• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and Contrast the Short Stories "Turned", "To Please his Wife" and "An Alpine Divorce". Comment on the Narrative Structure, Key Themes, the Role of Women and the Endings

Extracts from this document...


Compare and Contrast the Short Stories "Turned", "To Please his Wife" and "An Alpine Divorce". Comment on the Narrative Structure, Key Themes, the Role of Women and the Endings In this essay I will be examining the three short stories "Turned", "To Please his Wife" and "An Alpine Divorce". I will analyse key themes in the stories, such as women's independence, and wealth. I will also compare and contrast some of the characters. The plot of "Turned" is centred on Mrs Marroner, a woman who is betrayed by her husband when he gets their servant, Gerta, pregnant. Mrs Marroner chooses to take herself and Gerta, away from Mr Marroner, and survive on her own. "To Please his Wife" is about Joanna, who wants to improve her social standing and become rich. Her ambitions eventually get her husband and sons killed. "An Alpine Divorce" is about an unhappy marriage between Mr and Mrs Bodman, driving Mr Bodman to murder his wife. However, Mrs Bodman commits suicide, framing Mr Bodman for a murder he didn't have the chance to commit. The three short stories open in very different ways. "Turned" opens by going straight into the plot, saying: "Mrs Marroner lay sobbing". ...read more.


Another theme addressed in all three stories is reputations. In "To Please his Wife" Joanna wants to improve her social standing and reputation by becoming rich. To her, reputation is important, since she is willing to risk her children and her husband for one. In "Turned" reputation affects the story in a different way. Mr Marroner's reputation prevents him from casting out Joanna, as she could go to the newspapers. He, like Joanna considers reputation important. Similarly, in "An Alpine Divorce", Mr Bodman cannot leave Mrs Bodman, as his reputation would be ruined, the text tells us "If he had been a poor man he would probably have deserted her". In this story, as well in "To Please his Wife", reputation limits the options of a character. Lack of communication is another theme that runs through the three stories. In "Turned" Gerta will not tell Mrs Marroner what is wrong with her, "She would admit nothing, explain nothing" tell us this. The lack of communication is a negative influence, since when Mrs Marroner discovers Gerta is carrying Mr Marroner's child, she is at first angry ("She had no shadow of pity"). In "To Please his Wife", the lack of communication is between Shadrach and Joanna. ...read more.


"To Please his Wife" was completely acceptable, as sexism was commonplace when it was written. If it had be published today however, it would be completely unacceptable, as moral values have changed. "Turned" was quite groundbreaking for when it was written, it illustrated feminism, which was at the time considered outlandish, even by most women. Today however, the moral of women's independence is wholly normal. "An Alpine Divorce" is "To Please his Wife" was written in 1891, by Thomas Hardy. It reflects his traditional views of women, and was completely acceptable for the time. The moral is centred on Thomas Hardy's views of women, that they should be obedient, unquestioning and feminine, basically like Emily. "Turned" was written in 1911 by Charlotte Perkins Gilman, who supported women getting the vote and being independent, poles apart from Thomas Hardy. It was quite an unconventional story, for the time it was written. I think the moral of this story is that women can and should be both independent and educated, as Mrs Marroner's actions illustrate. I think the moral of "An Alpine Divorce" is centred on the authors views of marriage that it is basically a compromise and nothing more. In conclusion, the three stories are all very different, each one encompasses a different set of views and issues, but they all address these problems very effectively. ?? ?? ?? ?? 1 Chris Turner ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Geoffrey Chaucer section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Geoffrey Chaucer essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    I am going to compare and contrast two stories the first 'The Fury' and ...

    3 star(s)

    shows when she is slicing the potatoes, knitting and smashes the vase. Although Mrs Fletcher has arguments with her husband she likes to keep her problems private and she does this by not letting Mrs Sykes know how she feels, 'she felt a strong desire to abuse him in her talk, but pride held her tongue.'

  2. William Wycherley`s "The Country Wife".

    which is true, even if it makes him appear more selfless than he is. Horner even risks his life later on to protect Mrs.

  1. The Tall Woman and Her Short Husband - During the course of this short ...

    This is rather unconventional but practical in their case. Once again we find their situation comical. We are told in the story that all the people who are living at "Unity Mansions" laugh and jeer at the couple. Instead of retaliating they just take it in their stride.

  2. Discuss the main themes of the story, in Charlotte Perkins Gilman's

    Another reason she can't argue with him was because he is a man. Men were regarded as socially superior up until after the First World War and to some extent they are still regarded in this light today. She feels afraid of her husband not only because he's a man

  1. With reference to at least two pre-twentieth century stories, describe the portrayal of women.

    After the death of the mother shortly after giving birth to her and William Preston's first child, the only other reference to women was that of Aunt Fanny. She takes the position of the mother within the household. I think that this, in itself, shows how women were portrayed and to some extent, are still portrayed.

  2. In the two stories I am studying; 'Her Turn' by D. H. Lawrence and ...

    She married Shadrach as she is socially ambitious. She regards herself as particularly high up in the social hierarchy of Havenpool Town and doesn't want her friend to triumph over her. Mrs Radford, on the other hand, quite obviously believes that she is entitled to a percentage of Mr Radford's income.

  1. In this essay I am examining the three short stories "Turned" written by Charlotte ...

    Mrs. Marroner analysed the problem with her intellectual wisdom. 'As the older, wiser woman forced herself to understand and extenuate the girl's misdeed and foresee her ruined future, a new feeling arose in her heart, strong, clear, and overmastering: a measureless condemnation for the man who had done this thing'.

  2. How do Thomas Hardy and D.H. Lawrence portray relationships between men and women in ...

    She knows her place in the relationship and has his dinner prepared for him when he returns home. He 'never comes in drunk' and so is always predictable around her. He doesn't want to be seen by her in that state.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work