• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the three characters showing how their personalities and lives are similar and how they are different - How do the lives of all three women differ from those of women today?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Both 'The Withered Arm' and 'The Distracted Preacher' have important female characters- Rhoda, Gertrude and Lizzy. Compare and contrast the three characters showing how their personalities and lives are similar and how they are different. How do the lives of all three women differ from those of women today? 'The Withered Arm' is a story about a woman whose arm becomes withered. She believes that a woman in the village has inflicted this injury upon her, and she spends all her time trying to find a cure using whatever methods she can. 'The Distracted Preacher' is about a preacher who lodges in a woman's house. They fall in love, but things become complicated when he discovers she is involved with smuggling. The three women all have very distinctive lives and take up different roles in each of the stories. Rhoda is a milkmaid who has a son, by her employer, Farmer Lodge, but they are no longer together. She lives a very secluded life, and rarely talks to anyone but her son. Gertrude is quite young, very pretty, and married to Farmer Lodge, although she knows nothing of his previous relationship with Rhoda or of their son. She is very kind hearted, 'She gives away things to other folks in the meads' (p.9) Lizzy has no real trade, although she takes in lodgers, her main source of income is smuggling, she uses this money, to support her and her mother. ...read more.

Middle

For instance Gertrude and Lizzy are both very beautiful, Gertrude has a, 'face as comely as a live doll's' , 'her mouth is very nice and red; and when she smiles her teeth show white.' , 'She's lovely' (p.5,6). Lizzy is an, 'extremely well made young woman' , she has 'a beautiful forehead' , and, 'eyes that warmed him before he knew it' (p.88-9). Whereas Rhoda is just described as, 'a thin fading woman of thirty' (p.1). They are all however in different positions, as far as marital status is concerned. Rhoda isn't married, but had at one time had some sort of relationship with Farmer Lodge, we know this because she has a son by him. Gertrude is married to Farmer Lodge, but has no children, and Lizzy, isn't married, but has had at least two husbands previously, she does however have Mr Stockdale as her lover, and they do eventually get married. They are all similar, in that they are all independent, however if you look more closely you will see that they have all achieved different levels of independence. Rhoda, in my opinion is the least independent because, although she lives on her own and is raising a son by herself, she hasn't chosen to be that way, and only copes with that because she has to. ...read more.

Conclusion

Lizzy judging by her character would probably have a job other than the smuggling, which she would probably have given up, because of the stricter laws now. I feel quite differently about Lizzy compared to the other two women. I feel that she is altogether not a particularly nice person. She leads Stockdale on, to believe that they were going to get married, even though she had no intention of giving up smuggling. If she had really loved him, she would know he was too good and honest to give up his profession for a life of smuggling. Although they did get married in the end, it was only because she was forced to give up smuggling, 'the trade is gone to nothing. We were hunted down like rats.' (p.148). I feel fairly indifferent towards Rhoda and Gertrude, as although I feel sympathetic towards both of their situations, Rhoda's exclusion from society, and Gertrude's arm. Rhoda vividly pictured inflicting a wound on someone, which appeared to have some effect, even though she had never met her and her only reason being jealousy. Gertrude, in a desperate attempt to cure her arm, doesn't care who has to die to make her better, '"O Lord, hang some guilty or innocent person soon!"' (p.23). Although these acts were extremely selfish, both these incidents involved very desperate women, and in their positions you can't tell what you would do or feel. For these reasons I am very sympathetic towards them. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Thomas Hardy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Thomas Hardy essays

  1. In Which way are women presented in a variety of pre 1914 stories.

    "Eyes were sunken" "Skin was waxy and hectic" The words used create an image of a sick man, who has obviously changed, which is created in the reader's mind. The author then goes on about the passionate love they had, has gone for Dorothea but not for Randall.

  2. Wessex Tales How the characters are effected

    Phyllis had a feeling something was going on. Phyllis had fallen in love with the Hussar but forced herself not to fall in love with him so she couldn't be disloyal to Humphrey. Phyllis carries on meeting the Hussar until one day her heart is broken because Humphrey comes back and tells her he is married.

  1. Choose Three Stories from the Collection and Comment on How They Illustrate the Position ...

    They never spoke but the narrator thought this woman "hated her." On the day the narrator was due to leave a party was organized for everyone in the village, the one rose for two hundred miles around had been promised to the other woman.

  2. Compare and Contrast “Piano” and “At Castle Boterel”

    The reader can see that Hardy's life is coming to an end. My final contrast is that in both poems the concluding stanzas leave the reader with the idea and impression that time cannot be reversed and once it has past it is lost forever.

  1. Compare and Contrast a selection of Thomas Hardy's Poetry

    As the third stanza opens, we sense the change in tone. Hardy brings us into the world of him and his 'Faithful Phantom' Emma, where they now travel to, back to where they used to go. This is a comparison with the 'Domicilium' of the past setting of the garden and beyond.

  2. How does Hardy elicit sympathy for the three main characters?

    (Page 19) She needed his help and support but still he ignored her. This is cruel as he marries her and then ignores her. It is wrong. Hardy portrays him to be bitter and heartless and therefore he receives no sympathy what so ever.

  1. 'How did authors show that women were treated differently in the Nineteenth Century?'

    and refuse his marriage proposal at the end, all three of them accept his instructions willingly to begin with and so follow the stereotypical standards of women. This shows that generally women would follow the rules of society and most of them let themselves become passive to men.

  2. Comparison of three nineteenth century short stories.

    Throughout Gilman's life she worked for the trade union movement, for the cause of women's suffrage and for more equal treatment of men and women in all aspects of their home and working lives. You can see this is in her writing as she tries to show the reader that

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work