• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9

Compare and Contrast The Story Of An Hour by K. Chopin and the Red Room by H.G. Wells

Extracts from this document...


Compare and Contrast The Story Of An Hour by K. Chopin and the Red Room by H.G. Wells I have read two short stories from the nineteenth century which both contain tension and suspense. They both lead up to a sense of the unexpected at the end however it is achieved in different ways that they are told. The Story Of An Hour is the shorter of the two. The story starts suddenly and a tragedy is introduced immediately. The opening paragraph is very short as it is only one sentence but a lot of information is given to the reader. It is written in third-person narrative, which shows that the reader will be able to know things that other characters don't. Two characters are brought into the story, Mrs Mallard and her husband. We are also told that her husband had died and that she has been suffering with 'heart trouble', 'Mrs Mallard was afflicted with heart trouble, great care was taken to break to her as gently as possible the news of her husband's death'. This builds up the tension and suspense and makes the reader think that something is going to happen to her or that she could have more trouble following his death. The reader is drawn into the story as the tragedy shows that there could be sadness or misery. The detailed opening encourages images and ideas of how the story is going to progress, making the reader feel that a tragedy is to follow. The Story Of An Hour is set in Mrs Mallard's house and as it continues the setting is moved to her room for a large section of the story. At the beginning, the setting is not obvious as the action starts suddenly without an explanation as to where the characters are. However in the third paragraph she runs up to her room, this indicates that she could be in her own house, alternatively she could be staying in a hotel or lodging in a house belonging to someone else. ...read more.


They help the reader to gain understanding of Mr and Mrs Mallard, they don't play important parts in the main body of the story but they are essential in Mrs Mallard's death. The story is told in third-person narrative, which means we are observing the action from outside the story. The narrator gives us an important insight to the story so that we know things that other characters don't, she involve us closely so that we know exactly what the character is feeling, we stay in the room with her and we know more than those outside. The narrator's language is very descriptive throughout, ' Her pulses beat fast and the coursing blood warmed and relaxed every inch of her body', which helps to set the scene of the story and understand the characters. The story ends as suddenly as it started. Mrs Mallard leaves her room after much persuasion by her sister, Josephine, and they both descended the stairs, she is now back to reality, in a world where such happiness can't last. She is described as a 'goddess of victory', showing a sense of surreal happiness that is too good to be true. The next paragraph begins with, 'Someone was opening the front door with a latchkey.' The short sentence builds tension and is evidence that only people that live in the house have keys, creating uncertainty and tension, which makes the reader think that it is Mrs Mallard's husband but previously we were told that he had died. Brently Mallard entered the house and was amazed to hear Josephine scream and see Richards try to hide him from his wife to stop her from getting a shock. Richards was too late and the doctors said she died of 'heart disease-of joy that kills'. The doctors thought that she was so overjoyed to see her husband that it was too much for her and the joy killed her. ...read more.


The mood of the story alters because the narrator changes from being confident and fearless to being panicky and fearful while in the room. The ending to The Red Room is unexpected as is the ending to The Story Of An Hour. However, the ending to The Story Of An Hour is only understood by the reader and the narrator, whereas the ending to The Red Room is known and understood by all of the characters. Both characters come to a sense of realisation in their rooms but in 'The Story Of An Hour' only the reader knows this. The main character is also the narrator; this is different to The Story Of An Hour as it is written in first-person narrative so the character is telling us the story. The narrator is an important part in this story as well as the other story I read as they both allow us to get inside the characters thoughts and feelings even though they are written differently. The narrator in The Red Room has a particular attitude towards the other characters; he exaggerates their appearance to make them sound more grotesque which give a biased view of them. The narrator in The Story Of An Hour does not express their views on the characters or events. The other characters are not named, there is a 'man with the withered arm', 'the old woman' who had 'her pale eyes wide open' and 'a second old man' who was 'more bent, more wrinkled', 'more aged' and had a shade over his eye. The narrator presents these characters to be mysterious and disturbing, such features add to the sense of mystery. These characters try to give him advice but he acts against it. After reading The Red Room, I prefer The Story Of An Hour because, although The Red Room is more surreal and mysterious, The Story Of An Hour has a more satisfying ending. The Red Room is much more descriptive and H.G Wells exaggerates the characters and the setting to add to the tension. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE H.G. Wells section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE H.G. Wells essays

  1. knowing and not knowing humour and iriony in H.G Wells' short stories

    He doesn't try to make the tale like an everyday ghost story by making it sound dramatic; it is definitely what you wouldn't expect it to be. Then, as soon as Clayton has the reader believing him, you begin to doubt him because he starts to forget he is telling a ghost story and makes it humorous.

  2. The Red Room and The Monkey's Paw(Compare and Contrast)

    This describes the mood and the weather all in one line. The quote is from Mary Shelley's "Frankenstein" novel. Authors use pathetic fallacy in ghost stories to make the reader understand the weather and the character's emotions. If in a story the castle was terrifying then the weather outside would be raining and thunder and lightning would commence.

  1. Discuss the ways in which H.G Wells creates tension and drama in The Red ...

    We worry for the narrator. The emotions of the narrator vary from being fearless and calm to being panicky so we realise that the narrator has managed to become scared. When he wakes up he doesn't remember what happened, 'I could not recollect', meaning that the experience was so bad that he couldn't remember what had happened.

  2. To what extent is ' The Red Room' a typical ghost story?

    The custodians have their own reason for believing the room to be haunted. The story ends with a reference to " his house of sin." The servants believe that the evil action of the Duke, " To put such a curse upon a woman," means that the house will be eternally haunted.

  1. Short Story discussion of

    This was almost seen as a test by the Sergeant, he was testing the White family that if they had become very emotionally involved to this paw and if they would save it from the burning fire and the Sergeant succeeded in doing this.

  2. Compare 'The Red Room' by H G Wells with 'Farthing House' by Susan Hill ...

    In 'Farthing House', there is repetition of the words that describe the narrator's emotions. For example, 'melancholy... distressed...anxious... wretched... inconsolably sad.' These all contrast with 'warm... comfortable.' She feels warm and comfortable when she is not in Cedar Room; when she can take her 'mind off' the fear, as does also by reading a book whilst in the room.

  1. The two short stories,” The Red Room,” and,”The Phantom coach,” create an atmosphere and ...

    The "Phantom Coach" crashes, and the conclusion is revealed, the main character was a passenger in the previous coach accident. This story line keeps the reader's attention, because it uses varied sentence lengths in suspense parts of the story, also the use of dramatic irony creates suspense.

  2. Is 'The Red Room' by H.G Wells a good ghost story?

    of 'the young duke' and 'a timid wife' are on his mind and frighten him. When he reaches the room he is still frightened and urges himself to stay awake to 'reassure himself nothing is there' and he talks to himself showing a side of craziness.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work