• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the roles of the Nurse and Friar Lawrence in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

English - Shakespeare Coursework Essay Compare and contrast the roles of the Nurse and Friar Lawrence in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet in the following ways: * Consider their contribution to the plot * Select short sections from the play involving these two characters for close study, showing appreciation of dramatic structure and stagecraft * Analyse what they tell us about Elizabethan society This essay will focus on the Nurse and Friar Lawrence, and how their actions and opinions affected Romeo and Juliet. From the outset of the play the prologue dooms them both by stating their "death-marked love". This makes the part of the Friar and the Nurse in their deaths unclear, as we do not know whether the "star-crossed lovers" would have died without them intervening on their behalf since it was written in the stars. As well as this, it also describes that the consequences of their actions "bury their parents' strife" giving a twist to the plot which, if the observer was removed from the emotional aspects of the play, could find balanced out the tragedy with a 'greater good'. Romeo and Juliet are the children of two wealthy families in Verona, the Montagues and the Capulets. Friar Lawrence and the Nurse are both lower down the social scale than Romeo and Juliet but act as confidants and close friends to them both, the Friar being a spiritual adviser as well. Romeo and Juliet depend on them both and treat them as extended family. In this way they value their advice and have very strong bonds between them. Although the guidance given by both the Nurse and Friar is valued equally, the actual opinion of each character may differ greatly. The Nurse is an out-going character who has wet-nursed and cared for Juliet since she was a baby and, due to the detached supervision of her own mother, Juliet is more likely to turn to the Nurse for advice and guidance. ...read more.

Middle

Due to the complexity of the Friar's plan, there is no 'backup' scheme that can be used in the event of a failure. In order for it to work, each 'link' in the plan must work flawlessly - which it does until only a seemingly small detail - the delivery of a letter to Romeo explaining what has been done - it unaccomplished due to a plague to the city. This throws all of the subsequent events into disarray and the Friar panics. His an example of his contradictory beliefs are shown when he is hurrying towards the vault where Juliet is lying, in order to warn Romeo that she is not actually dead. "Saint Francis be my speed. How oft tonight Have my old feet stumbled at graves." In his haste to get to the vault, he trips and stumbles - reminding us of what he said at the start of the play - "They stumble that run fast". His calm attitude towards the situation has not prevailed and he has wasted time. As well as this, the Friar ends by blaming the stars for the tradegy that occurred. When the Friar attempts to convince Juliet to leave the vault as he has heard a voice, he blames the problem not on his (or anyone else's) actions, but on a higher power. 'A greater power than we can contradict Has thwarted our intents.' When confronted with the Prince and other characters at the end, he admits involvement even though he feared being punished. The Friar explains the sequence of events that led to the tragedy and, in telling the truth, discloses the Nurse's involvement. He is believed because of his status as a 'holy man' and offers his life as a penance for his fault. This is interesting and shows part of the Friar's character not seen before. He may have offered his life honestly, and accepted that he would have to pay with his life. ...read more.

Conclusion

I think that the role of the Nurse and Friar in the tragedy is small, but the compound effect of many characters mistakes caused the deaths of the two lovers. For example Romeo and Juliet both took decisions which led to their deaths, but this is only part of the story. They behaved as they did because of the situation they found themselves in and because of the way in which people treated them. There is almost none in the play who does not bear some responsibility for their deaths - even the Prince could be accused; if he had been more forceful with his actions against the feuding families, the fight between Mercutio and Tybalt would not have happened. Romeo would not have killed Tybalt and therefore not been punished, bypassing the need for Friar Lawrence's complicated plan and avoiding the tragedy. The role of fate in the play is something that could be discussed in great detail. Was it just coincidence that Capulet should send out the invitations to the feast using a messenger who could not read, just at the moment when he will meet Romeo and so ask him to read the list for him. Also, it is strange that at a crowded party, where there are many attractive young girls, Romeo should see Juliet. There is only one point in the entire play where a character is mildly more to blame than any other - the Friar leaves Juliet by herself in the tomb, with Romeo and Paris both dead nearby. This is when she takes her own life, if the Friar had stayed longer, or forced her to come with him, she may have lived. Although this is akin to saying if Romeo had not drunk the poison, he would not have died, so my argument is flawed. I think that the Nurse and Friar are to blame, but just as much as other characters who interacted with Romeo and Juliet. If any one thing is to be blamed - it is the stars. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Romeo and Juliet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Romeo and Juliet essays

  1. Discuss the characters attitudes towards love and arranged marriages in 'Romeo and Juliet' focus ...

    father has spoke, she sees no way out of this arranged marriage she lowers to her knees while begging for him to listen to her. Lord Capulet will then give Juliet a filthy look to say what are you doing, he then insults her "disobedient wretch" he then repeats that

  2. Free essay

    Examine closely, referring to the text whenever necessary, the character of Friar Lawrence in ...

    The fight was unnecessary and was simply for very improper causes. Tybalt had come for Romeo, but ended up killing Mercutio. Romeo is also much to blame. It is his impulsive behaviour that causes the main problems. There was no need for Romeo to be so careless to kill Tybalt.

  1. How does Shakespeare present the relationship between Juliet and the Nurse, Romeo and the ...

    The nurse has a number of pet names for Juliet including "Lamb" and "Ladybird" this is a sign of their close relationship and is picked up upon by the audience. Shakespeare hints to the audience that the nurse has mothering instincts over Juliet by using the line "And I might

  2. Writing about the story of Romeo and Juliet, in a prologue then the relationship ...

    the couple would still have gone ahead with their condemned marriage once they had fallen in love. The Friar, Romeo's friend and assistant of Juliet in her final plan, changed the course of events by helping the young couple in their plans to marry and assisting Juliet in her scheme to be with Romeo once again.

  1. How do Juliet's Nurse and Friar Lawrence contribute to the tragedy of the play?

    The Friar is now deeply involved with the tragedy, and when Juliet comes to visit him he comes up with another plan, which is even more risky than the first two. At this stage, some of the audience may wonder whether the Friar may be thinking of saving himself, not just Juliet.

  2. Romeo and Juliet - What different types of love are represented in the play, ...

    a constellation forever because life is too short a time for her to enjoy him, she wants to enjoy him for ever. By introducing the idea of her death this implies how short her time with him is. The metaphor "mansion of a love" in line 26 stands for their bodies.

  1. To what extent do you consider Friar Laurence to be responsible for the tragedy ...

    In a more secular society, we could view arranged marriages as highly unfair and that women should have the right to choose their husband and true love is principal. In this instance it could be thought that her parents put too much emphasis on the arranged marriage.

  2. How far do you think Friar Lawrence is to Blame for the Tragic Events ...

    Another major reason why Friar Lawrence is to blame for the death of Juliet at the end of the play is that at the critical point when Juliet wakes up from her deep sleep to find that her beloved husband is lying next to her dead, Friar Lawrence abandons her as he is to concerned with his own well being.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work