to do a kind turn for anyone' his mistreatment by all the people close to his mother and he still gives his life to his half brother because of the love of his dead mother. Gregory speaks to his brother as he comforts him in the snow 'I reckon she sees us now, and belike we shall soon be with her.' However it is too late for his half brother or step father to know why he gives his life. For both boys who lose their lives, they have stirred feelings with their deaths. Kingshaw's death makes the adults seem very self absorbed and keen to comfort the persecutor who shows no remorse, like the adults, even Kingshaw's own mother. Gregory's death provokes remorse and guilt in his stepfather and half brother. Kingshaw's death was because he lacked love, his mother was shallow and blind to her sons feelings. Gregory's death was because his mother loved him so dearly, he showed compassion for his half brother, and was compelled to give his life. Wider Reading Assignment Sophie Turner 11SG 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Susan Hill section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Susan Hill essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    "I'm the King of the Castle" - with close references to the text discuss ...

    3 star(s)

    At first we read about Hooper. We read about his family history, and about Warings, a house which is part of the Hooper family history. Hooper didn't think much of the house physically. "It was an ordinary house, he thought".

  2. The King of the Castle Character Assessment Joseph Hooper.

    Joseph also knew that his son would never make a name of himself or something big. I think that Joseph Hooper was a fairly good single parent; he tried his best to teach his son the right and wrong things.

  1. I'm the King of the Castle by Susan Hill. - Throughout the novel, what ...

    But instead he tries to help Hooper to get down, he had already peed his pants in fright, he was a blubbering mess. But as Kingshaw put his arm out Hooper fell to the ground. He could have been killed.

  2. Can Hooper be seen as anything other than Evil? A comparative Essay on 'I'm ...

    Defensively Kingshaw replies by saying 'Well, I know that, everyone knows that.' This line of questioning carries on until it gets to the moment when Kingshaw doesn't answer one of Hopper's questions straight away, this makes Hooper angry an example of this is found on pg 20, line 18 - 22.

  1. I'm the King of the Castle

    At that time, the young boy was oblivious towards Hooper's tormenting words. Yet, his reaction said a lot about his inner being. Kingshaw upon knowing of the past of his new bedroom only "went to the suitcase and squatted down".

  2. Consider the theme of loneliness in the novel "I am the king of the ...

    Joseph Hooper is a portrait of failure. His lack of action towards his son and Miss Kingshaw shows he is a very reserved guy, but actually this is not the way he wanted to be. His fears of being rejected and abandoned control him even though on the inside he wants to take action. He lacks confidence.

  1. How do the experiences, feelings and thoughts of Helena Kingshaw contribute to events in ...

    Also, she places much importance on family security, as she repeatedly mentions the "four of them" being like one family, and obviously wishing this to be true. This need for companionship, social life and family security makes her desperate to succeed in her life with the Hoopers.

  2. I'm the King of the Castle" - In her after word, the writer talks ...

    Yet, one must take into consideration that it is the environment and external influences that led him to be evil. Hooper is born into a dysfunctional family. His mother died when he was very young, and that deprived him of mother-love, which is often thought to be very important and influential during a child's growing phase.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work